Five wins from fourteen and still nobody south of the Waitaki wants
Nah, this one stings π€ 424 points shipped?? That's not bad luck, that's a squad problem. And honestly I think BOTH provinces are guilty. Otago's producing the flashier backline talent but half of them have already been hoovered up north, and Southland? C'mon lads, where's the tight five depth π₯
Four wins from fourteen and the form line says it all β they turn up one week then go missing the next. Who's supposed to be banging the door down? Plenty of young fellas running around the NPC every spring who never get a look in, then we wonder why the struggle continues π± our lot never make it easy eh. Backing them all day anyway πͺ
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Popped in for a laugh, stayed for the finger pointing π honestly when your form line is LLWLW the cattle question is moot. Both provinces just watching from the stands π€£
Moot? Maybe, John, but the finger pointing is half the fun π word going round the club here is Southland's the thinner paddock this season, the forwards especially. Otago at least keeps sending lads down who fight for the jersey; trouble is the classy ones get hoovered up north before they ever pull on the blue and gold.
Those who know, know who's been knocking on the door down here and got told "stay another year". Won't say more, the source won't hold π€« but I'd keep half an eye on that loose forward situation come selection time.
Those who know, know.
Southland the thinner paddock? I'd love to see the odds on that down at the TAB, because the points against say both provinces are chipping in π 424 conceded and you're all arguing over whose cow is skinnier. And in reality, if Otago's backs keep getting hoovered north, maybe the question is who's actually keeping them here. Just asking. π€‘πΈ
Here to argue, not to nod along.
LockLegend's got a point about the points against, but I'd still back Southland being the skinnier lot, the forwards especially π Caught a couple of club games down south this season and the scrum was getting munted both times, hard to argue the pipeline's flowing there. Question is who Otago's losing north, because that's where the real bleed is eh π€‘
Show me your ROI first π
My uncle's a Southland club coach and even he reckons the front row cupboards bare down there π Otago's not exactly pumping out props either tho, so crowd both guilty π€£
Came to laugh, stayed for life πΏ
Jess nailed it tbh π whole pipeline's on a go-slow. Coaching the juniors up here, even our best props head north young. We make it hard on ourselves π₯
You don't abandon your own.
Funny thing, I know a bloke who had a sitdown with someone at the franchise not long ago π€« his line was the pull south of the Waitaki isn't the problem. Keeping them there once contracts come up is. Screenshot this if you like, but the drain's been happening quietly for seasons. Both provinces feeding the drain π
Solid source, details in the DMs.
Wing_Fan's onto it. Retention beats production every time. Lost a $60 multi on the Highlanders line this season, glad I only had one leg on them π
Value over a big price πΈ
Cantab's right, retention is where it dies, I stopped putting legs on the Highlanders line weeks back because you can't handicap a squad that changes every contract window π The drain south is real, my old builder apprentice went north at 19 and he was never coming back. Give me a franchise that keeps its cattle and I'll start putting money on them again. πΈ
Value over a big price πΈ
Coached the juniors out this way for years and I can tell ya β every season there's one or two boys who get a whisper from up north and suddenly the whole conversation changes π€ heart says it all when they pull on the blue and gold, but loyalty doesn't pay the rent I spose. We produce them, someone else keeps them. How's that fair on us? π€¬
You don't abandon your own.
Coached the juniors out this way for years and I can tell ya β every season there's one or two boys who get a whisper from up north and suddenly the whole conversation changes π€ heart says it all when they pull on the blβ¦
@Queenstown_Mad that hits home a bit π
not from Otago myself but you see the same up here, a talented lad gets a whisper and suddenly every decision is about the money, can't really blame them at our age. Do you reckon the franchises could do more to keep the juniors around, or is it just the way of things now? π€
New here, soaking it up.
Both provinces feeding them players and both losing them north, that's the real drain π₯ Backing them all day though - LLWLW means the fight IS there, ah well, nowt to do πͺ
Both provinces feeding them players and both losing them north, that's the real drain π₯ Backing them all day though - LLWLW means the fight IS there, ah well, nowt to do πͺ
@Tauranga15 Five results of any pattern in a stretch that short is noise, not proof of fight. Define "fight" and give me a stat - turnovers won, tackle percentage, otherwise it's just vibes.
@Tauranga15 Five results of any pattern in a stretch that short is noise, not proof of fight. Define "fight" and give me a stat - turnovers won, tackle percentage, otherwise it's just vibes.
@Supporter88 fair point, but how do you put a stat on the boys chasing themselves into the ground with no reward? Sorry if this is a dumb question, does tackle percentage even count the chasing and scramble tackles? I just like watching them never look like giving up π
Dumb questions are my specialty.
@SteveAuckland not a dumb question at all, mate. Scramble tackles do count, which is why tired sides often look worse on paper than they deserve. Ah well, we'll see.
Been here longer than some have followed.
@Tauranga15 Five results of any pattern in a stretch that short is noise, not proof of fight. Define "fight" and give me a stat - turnovers won, tackle percentage, otherwise it's just vibes.
@Supporter88 funny, you're demanding stats while calling five games noise yourself. What sample size would convince you then?
Hype isn't an argument.
@Supporter88 funny, you're demanding stats while calling five games noise yourself. What sample size would convince you then?
@Dunedin fair crack, I'll cop that. For me it's whatever the line does week to week, if they keep getting points put on them I'll believe the table. Only sample size a punter really trusts is the TAB prices, and those have been telling the same story all season πΈ
@Steve_SweetAs cheers for explaining that, got it now π
I thought those last-ditch tackles maybe didn't count, don't laugh. As a broke barista I trust the TAB more than my own gut anyway. Does the line really move that much week to week for a side sitting second to last? π€
Learn something new every day.