Forget the halves debate, this club's real problem is we've never
Ha, watching you lot romanticise 2015 like the trophy papered over everything π That side had mongrel because Nasi Manu and the Tuilagi brothers went hunting at every breakdown - since then we've been playing touch footy with a smile. Honest question though: when exactly did being "nice" last win anything at Forsyth Barr? Remind me of your ROI on nostalgia π
Show me your ROI first π
Ha, watching you lot romanticise 2015 like the trophy papered over everything π That side had mongrel because Nasi Manu and the Tuilagi brothers went hunting at every breakdown - since then we've been playing touch footyβ¦
Nostalgia's doing a lot of lifting there, mate. Manu and the Tuilagis carried that edge, sure, but plenty of sides since have been just as willing at the breakdown, we just didn't have the results to dress it up as grit. Mongrel without a trophy suddenly reads like touch footy, funny how that works.
Nah Supporter88, watch the 2015 semi again and tell me we've been the same since π€ Manu hitting rucks like he owed money, Elliot Dixon running over the top of blokes, we scared teams that year. These days? We get cleaned out at our OWN breakdown and the lads just have a yarn with the ref. Seriously, when did we last put a side off their game at Forsyth Barr? π±
I coached juniors down here for years and you can spot the difference a mile off, southern boys used to relish the dark nights and the wet turf, seemed to LOVE the grind. Now it's all structured and polite tbh. Bring the mongrel back and the results follow, you just know it πͺπ₯
You don't abandon your own.
Went back through my own ruck tallies from that season and Queenstown_Mad has the right of it. Manu was hitting double the cleanouts per match of anyone we've had since, and the whole pack fed off that. Sample size is small by 2025 standards, but the tape agrees: we've been first to the ball less and polite about it more. I could be wrong, but you don't win a title on niceness. π
Context beats a bare stat.
Been going to Forsyth Barr since it opened and I'll tell you straight, I used to put my hard-earned on us winning the collision zone most weeks back then, now I wouldn't touch us on the line at home. Manu flying into rucks was worth a few points a game easy, and I remember sides like the Chiefs arriving in Dunedin looking nervous. That edge paid my TAB more than once, and it's been missing ever since π
Mint thread this π₯ but half of you are remembering 2015 through beer goggles tbh β Manu was a machine, yeah, but I reckon the real mongrel left with every bloke who came up through the Southland club scene and got poached. Coach the juniors out here and you can SEE the gap. Ah well, nowt to do but keep turning up at Forsyth Barr through thick and thin πͺπ₯
In the stands since I was a kid.
Beer goggles? Mate I had $50 on us at the line every home week that season and cashed more often than not, my TAB slips remember it better than your memory does π Tryline's got half a point on the poaching but Manu bashing rucks wasn't Southland club development, that was just hunger - and we've signed enough southern boys since who don't hit a single cleanout like he did πΈ
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
Tryline's closest to it, I reckon, though I'd want to see the provincial pathways data before we all nod along. What I'll grant is this: watching the Bunnings NPC on a Saturday arvo, the southern provinces keep producing those hard-nosed loose forwards and locks, and they seem to end up wearing other franchises' jumpers by the time they're 22. Whether that's poaching or just our recruitment being slow, I'd need someone with actual access to confirm, happy to be shown the list of where our academy lads ended up, condition on it being sourced and not pub memory.
Same goes for the ruck tallies, Rob. Manu clearing double anyone since sounds right to my eye watching from the terraces, but "my own tallies" is still one bloke with a notepad. I'll believe it when I see it matched against official match data.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Tryline's spot on imo, the poaching gutted us π
I'm still learning all this but my old man reckons the mongrel died when the Southland boys stopped staying home. Thanks for explaining it properly π
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Hunger? Sure thing, mate π And in reality we've been paying soft men soft money to miss soft tackles. Southland keeps growing them, we keep buying nice ones instead π€‘
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Soft money? Nah mate, you just know the kids coming thru Southland would run through a brick wall for the jersey πͺ Question is why we keep looking elsewhere, aye. Ah well, nowt to do π₯
Nah, both halves of this argument are right and that's what does my head in π
Watched that 2015 side from the terraces, we had Nasi Manu smashing rucks like his life depended on it. You just knew every loose ball was gonna be a war. Now? We sign nice lads who smile at the ref while our breakdown gets mown π₯
Tauranga15 is onto something tho, Southland keeps feeding us that hard-nosed stock and we keep looking elsewhere π€¬ Anyway, pub before the next home game at Forsyth Barr, first round's on me and we settle this properly π»πͺ CHURR THE HIGHLANDERS π
You don't abandon your own.
@Tauranga15 word going round the lower grades down south is exactly that, kids who'd walk over hot coals for the jersey, and the scouts keep driving straight past π why that is, I'll let you work out. Had a bloke at the β¦
@MaulTragic that 2015 side cost me a few multis early in the season, then paid my bar tab by June once the market caught up π
you're spot on though, they treated every ruck like it owed them money. Now I watch and can't find a single leg worth putting in the odd try scorer leg, let alone the rest.
Nah, both halves of this argument are right and that's what does my head in π
Watched that 2015 side from the terraces, we had Nasi Manu smashing rucks like his life depended on it. You just knew every loose ball was gonβ¦
@MaulTragic that 2015 pack hits me right in the feels tbh π’ everyone hunted that loose ball, now we wait for someone else to clean it. where's that mindset coming from these days? juniors down here still smash everything, something goes missing between colts and the big jersey π€¬
One love, one side β€οΈ
@MaulTragic that 2015 pack hits me right in the feels tbh π’ everyone hunted that loose ball, now we wait for someone else to clean it. where's that mindset coming from these days? juniors down here still smash everythingβ¦
@Metric_Lab this actually makes sense to me, watched the colts down here and they're all scraps and chase, then something changes by the time they get the big jersey π€ Maybe it's fear of making a mistake at that level? Don't laugh if that's a dumb theory, still learning this stuff π
π
New here, soaking it up.
@RobbedAgainNightmare that theory makes sense to me honestly π
watched a mates colts game in Timaru and they chased everything, no fear at all. Maybe it's pressure once it's a job?
Learn something new every day.
Soft money? Nah mate, you just know the kids coming thru Southland would run through a brick wall for the jersey πͺ Question is why we keep looking elsewhere, aye. Ah well, nowt to do π₯
@Tauranga15 word going round the lower grades down south is exactly that, kids who'd walk over hot coals for the jersey, and the scouts keep driving straight past π why that is, I'll let you work out. Had a bloke at the club mention a name or two worth keeping an ear on, and mate, when you hear it you'll know why some of us are quietly confident. You'll all find out soon π€«
@Metric_Lab this actually makes sense to me, watched the colts down here and they're all scraps and chase, then something changes by the time they get the big jersey π€ Maybe it's fear of making a mistake at that level? Dβ¦
Not a dumb theory at all mate, probably the smartest post in this thread π they get coached into playing scared the moment it becomes a job. Sure thing, mate, blame fear all you like π
Show me your ROI first π