Forget the imports, our best halves pairing is already sitting in
Saw the academy boys at McGillivray Oval myself and honestly the senior backline looked like they were training in slow motion next to them. If Donaldson isn't glancing over his shoulder after those trials he's not watching the same footy we are. The imports can pack their bags for all I care. The future's already in the building 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Trials are trials, mate, academy kids flying against blokes pacing themselves in February means nothing. Show me that form against proper Super Rugby defensive lines.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Seriously? pace themselves in Feb? 😂 those kids were putting SENIORS on their backs at McGillivray. You were there or just reading scores mate? backing the academy all day 💪🔥
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Watching from the hill at McGillivray I'd side with the sceptic here, honestly. I could be wrong, but trial scoring against a senior backline in mid-February tells us almost nothing until we see it against real Super Rugby defensive lines. Small sample though, and I'll keep my own table running through round five before crowning anyone.
Context beats a bare stat.
Don't laugh but I only started following properly a couple seasons back 😅 still, even I remember people writing off young halves before, then they carve up the derby sides. Go easy on me, could be the same again? 🙏
Was at McGillivray too and nah Rob, those kids were flying, "pacing themselves" is what blokes say when the young fellas make 'em look slow 😂🔥 ah well, nowt to do
In the stands since I was a kid.
JoshBeliever, don't sell yourself short - you've actually landed on something real there.
Rob, I take the point about February trials being a messy sample, I do. But I've kept my own numbers through pre-season for years and here's the nuance: the academy halves weren't just scoring, they were doing it against the same defensive shape the senior backline keeps failing to crack. That's a control group sitting right in front of us. And it's happened every trial so far, which is more than one good arvo at McGillivray. Remember when everyone wrote off a certain young five-eighth before he carved up the derby sides? Josh remembers it too, apparently. If Donaldson's watching those sessions from inside the squad, he'd be worrying more than any of us on this thread. Small sample though. I'll concede that much once we see them against a proper Super Rugby line.
Numbers > vibes.
Rob's got a point, though, remember the same smoke around academy flyhalves in Bunnings NPC pre-seasons that evaporated by round six. I want to see the kids handle actual contact before crowning anyone.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Scrum10 makes the point I was going to make, so I'll just add the caveat I keep in my own notes: February trials are a messy sample no matter how good it looks live. I was at McGillivray that afternoon too, seven middies deep in the sun, and the academy halves did look a class above - but I've kept my own trial-by-trial tables long enough to know a rookie carving up a tired second-string pack in a warm-up tells you less than people want it to.
That said, JoshBeliever's basically right on the history: young halves written off in pre-season who then dominated derbies by round six. I could be wrong, but the difference this time is the gap looked structural, not just a hot afternoon. Contact is the real exam, though. First proper Super Rugby Pacific hit out, when a clockwise flanker is hunting you for real, that's when we find out whether it's smoke or the real thing. Happy to wait for that before crowning anyone, but my money's tilted the kids' way.
Someone at TAB might be giving odds on Donaldson starting round one, take the line and laugh all the way to the bank 🤡💸 the kids were that good, Rob
Any stat can be bent.
Reckon Scrum10's got a point tho, I've seen plenty of Feb heroes fold by round six 😅 But the academy boys looked sharp at McGillivray Oval, gotta admit 🔥
One love, one side ❤️
Reckon Scrum10's got a point tho, I've seen plenty of Feb heroes fold by round six 😅 But the academy boys looked sharp at McGillivray Oval, gotta admit 🔥
@ClassicGuy round six folding is exactly the trap, Feb footy flatters kids every year and I've paid for it. Threw a multi together off a trial performance a few seasons back, three legs, none of them landed. Never again at more than coffee money.
That said, what I saw at McGillivray wasn't the usual trial mirage, they were running onto a proper Super-level defence and still making it look easy, which is the bit that makes me think the value's actually there rather than just vibes. I'd still keep the punt small, SweetAsNZ and HarryReds are right about the NZ$5 cap on that Donaldson market, but the line will move once the team sheets drop, mark it. Question is whether the coach is brave enough to start them or just benches them and breaks everyone's ticket anyway 😄🍺
Value over a big price 💸
Fair push back from you both, but I've seen enough Feb triallists flop to know the difference, these academy kids weren't beating slow seniors, they were carving up a backline that's meant to be Super Rugby standard, and anyone holding a bet on Donaldson starting round one should check the line movement already 💸 By round six we'll know, but I'd rather back the form in front of my own eyes at McGillivray than hype from three seasons ago.
Laughed at FrontRow's TAB line joke, but honestly I'd only put NZ$5 on that market max 😄 Trials are autobiographies of nothing, I've thrown money away on Feb form before. Still, kids carving up a full-time backline is worth more than a punt on vibes. Guess the real payout comes when round one team gets named 🔥
Value over a big price 💸
Tried a Feb form multi once in town, kids tore it up in the trial then didn't land a single leg by round four. NZ$5 max on Donaldson starting, agreed 😄
@HarryReds your multi story is the exact reason I keep a spreadsheet of Feb form versus round five reality, and the hit rate is ugly. Depends how you count it too, a trial against tiring midweek legs reads very differently to a full强度的 preseason camp, context matters. I'd cap it at NZ$5 as well, though if Donaldson is genuinely getting outplayed at training the TAB line will move before any of us hear it officially.
Do the math before you argue.