Tin Hearth
22 Nov, 7:47 pm Log in Sign up
Highlanders

Forget the imports, our best Highlanders side of the decade is the

club debate Highlanders Supporters Highlanders 6 posts ·21 views ·Posted: 16 Nov 2026, 6:15 pm ·Updated: 18 Nov 2026, 9:39 am
BE BenDunedin Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 18 posts 16 Nov 2026, 6:15 pm
Chucking the imports angle out there, but honestly the 2015 lot only became gods because we let the Southland nearly-men have one final swing. Half those legends were fringe guys anywhere else and suddenly they're immortal because Dunedin cold plus one last crack turned them into something. Nasi Manu, Marty Banks, that whole crew. Great bunch, loved the title night as much as anyone, but romanticising it as some pure Otago academy product is a stretch. I'd take a proper homegrown side built from the door of Forsyth Barr over a nostalgia XI any day. And in reality? Most of you would too if you were honest. Sure thing, mate, tell me the 2015 side was all local blood and I'll tell you why Southland clubs still bring it up at the pub 🤡😏
It's a lottery, not sport.
Reply Quote
BenDunedin wrote:
Chucking the imports angle out there, but honestly the 2015 lot only became gods because we let the Southland nearly-men have one final swing. Half those legends were fringe guys anywhere else and suddenly they're immort…
SU Supporter88 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 339 posts 16 Nov 2026, 9:49 pm
"Nearly-men"? That 2015 side beat the Crusaders in the final in Wellington, mate. Fringe guys don't win knockout games against that lot, the Dunedin cold or otherwise.
Reply Quote
AU Auckland_Mate Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 10 posts 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am
Nah Ben, that final in Wellington wasn't charity work, we outplayed the Crusaders when it counted 😤 Southland boys or not they earned every bit of it. But tbh I do love a proper Otago-only side, watch the juniors up here and you can see that Dunedin grit coming through 💪
In the stands since I was a kid.
Reply Quote
TI Tighthead Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 193 posts 17 Nov 2026, 7:25 pm
Watched that 2015 final again last week and the pattern holds every time, the blokes Ben calls fringe were making the tackles that won it in Wellington. A small sample though, one knockout run, so I get why he squints at it. Still, you beat the Crusaders in a final on their patch and that's the whole counter-argument right there.
Highlanders stadium
Numbers > vibes.
Reply Quote
SW SweetAs_Mad Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 784 posts 17 Nov 2026, 10:15 pm
Funny how the fringe blokes seem to make the big hits in every final I've sat through. Back in the amateur days at Eden Park the so-called nearly-men were always the ones bleeding for the jersey while the flash boys took the glory. Ben, laddie, one last crack is how most legends are made, that Wellington night proved it 😉
Reply Quote
NI NickBreakdown1982 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 283 posts 18 Nov 2026, 9:39 am
Flipping through my season tables the other night and this thread kept nagging at me. Depends how you count it, really. If a legend is someone who developed here, then half the 2015 lot only became household names wearing our strip, which muddies Ben's clean Otago story a fair bit. Tighthead's right that one knockout run is a thin sample, but Wellington was as close to a controlled test as you get, against the Crusaders at full strength, and the "fringe" blokes held up. Where I land, or rather where I refuse to land: the Southland contribution and the Dunedin development aren't rival explanations, they're stacked on top of each other. Dig a bit deeper into any of those careers and you find both. So I'm keeping the argument open, and enjoying it more than I probably should.
Context beats a bare stat.
Reply Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up — it's quick.