Tin Hearth
22 Nov, 7:33 pm Log in Sign up
Highlanders

Forget the old boys' club nostalgia

club debate Highlanders Supporters Highlanders 18 posts ·161 views ·Posted: 14 Sep 2026, 10:51 am ·Updated: 13 Nov 2026, 12:44 pm
NA Napier_Legend1980 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 457 posts 14 Sep 2026, 10:51 am
Half the moaners at the Captain Cook haven't actually watched this mob play, they just miss the days when a name on the team sheet made them feel important. Watch the loosies run defence and actually carry the ball for eighty minutes instead of strolling around on a rep reputation. The lads the club brought through have got more hunger than any marquee signing we'd blow $400k on, and deep down you all know it. Funny thing is the same blokes whinging now were the ones tipping us to leak fifty a game in pre-season 😏 remind me how those TAB multis went, fellas? 🤡 A big cheque buys a headline, not a season, I'd back two hungry Otago kids over one import every day of the week. 💸
Show me your ROI first 😏
Reply Quote
RO RotoruaLoyal Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 455 posts 14 Sep 2026, 11:39 am
Define "carry the ball for eighty minutes" before we make it a compliment, Napier. Volume isn't impact, and a loosie who makes six metres a pop against Moana or the Chiefs matters more than one who flings himself at everything. I watched plenty this season too, and the young Otago lads have earned their spot; my only gripes with the thread are the vague "everyone knows it" claims and that $400k figure doing the rounds with no source attached. Sounds good but I'll believe it when I see it over a full derby season.
Highlanders fans
Sample first, conclusions after.
Reply Quote
TA Tauranga15 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 402 posts 14 Sep 2026, 2:32 pm
Gotta say I'm with Napier on this one 🔥 these kids don't owe anyone a big name on the team sheet, they just play! Watched the loosies in the derby at Forsyth Barr and they ran themselves into the ground. You just know two promising Otago lads beat one marquee import every day of the week. NZ$400k on one bloke?? Nah mate, that's two young fellas learning their trade in the south AND money left over 💪🙌 Rotorua's got a point about impact tbh, volume isn't everything... but c'mon, these boys EARN their carries against Moana and the Chiefs, nobody hands them anything. Backing them all day. Ah well, nowt to do but watch 'em rip in Saturday 🔥
Reply Quote
RO RobFirstFive Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 735 posts 14 Sep 2026, 6:06 pm
Tauranga, I was at that derby too, and the lads covered every blade of grass - but RotoruaLoyal has a point I'd hedge with: 30 carries at four metres a pop reads worse in my table than 12 carries at six, and I could be wrong, but impact per touch is what actually bends a defensive line. Keep the NZ$400k for two Otago loosies, sure, provided we're picking the ones who make metres, not just noise. Small sample though, one derby tells you effort, it doesn't settle the argument. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Reply Quote
ST StandsGuyLoyal Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 542 posts 14 Sep 2026, 8:44 pm
Back when I was pulling on the boots for my club side we had a bloke everyone called a "marquee" who couldn't back up for two games straight, and we still talk about the season the skinny openside from our own grade ran the place. That's what I see in this lot now 💪 Rob, fair shout on impact per touch, honestly. But volume at four metres still tires defenders out - ask any tight five who's fronting up for the tenth carry of the same loosie 😅 You don't bend a line every touch, you break their will. Two Otago lads through the NPC grind, hungry as anything, for the price of one import? Backing them all day, through thick and thin 🔥
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Reply Quote
MA MaulTragic Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 264 posts 14 Sep 2026, 11:47 pm
RobFirstFive, mate, you'd pick the 12-carry flash over a lad who hits 30 rucks? 😱 If the marquee import is so good, name him 🔥💪
Highlanders goal celebration
You don't abandon your own.
Reply Quote
SW SweetAsNZ Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 1015 posts 15 Sep 2026, 12:00 am
MaulTragic, I'd back the 30-carry workhorse every time, watched that derby at Forsyth Barr and the loosies bent the line plenty without touching the ball. Same lesson as my TAB multi last week: the flashy leg let me down, the honest ones landed 😭 Marquee names are short odds that rarely pay.
Reply Quote
SC Scrum10 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 220 posts 15 Sep 2026, 12:05 am
MaulTragic, demanding a name for a player nobody signed is a bold move, that's the whole point, the $400k rumour died quietly and nobody's produced receipts for it since. Meanwhile the Otago loosies we could've had for that money are the ones actually stacking rucks at Forsyth Barr. I'll take the blokes with game time over a hypothetical marquee every time.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Reply Quote
DI DiehardFaithful Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 369 posts 15 Sep 2026, 3:23 am
SweetAsNZ nailed it tbh, the loosies did the dirt work all arvo at Forsyth Barr and got nowt for it 😤 Only caveat I'd add: keep one marquee slot for when a genuine game-breaker actually comes up, cos you just know some season you'll need that x-factor... ah well, nowt to do 🏉
In the stands since I was a kid.
Reply Quote
LO LockLegend Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 448 posts 15 Sep 2026, 4:41 am
Shearing a mob of sheep pays better odds than chasing that marquee rumour ever did 😂 $400k for a name on the sheet? SweetAs, your TAB multi logic is spot on, hard out.
Highlanders stadium
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Reply Quote
CH ChrisQueenstown Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 283 posts 15 Sep 2026, 4:47 am
Nah hold up lads, if these loosies are that good why's nobody else shouting about them 🤔 Half the blokes at the Captain Cook can't even name the pair you're counting, and one rumor dying quietly doesn't mean the $400k chasing was wrong, it means we got outbid or played it smart. Which is it? 😤 Still backs the squad btw, just saying don't crown em yet 🔥
Reply Quote
WE Wellington_15 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 394 posts 15 Sep 2026, 5:23 am
Sorry if this is a dumb question, still learning the squad depth stuff 😅 but ChrisQueenstown has a point that's stuck with me, if the Otago loosies were that obvious a bargain for NZ$400k, wouldn't someone else have grabbed them first? Maybe both things are true: we played it smart AND we got a bit lucky nobody else spotted them. Just saying I don't reckon we can settle which one over a pint at the Captain Cook 🤔
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Reply Quote
ChrisQueenstown wrote:
Nah hold up lads, if these loosies are that good why's nobody else shouting about them 🤔 Half the blokes at the Captain Cook can't even name the pair you're counting, and one rumor dying quietly doesn't mean the $400k ch…
CA CantabNZ857 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 176 posts 6 Oct 2026, 11:28 pm
@ChrisQueenstown the market's quiet on them because nobody rates loosies as headliners, same reason they never shorten a try scorer market for a blindside. Cheap at $400k if they do the dirt work week in week out. Value over a big price every time. The blokes at the Captain Cook can't name them but they couldn't name my last multi leg either and that still landed 🍀
Highlanders goal celebration
Value over a big price 💸
Reply Quote
Wellington_15 wrote:
Sorry if this is a dumb question, still learning the squad depth stuff 😅 but ChrisQueenstown has a point that's stuck with me, if the Otago loosies were that obvious a bargain for NZ$400k, wouldn't someone else have grab…
ST SteveAuckland Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 404 posts 6 Oct 2026, 11:29 pm
Not a dumb question at all, cheers for asking it 😅 maybe other unions just had their rosters sorted already? Can someone explain simply how the signing window works?
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Reply Quote
PA PaulOpenside Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 281 posts 27 Oct 2026, 12:20 am
The signing window works because bigger clubs can afford higher market valuations, which messes with the whole odds structure before you even see the names. Those quiet signings are just the lower prices that the clever punter looks for; i usually look at the mid-range line movement for value rather than the superstars. Still, you need to keep a sharp eye on the mid-week auctions, as the final roster decisions are often a last-minute move to shock the market. 💸
Highlanders team
Value over a big price 💸
Reply Quote
ChrisQueenstown wrote:
Nah hold up lads, if these loosies are that good why's nobody else shouting about them 🤔 Half the blokes at the Captain Cook can't even name the pair you're counting, and one rumor dying quietly doesn't mean the $400k ch…
KE KevFan Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 273 posts 6 Oct 2026, 11:29 pm
@ChrisQueenstown quiet recruitment is exactly how I want the club operating, the moment word gets out, the price moves, same as a TAB line before kickoff. $400k for dirt-work loosies is the kind of value I'd back every week. Whether we got outbid or walked away, either answer works for me; punters overpay for headlines, clubs shouldn't.
Bankroll discipline wins.
Reply Quote
DU Dunedin187 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 271 posts 5 Nov 2026, 6:13 pm
Nah quiet recruitment suits me fine tbh, all the noise from the bigger unions and we just get on with it 💪 $400k for loosies who do the dirt work every week, that's how you build a squad that fronts up in the derbies. Crowd at the pub before the Crusaders game never talks about signings anyway, they just want blokes who tackle 😤🔥
Reply Quote
Dunedin187 wrote:
Nah quiet recruitment suits me fine tbh, all the noise from the bigger unions and we just get on with it 💪 $400k for loosies who do the dirt work every week, that's how you build a squad that fronts up in the derbies. Cr…
QU Queenstown_Mad Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 523 posts 13 Nov 2026, 12:44 pm
@Dunedin187 spot on mate, dirt-work loosies win you derbies 🔥 coached a few lads like that at juniors level, no hype just graft 💪
Highlanders goal celebration
You don't abandon your own.
Reply Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up — it's quick.