Tin Hearth
22 Nov, 7:14 pm Log in Sign up
Highlanders

Forget the old boys' network

club debate Highlanders Supporters Highlanders 17 posts Β·2488 views Β·Posted: 11 Sep 2026, 11:50 am Β·Updated: 20 Nov 2026, 5:54 am
NA Napier_Legend1980 Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 457 posts 11 Sep 2026, 11:50 am
Form over reputation, every day of the week - half these old boys wouldn't crack a Super Rugby side on current form, let alone captain it 🀑 If they're trialling someone new at training I say good, pick whoever's actually leading the tackles. And remind me, what's the last captaincy pick that won us anything?😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Reply Quote
TR Tramping Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 272 posts 11 Sep 2026, 12:11 pm
"Leading the tackles", who's counting them, you? Training trials mean nothing until someone fronts a real game. I'll believe it when I see it.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Reply Quote
ST StandsGuyLoyal Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 542 posts 11 Sep 2026, 4:12 pm
Tramping mate, how do you think form gets noticed? Training's exactly where the coaches see who's Fronting up πŸ’ͺ backing whoever's grinding, reputation can sit down πŸ”₯πŸ™Œ
Highlanders team
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Reply Quote
RO RobFirstFive Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 734 posts 11 Sep 2026, 6:58 pm
Both of you have a point, honestly, but I'd side with StandsGuyLoyal here with one caveat. I keep my own notes through the season, and the nuance is this: training form and match form measure two different things, one shows you who's sharp at contact, the other shows who holds the group together when the game's gone sideways at 60 minutes. I could be wrong, but I'd want the trial skipper to get at least a couple of real outings before the coach locks anything in. Small sample though, so nobody on George Street should be declaring the answer yet. The tackle counts matter, sure. Depends how you count them too. But captaincy is decided more in those scrappy away quarters than at training. Give the trial a proper run, judge it on the tape.
Context beats a bare stat.
Reply Quote
SW SweetAsNZ Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 1014 posts 11 Sep 2026, 9:50 pm
Back in 2015 the armband went on form and we lifted the whole thing, reputations got us nowhere before that. Rob's right though, match day is where a skipper earns it, that's when I'd put my NZ$50 down πŸ’Έ
Reply Quote
QU Queenstown51 Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 483 posts 11 Sep 2026, 10:25 pm
2015 worked because the incumbents were dropped, not just overlooked. Coaches picking on form means picking against mates, I'll believe it when I see it at Forsyth Barr.
Hype isn't an argument.
Reply Quote
PA PaulOpenside Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 281 posts 12 Sep 2026, 2:16 am
Queenstown51's got a point but I'll still throw my lot in with SweetAsNZ on this one, I had the 2015 season baked into a multi that actually landed, so that armband call bought me a decent payout πŸ”₯ My caveat: form captain only works if the line at the TAB moves with the team picking up, and I'll happily put my NZ$50 next to theirs when it does. Whoever's trialling the skipper role better earn it on match day, not just at training 😭🍺
Highlanders fans
Value over a big price πŸ’Έ
Reply Quote
PaulOpenside wrote:
Queenstown51's got a point but I'll still throw my lot in with SweetAsNZ on this one, I had the 2015 season baked into a multi that actually landed, so that armband call bought me a decent payout πŸ”₯ My caveat: form captai…
DI DiehardFaithful Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 369 posts 12 Oct 2026, 4:41 pm
@PaulOpenside lad you're backing a call cos it paid out once πŸ˜‚ nah, captain picks itself if the bloke's training the house down... rest of us saw the 2015 lesson too ah well, nowt to do but wait and see πŸ”₯
In the stands since I was a kid.
Reply Quote
SC ScrumKiwi Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 241 posts 12 Sep 2026, 3:06 am
SweetAsNZ dropping NZ$50 like it's a prophecy πŸ˜‚ everyone's suddenly a punter when the TAB line hasn't even moved yet. Here's mine: reputation captains go quiet when the scrum's creaking at 60 minutes, form captains talk. Watch whoever's barking at the tight five in those trials, that's your man 🀑 laughable really.
Show me your ROI first 😏
Reply Quote
CL ClassicGuy Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 286 posts 12 Sep 2026, 4:11 am
Coached enough juniors to know the loudest bloke ain't always the best skipper πŸ”₯ form talk is easy in a pub on George Street, harder when the scrum's folding at 60 mins like ScrumKiwi says. If the coaches are trialling someone at training I'll back whoever earns it, reputation or not tbh. Ah well, nowt to do till they name him πŸ’ͺ
One love, one side ❀️
Reply Quote
DiehardFaithful wrote:
@PaulOpenside lad you're backing a call cos it paid out once πŸ˜‚ nah, captain picks itself if the bloke's training the house down... rest of us saw the 2015 lesson too ah well, nowt to do but wait and see πŸ”₯
LO LockLegend Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 448 posts 12 Oct 2026, 4:41 pm
@DiehardFaithful so landing one multi means the armband call was genius now? πŸ˜‚ and in reality, did Paul even pick the captain or just ride a multi someone else built? Genuine question mate, cos I've seen plenty of punters confuse a payout with a read on the team 🀑
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Reply Quote
DiehardFaithful wrote:
@PaulOpenside lad you're backing a call cos it paid out once πŸ˜‚ nah, captain picks itself if the bloke's training the house down... rest of us saw the 2015 lesson too ah well, nowt to do but wait and see πŸ”₯
SC Scrum10 Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 220 posts 12 Oct 2026, 4:41 pm
@DiehardFaithful "the 2015 lesson", define what you actually mean by that, because everyone in this thread seems to carry a different one around. If the armband picks itself off training form, fine, but I'd want to know who's tracking that training week to week rather than taking the coaching box's word for it. Happy to wait and see too, just don't dress the waiting up as a plan.
Highlanders goal celebration
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Reply Quote
JO JohnBlues Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 245 posts 29 Oct 2026, 8:21 am
The only 2015 lesson I remember is my TAB multi dying in the quarters 🀣 armband can pick itself, I'm just here for the drama.
Highlanders team
Only serious one here β€” barely.
Reply Quote
DiehardFaithful wrote:
@PaulOpenside lad you're backing a call cos it paid out once πŸ˜‚ nah, captain picks itself if the bloke's training the house down... rest of us saw the 2015 lesson too ah well, nowt to do but wait and see πŸ”₯
CH Chur Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 360 posts 7 Nov 2026, 7:42 pm
@DiehardFaithful can someone explain simply what the 2015 lesson actually is? I keep seeing it thrown around and I'm lost πŸ˜… like is it about picking the wrong captain or just backing the coaches no matter what?
Learning from the veterans, go easy πŸ™
Reply Quote
SA SamTurnover Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 61 posts 20 Nov 2026, 5:54 am
@Chur honestly nobody in this thread can agree on it either, so don't feel bad. Half of them mean "the coaches picked the wrong captain and it cost us", the other half mean "back the coaching box and stop second-guessing". Two opposite lessons wearing the same label. I'd want someone to actually define it before we argue about armbands. And a payout on a multi says nothing about whether Paul reads the team well, LockLegend is right there. Plenty of punters in Invercargill pubs who backed a winner once and now think they're selectors.
Reply Quote
SamTurnover wrote:
@Chur honestly nobody in this thread can agree on it either, so don't feel bad. Half of them mean "the coaches picked the wrong captain and it cost us", the other half mean "back the coaching box and stop second-guessing…
JO JohnNapier1976 Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 605 posts 20 Nov 2026, 5:54 am
🀣 classic forum moment, one label two fights. Chur mate the lesson is just pick a captain who can still walk at fulltime, that's my whole philosophy.
Came to laugh, stayed for life 🍿
Reply Quote
KE KevFan Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 273 posts 20 Nov 2026, 5:54 am
SamTurnover nailed it, two opposite lessons in one slogan πŸ˜‚ Same thing happens with punting, everyone quotes "back your judgement" and means completely different things by it. My 2015-style slip was a multi that had everything right except the odd try scorer, landed five legs and died on the sixth. Never forgotten.
Highlanders stadium
Bankroll discipline wins.
Reply Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up β€” it's quick.