Tin Hearth
22 Nov, 7:25 pm Log in Sign up
Highlanders

Forget the old boys' network

club debate Highlanders Supporters Highlanders 17 posts ·167 views ·Posted: 21 Sep 2026, 10:50 pm ·Updated: 18 Nov 2026, 3:51 am
LO LockLegend Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 448 posts 21 Sep 2026, 10:50 pm
Right, I'll say what half of you are already thinking over your beer at the pub. That 2015 love-in needs to end, and fast. Half this squad gets picked because of who they know and how long they've been around, not because they've earned the jersey this season. Watch any game from the last couple of years, the same blokes drift through 60 minutes doing sweet nothing and somehow start the next week. Meanwhile young fellas tear it up at training and can't buy a run-on spot. And in reality? If two stalwarts are genuinely on notice before the Crusaders come to Forsyth Barr, good. Should've happened two seasons ago. Sentiment wins you nothing against the red-and-blacks, ask any punter who's backed us on the line the last few years 😏. One of the pub crew reckons one of them should be captain, sure thing, mate, captain of what exactly, the after-match function? 🤡 Axe the favourites, pick on form, and this rebuild might actually go somewhere.
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Reply Quote
SU Supporter88 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 339 posts 21 Sep 2026, 11:17 pm
Funny how "earned the jersey" always means whoever you rate this week, eh. Before we start culling names, define what actually makes someone a favourite in your book, tenure, or selection ahead of a better option? Those are different problems and they need different fixes. I'll grant the sentiment: a couple of the old guard have been carried on reputation, and if the training-ground chatter about two stalwarts being on notice is real, then the coaches already agree. But gut feeling about who to axe is exactly the lazy part. Show me one name and one concrete reason, form, minutes, whatever, and I'll argue it with you over a pint before the Crusaders match. Otherwise it's just vibes dressed up as a rebuild plan.
Reply Quote
ME Metric_Lab Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 263 posts 22 Sep 2026, 1:47 am
Nah you've both got a point tbh, but I watched that mob at the 2015 reunion do a lap and half the pub went quiet, sentiment doesn't tackle anyone 😤 Axe whoever's coasting, doesn't matter if they lifted the trophy back then, Crusaders won't care at Forsyth Barr 🔥💪
Highlanders fans
One love, one side ❤️
Reply Quote
RO RobFirstFive Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 735 posts 22 Sep 2026, 3:13 am
I keep my own table on this stuff, and honestly Supporter88 has the sharpest question in the thread, tenure and blocking a better option are two different metrics, and the club keeps failing both. I could be wrong, but when you separate them properly, the tenure argument collapses: a bloke lifting the trophy in 2015 tells you nothing about whether he's outselling the 21-year-old behind him in carries or lineout takes this season. Sentiment is a lagging indicator, it always trails form by about two seasons. Small sample though on this year's tape, so I'd axe on blocks, not on badges. And if one of those stalwarts really is on notice before the Crusaders come to Forsyth Barr, then the captaincy chatter sorts itself out, you don't hand the armband to a bloke whose selection is a live debate. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Reply Quote
NI Nick_Tauranga Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 303 posts 22 Sep 2026, 3:50 am
Mum took me to the 2015 final celebrations and I still get goosebumps 😅 but she'd be first to say sentiment doesn't win you the Crusaders clash. Maybe I'm wrong though? 🏉
New here, soaking it up.
Reply Quote
SW SweetAsNZ Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 1015 posts 22 Sep 2026, 4:51 am
Took a $25 multi off the Crusaders game last season. Head-to-head plus the line plus a try scorer, and it died because our old guard fell off the pace in the last quarter. Paid out plenty of times on teams who pick on form, and the TAB rates the Crusaders short every time we name the sentimental side, that tells you something right there. I'm with Supporter88 that tenure and blocking a better option are separate problems, but here's my caveat: you don't gut the spine a week out from Forsyth Barr. You name your form side now, and if those two stalwarts are still on notice come the back end, then you swing the axe properly. My mate had $50 on us in a margin band that landed by one kick last year and he swore the difference was fresh legs off the bench, that's a coaching call, not a cull. Sentiment's lovely at the reunion, brutal at the book. 🔥
Reply Quote
NA Napier_Legend1980 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 457 posts 22 Sep 2026, 6:35 am
SweetAsNZ your multi died because you backed the old guard, that's on you 😂 Sentiment lost us finals before, axe them and stop crying into your beer 🤡💸
Highlanders goal celebration
Show me your ROI first 😏
Reply Quote
TA Tauranga15 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 402 posts 22 Sep 2026, 4:26 pm
Nah sorry Napier_Legend, blaming SweetAs's multi is weak 😅 sentiment's cost us plenty but you don't bin two stalwarts a week out from the Crusaders either. What's actually going on at training? 🤔🔥
Reply Quote
WI Wing_Fan Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 202 posts 22 Sep 2026, 6:41 pm
Careful what you're all signing up for here 😏 word going round the place is the coaches know exactly who's fading, and they're not the type to torch a locker room a week out from the Crusaders. My source reckons decisions land after that clash at Forsyth Barr, not before. Screenshot this if you like, but patience, lads 🤫
Solid source, details in the DMs.
Reply Quote
QU Queenstown51 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 483 posts 22 Sep 2026, 8:31 pm
Wing_Fan, "source reckons" carries zero weight with me until it's on the team sheet. If the call genuinely comes after the Crusaders clash, fine. But then the training-ground whispers about stalwarts on notice are just pub noise, and this whole thread is arguing over gossip. I'll believe it when I see names missing from that Friday lineup.
Hype isn't an argument.
Reply Quote
PA PaulOpenside Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 281 posts 7 Oct 2026, 5:52 pm
@Queenstown51 pub noise still moves teamsheets eventually, same as a line drifting before it lands, you back the early read or you pay full price later. I got burned once loading a multi on a bloke "definitely starting" who got axed on game morning, so now I wait for the printed side too 😭 If the change does come after the Crusaders clash though, that's value right there.
Highlanders stadium
Value over a big price 💸
Reply Quote
PaulOpenside wrote:
@Queenstown51 pub noise still moves teamsheets eventually, same as a line drifting before it lands, you back the early read or you pay full price later. I got burned once loading a multi on a bloke "definitely starting" …
AU AucklandMate Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 109 posts 6 Nov 2026, 3:57 am
@PaulOpenside been there mate, axed at the team sheet and the multi's gone 🔥 feels exactly like backing our lot, never make it easy. Load the young blokes in anyway 🙌
Reply Quote
JohnInvercargill84 wrote:
@Queenstown51 don't laugh, but I kind of like the gossip even if it's pub noise, makes the wait till the team sheet fun 😅 does anyone here actually rate the young blokes pushing for a spot?
LA LauraFaithful Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 35 posts 18 Nov 2026, 3:51 am
@AucklandMate the amount of multis I've torched over a late team sheet change is honestly a skill at this point 😂 My mate reckons I should just wait for the official naming but where's the fun in that. Load the young blokes in anyway, worst case we get a laugh and a story 🍿
Highlanders game moment
Memes are analysis too.
Reply Quote
JO JohnInvercargill84 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 290 posts 7 Oct 2026, 5:52 pm
@Queenstown51 don't laugh, but I kind of like the gossip even if it's pub noise, makes the wait till the team sheet fun 😅 does anyone here actually rate the young blokes pushing for a spot?
Reply Quote
BA BachMate Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 124 posts 27 Oct 2026, 6:30 am
@JohnInvercargill84 no laugh from me, the gossip's half the fun honestly 😅 I'm too new to rate the young blokes properly but keen to hear who you lot rate.
Learn something new every day.
Reply Quote
ST StandsGuy_Ultra1997 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 368 posts 22 Sep 2026, 9:51 pm
Wing_Fan pretty much nailed it tbh 👀 you don't torch the room before the Crusaders roll into Forsyth Barr. Seen this movie before, decisions land after 🔥
Highlanders stadium
You don't abandon your own.
Reply Quote
TR Tramping Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 272 posts 22 Sep 2026, 10:29 pm
Fair point from Queenstown51, whispers mean nothing until they show up on the team sheet at Forsyth Barr. Though I'll concede Wing_Fan might be right, on condition that what follows the Crusaders clash is actual change and another "we're rebuilding" presser. I'll believe it when I see the names gone, not the rumours.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Reply Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up — it's quick.