Tin Hearth
22 Nov, 7:14 pm Log in Sign up
Highlanders

Forget the trophies talk. This Highlanders squad's problem is that

club debate Highlanders Supporters Highlanders 23 posts Β·3546 views Β·Posted: 4 Sep 2026, 10:57 pm Β·Updated: 20 Nov 2026, 4:19 am
LO LockLegend Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 448 posts 4 Sep 2026, 10:57 pm
Funny how every season we anoint some "future All Black" and then wonder why he's still here in five years collecting loyalty points 😏 Nothing wrong with loving your own, but passion doesn't pay the bills when there's no silverware on the shelf - and in reality? The big clubs just go out and buy the finished article. Sure thing, mate, keep singing Southern Men at Forsyth Barr, the trophy cabinet won't hear a note πŸ€‘πŸ’Έ
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Reply Quote
LockLegend wrote:
Funny how every season we anoint some "future All Black" and then wonder why he's still here in five years collecting loyalty points 😏 Nothing wrong with loving your own, but passion doesn't pay the bills when there's no…
QU Queenstown51 Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 483 posts 5 Sep 2026, 12:55 am
And who exactly did we "anoint", LockLegend? Name one. You're waving at a pattern you can't actually show, mate, silverware's a fair point, the rest is vibes.
Hype isn't an argument.
Reply Quote
MA MaulTragic Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 264 posts 5 Sep 2026, 1:55 am
Nah Queenstown51 he's got a point tbh, remember everyone crowing about certain lads as ABs-in-waiting? Still stings singing Southern Men that arvo 😒πŸ”₯
Highlanders game moment
You don't abandon your own.
Reply Quote
RO RobFirstFive Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 735 posts 5 Sep 2026, 4:15 am
Been keeping my own spreadsheet on this for a few seasons now and I'll back LockLegend's vibe with something a bit firmer. If you count how many of our "future All Blacks" chatter players actually went on to earn caps while in Highlanders colours, the hit rate is genuinely thin, most of the lads we got excited about peaked as solid Super Rugby men or did their best work elsewhere. Small sample though, and I could be wrong on how you slice it, because it depends whether you count the ones who became ABs after leaving Dunedin as a success story or a failure of retention. Here's the nuance people miss: our fan affection holds up brilliantly on matchday at Forsyth Barr and terribly as a development pipeline metric. That quarter-final where the whole ground belted Southern Men? Beautiful night, zero points on the trophy column.
Context beats a bare stat.
Reply Quote
GL GloryDays247 Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 296 posts 5 Sep 2026, 7:28 am
God, Rob's spreadsheet just took me back to the mid-2010s when half the pub swore we had three ABs-in-waiting in the one backline, and every year they'd go to camp while we sang Southern Men at quarter-final time again. Been watching this club since way before some of you lot could get in the gate and it's the same cycle every time, we fall for the promise, the ABs rarely do. That's the real heartbreak, not the scoreboard 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Reply Quote
TR Tryline_Mate Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 640 posts 5 Sep 2026, 8:58 am
Bugger off with that chat eh, singing Southern Men loud at the QF is the whole point of being us πŸ™ŒπŸ”₯ We'd take one lads through thick and thin ah well, nowt to do
In the stands since I was a kid.
Reply Quote
TR Tramping Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 272 posts 5 Sep 2026, 11:10 am
Rob's spreadsheet tracks the pattern, sure, but there's a condition on all this: every club outside Auckland and Christchurch bleeds talent the same way, so it's the system more than our judgement. We even did our job right, sent players up the road, watched them get capped elsewhere while we kept the heartbreak. I'll concede the anointing culture's over the top, on condition that someone shows me a mid-market franchise with a better conversion rate.
Highlanders team
Sample first, conclusions after.
Reply Quote
CH Chur Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 360 posts 5 Sep 2026, 1:31 pm
Tramping has a point eh, it's the whole system bleeding us dry πŸ˜… but I reckon we still hype our own too hard before they've earned it. I got swept up in that QF at Forsyth Barr too, throat gone from singing Southern Men, and I'd do it again πŸ™ so maybe the falling in love is just part of being us? Or am I coping πŸ˜‚
Learning from the veterans, go easy πŸ™
Reply Quote
NA Napier_Legend1980 Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 457 posts 5 Sep 2026, 3:55 pm
Tramping's right eh, every province outside the big two cops the same drain. But Chur, we still crowned half a squad ABs-in-waiting before they'd earned it - that bit's all us 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Reply Quote
CL ClassicGuy Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 286 posts 5 Sep 2026, 8:02 pm
System's the excuse half of you hide behind πŸ˜… Napier's right, we crowned them ABs-in-waiting ourselves. Passion's why I'm here, silverware's why I yell, ah well, nowt to do πŸ”₯
One love, one side ❀️
Reply Quote
CH ChrisFullback Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 181 posts 5 Sep 2026, 10:29 pm
ClassicGuy, passion's why you yell? Ask your source at the pub whether that singing counted for anything come full time at Forsyth Barr 🀫 Word going round is the recruitment folk knew years back which lads would stay homegrown forever - those who know, know. Screenshot this one. 😏
Highlanders fans
Solid source, details in the DMs.
Reply Quote
SU Supporter88 Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 339 posts 5 Sep 2026, 10:39 pm
ChrisFullback, receipts please on that recruitment gossip, because "those who know, know" is exactly the vibe-driven nonsense this thread's about. Anecdote for you: I sat in the tallies at Forsyth Barr before that QF and heard blokes rank half our backline as ABs-in-waiting, none of them made a test squad after. The pub talks, the selection table doesn't listen.
Reply Quote
QU Queenstown_Mad Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 523 posts 5 Sep 2026, 11:35 pm
Nah Supporter88 is onto it, receipts or it didn't happen 😀 But I'll admit I was one of those tallies blokes calling half the backline future ABs, still got the sore throat from singing Southern Men that night to show for it πŸ’” Passion's why I coach the juniors tbh, but mate we need to stop fallin in love before they earn the silver fern πŸ™Œ
You don't abandon your own.
Reply Quote
SC ScrumKiwi Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 241 posts 6 Sep 2026, 1:41 am
Tallies blokes calling future ABs over a few pints? I'd back that lot with a TAB multi before trusting our recruitment folk, and I'd still get better odds 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Reply Quote
ST StandsGuyLegend Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 186 posts 6 Sep 2026, 4:51 am
Reckon both sides are right tbh... we love our own too much AND the silverware never comes. Sore throat from that night still beats a trophy shelf though πŸ’”πŸ”₯ ah well, nowt to do
Highlanders goal celebration
One love, one side ❀️
Reply Quote
StandsGuyLegend wrote:
Reckon both sides are right tbh... we love our own too much AND the silverware never comes. Sore throat from that night still beats a trophy shelf though πŸ’”πŸ”₯ ah well, nowt to do
FR FrontRowArmy Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 187 posts 29 Oct 2026, 6:39 am
@StandsGuyLegend I know exactly the night you mean, I drove down from Napier for one of those throat-wrecking evenings a few seasons back and I still rate it above any trophy conversation, so hard to argue with you there. But I'd push back gently on the "both sides are right" framing, because context matters with loyalty. Keeping faith with your own players only becomes a problem when it stops the club from making hard calls at contract time. The seasons where we kept backing a fading core are the ones that hurt most, and those weren't emotional failures, they were list-management ones. So love the squad by all means, just make sure someone at the table is doing the cold spreadsheet. That someone is usually me πŸ“Š
Do the math before you argue.
Reply Quote
StandsGuyLegend wrote:
Reckon both sides are right tbh... we love our own too much AND the silverware never comes. Sore throat from that night still beats a trophy shelf though πŸ’”πŸ”₯ ah well, nowt to do
ST Steve_SweetAs Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 236 posts 12 Oct 2026, 10:24 am
@StandsGuyLegend nah mate, sore throat doesn't pay the bills. I've backed the Highlanders on plenty of weekends with the head-to-head and the line, and the heart says yes every time while the bankroll says otherwise. That's the lesson from last season's losses - I kept taking short prices on them out of loyalty and it landed maybe half the time. Value over a big price, and there's been no value in this squad for years. You're right that we love our own too much though. Every derby I talk myself into them and every derby I'm staring at a slipped ticket going 😭. Passion is fine for the tallies, but somewhere upstairs they need to make calls with the head instead. Otherwise I'll keep backing them with my heart and my wallet will keep reminding me who's boss. πŸ’Έ
Highlanders fans
Reply Quote
Steve_SweetAs wrote:
@StandsGuyLegend nah mate, sore throat doesn't pay the bills. I've backed the Highlanders on plenty of weekends with the head-to-head and the line, and the heart says yes every time while the bankroll says otherwise. Tha…
CH ChristchurchLoyal Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 117 posts 12 Oct 2026, 10:24 am
@Steve_SweetAs that's rough mate, backing your heart every week and the bankroll bleeding for it πŸ˜… maybe I'm wrong but I figure if you keep picking them with your head off, the TAB will keep loving you. I'm too new to all this to bet, still learning who's even in the squad, but does the heart ever actually win long term? πŸ€”
Learning from the veterans, go easy πŸ™
Reply Quote
ChristchurchLoyal wrote:
@Steve_SweetAs that's rough mate, backing your heart every week and the bankroll bleeding for it πŸ˜… maybe I'm wrong but I figure if you keep picking them with your head off, the TAB will keep loving you. I'm too new to al…
WI Wing_Fan Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 202 posts 12 Oct 2026, 10:24 am
@ChristchurchLoyal stick with the no-betting instinct mate, heart punting on the Landers is a slow bleed. Word going round theTabs never lost money on loyal fans 😏 Mind you, a source reckons things down south ain't as grim as they look next season. That's all I'll say 🀫
Solid source, details in the DMs.
Reply Quote
MA MatchdayZone Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 161 posts 29 Oct 2026, 6:39 am
Ha, the TAB loving us Landers punters, felt that one πŸ˜… Still remember a night at the ground when the crowd lifted the boys so hard the hairs stood up. Get in! β€οΈπŸ‰
You don't abandon your own.
Reply Quote
ChristchurchLoyal wrote:
@Steve_SweetAs that's rough mate, backing your heart every week and the bankroll bleeding for it πŸ˜… maybe I'm wrong but I figure if you keep picking them with your head off, the TAB will keep loving you. I'm too new to al…
DU Dunedin187 Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 271 posts 29 Oct 2026, 6:39 am
@ChristchurchLoyal smart to stay out of it tbh, heart punting on the Landers is a mug's game πŸ˜… I gave up putting NZ$ on my own province years ago after one season too many of "this is our year". Follow the boys through thick and thin but leave the TAB alone, ah well, nowt to do πŸ”₯πŸ’ͺ
Highlanders team
Reply Quote
CA CantabNZ857 Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 176 posts 20 Nov 2026, 4:19 am
@Dunedin187 nah I punt the Landers every week, just never with the heart. Value over a big price keeps me honest, and when one lands it covers the rest πŸ”₯
Value over a big price πŸ’Έ
Reply Quote
JO JoshBeliever Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 206 posts 7 Nov 2026, 4:43 pm
Quietly hoping that insider note about next season is true 🀫 Kept my NZ$ in my pocket anyway, learned that lesson the hard way. Thanks for the hope though Wing_Fan πŸ™‚
Highlanders team
Reply Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up β€” it's quick.