Tin Hearth
22 Nov, 7:30 pm Log in Sign up
Queensland Reds

Fraser McReight is already a better Reds flanker than George Smith

club debate Queensland Reds Supporters Queensland Reds 16 posts ·133 views ·Posted: 20 Oct 2026, 2:03 am ·Updated: 11 Nov 2026, 8:40 am
SC ScrumKiwi Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 241 posts 20 Oct 2026, 2:03 am
Right, someone has to say it, so I will. McReight's pilfer count at Suncorp this season is already past Smithy's best single year in maroon, and yet half of you still carry on like George walked on water at Ballymore. He was quality, sure, but he did his best work elsewhere. Fraser is doing it for us, right now, in our shirt. I'd put actual money on it at the TAB and I don't say that lightly. Nostalgia merchants incoming in 3, 2, 1... 🤡😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Reply Quote
SC Scrum10 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 220 posts 20 Oct 2026, 5:38 am
Did you actually think that a single season's pilfer count is all we need to rewrite history? That statistic shows a good snapshot of recent form, I grant you, but comparing specific metrics from one half of a campaign against a peak performance in a different system doesn't make the case for a definitive upgrade. Show me the full set of metrics over a whole season to make that argument stick.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Reply Quote
TR Tryline_Mate Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 640 posts 20 Oct 2026, 9:10 am
How can you even argue with those numbers? He’s putting in the work mate, the legacy stuff is just nostalgia, ah well, nowt to do 🔥💪
Queensland Reds stadium
In the stands since I was a kid.
Reply Quote
RU Ruck9 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 200 posts 20 Oct 2026, 12:18 pm
Honestly, I don't understand how anyone is still going to argue this when you see the sheer output McReight is having at Suncorp this year. The simple fact is that his pilfers alone have already outpaced what George managed in his absolute best campaign here in maroon. It’s about the current standard of play, mate.
Reply Quote
CL ClassicFan Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 485 posts 20 Oct 2026, 3:09 pm
Watched Smithy at Ballymore in the flesh, boys. Different game back then, poaching wasn't the whole job. McReight's tally is fair dinkum though, ah well, we'll see.
Been here longer than some have followed.
Reply Quote
TR Tramping Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 272 posts 20 Oct 2026, 3:22 pm
Funny how those younger guys just seem built for this sort of modern grind. I realise his carrying out of contact is what really sets him apart this year.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Reply Quote
TI Tighthead Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 193 posts 20 Oct 2026, 6:46 pm
ClassicFan's got a point about how different the game was, but McReight's actually shaping the ruck every week, not just poaching. I keep my own table each round and his numbers jump off the page 📊
Queensland Reds game moment
Numbers > vibes.
Reply Quote
FR FrontRow_TillIDie Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 150 posts 20 Oct 2026, 10:16 pm
ClassicFan mate, I love ya, but "poaching wasn't the whole job" sounds a lot like "we had to walk uphill both ways" 😂 Rules made Smithy's job harder in some ways, sure, but McReight shapes the ruck every week at Suncorp while the old tapes show George mostly standing off. Put my money where the pilfer count is, and I'd want decent odds before I back nostalgia. 🤡
Any stat can be bent.
Reply Quote
TA Tauranga15 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 402 posts 21 Oct 2026, 12:12 am
Ha, standing off on old tapes? Smithy won Ballon-level respect without a TMO holding his hand 😤 McReight's pilfers are class though, backing them all day 🔥 Ah well, nowt to do but argue til kickoff.
Reply Quote
JO John_Faithful790 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 481 posts 21 Oct 2026, 2:16 pm
seems stats are all folks these days, eh? george's toughness in the old days meant more than just a quick pilfer count.
Seen it all, trust me.
Reply Quote
RO RotoruaLoyal Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 455 posts 21 Oct 2026, 5:30 pm
Stat comparisons mean little until you define what exactly you're valuing. Is 'shaping the ruck' measured by metres gained, or just possession turnover? Without agreed metrics, this is just noise.
Queensland Reds team
Sample first, conclusions after.
Reply Quote
RO RobFirstFive Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 735 posts 21 Oct 2026, 5:57 pm
RotoruaLoyal has a point, though I'd push back gently on calling it noise. I've kept my own breakdown of McReight's ruck work this season and the turnover column is only half the story. What gets me is how often his presence alone makes the attacking side rush their cleanout and bleed penalties. You can't put that in a stat sheet easily, but the tape shows it nearly every match at Suncorp. John_Faithful790, I hear you on toughness, George's durability across a whole career was enormous and nobody sane rates that away. I could be wrong, but if we're comparing peak value to the Reds specifically, McReight in maroon beats what Smith gave us, mostly because the modern openside does three jobs where the old model did one beautifully. Small sample though, one strong season against a decade of history. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Reply Quote
RobFirstFive wrote:
RotoruaLoyal has a point, though I'd push back gently on calling it noise. I've kept my own breakdown of McReight's ruck work this season and the turnover column is only half the story. What gets me is how often his pres…
KE KevFan Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 273 posts 1 Nov 2026, 11:44 pm
@RobFirstFive that rushed cleanout point is real value, same reason I keep taking Reds + line when the ref lets the ruck breathe, the penalty count swings it. Shame the TAB won't price "look of panic" into a multi, eh. Watching live beats any stat column for picking that up.
Bankroll discipline wins.
Reply Quote
MA MaulMad16 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 57 posts 21 Oct 2026, 6:58 pm
Watched McReight live at Suncorp and blokes just panic at the ruck when he's hovering. Smithy was great, but I'd take the freak hands every day 😏
Any stat can be bent.
Reply Quote
FR FrontRowArmy Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 187 posts 21 Oct 2026, 10:58 pm
My old man still reckons nobody cleans out a ruck like Smithy did, and honestly both things can be true. McReight's turnover numbers this season stand on their own, and the way teams rush their service when he's lurking is something the stat sheet barely catches. I'll keep my own table updated through the derbies and we'll see if the gap holds, but I'm not ready to bury George just yet.
Do the math before you argue.
Reply Quote
RE RefBlindMerchant Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 87 posts 11 Nov 2026, 8:40 am
Honestly, sounds like a committee deciding which type of gravy is best. Meanwhile, I just want a good Saturday arvo and a cold one. 🤣😂🍿
Memes are analysis too.
Reply Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up — it's quick.