Tin Hearth
22 Nov, 7:32 pm Log in Sign up
Hawke's Bay

Hawke's Bay don't need big-name signings

club debate Hawke's Bay Supporters Hawke's Bay 6 posts Β·15 views Β·Posted: 16 Nov 2026, 7:32 pm Β·Updated: 18 Nov 2026, 3:51 am
GL GloryDays247 Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 296 posts 16 Nov 2026, 7:32 pm
Nothing beats watching a kid from the Bay run out at McLean Park with the black and white on, and the "heart doesn't tackle" crowd can get stuffed 😏 Half our premiership sides over the years have come off that academy grind anyway, so why would we go shopping for ring-ins now? Put a few shekels on the kids at the TAB if you're that worried, that'll settle it quicker than any big-name signing.
Show me your ROI first 😏
Reply Quote
SA SamTurnover Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 61 posts 16 Nov 2026, 10:18 pm
Half the premiership sides claim gets thrown around a lot though, GloryDays. Name them. I like the academykids as much as anyone, but heart didn't stop Canterbury lifting the shield off us and 2021 feels a fair way back now. If a proven NPC calf can be had cheap, saying no on sentiment alone sounds like a pub idea that hasn't met a spreadsheet.
Reply Quote
DU Dunedin187 Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 271 posts 17 Nov 2026, 12:10 am
Bloody oath the kids bleed it πŸ”₯ Sam, Canterbury bought that shield fair and square, no shame there. Give the academy lads a proper crack and we'll take it back πŸ–€πŸ€
Hawke's Bay goal celebration
Reply Quote
FR FrontRowArmy Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 187 posts 17 Nov 2026, 11:06 pm
Myke at the pub asked me this same question last Friday and I pulled my notes out, because I do actually track this stuff round by round. Here's where I land: Sam's challenge is fair, but context matters. The 2021 shield side, the last time we held it, wasn't built on imports either. It was mostly Bay-grown blokes who'd come through the pathways, and nobody called them soft then. So I don't buy the heart-versus-tackle framing. Heart doesn't tackle, sure, but neither does a big-name ring-in who's never played in front of a windy McLean Park crowd on a Saturday night. If the academy produced a shield-winning core four years ago, the pipeline clearly works. The gap since 2021 is coaching continuity and injuries as much as recruitment, going off what I've charted. Give the kids the reps. I'd rather lose with six locals coming through than patch a season with hired hands and end up mid-table anyway.
Do the math before you argue.
Reply Quote
SW SweetAs_Mad Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 784 posts 18 Nov 2026, 3:08 am
It's easy to look at any single year, like 2021, and point at the big names and say, 'See, we needed that,' but you forget the structure that allowed them to be there. I remember watching some of those older squads back when the game was tougher, and it wasn't all about who signed the flashiest contract. The bedrock of this team, mate, is always been the guys who grew up watching us in the local parks. The reason the academy is so vital is that they understand the soul of this club, the grind of playing for the Bay, which is something no import can ever truly replicate. The 2021 team might have needed some external firepower, sure, but the foundation, the sheer bloody commitment from the youth section, that’s what makes them fit to lift anything. We need to stop looking at short-term results and start investing in that foundational strength, because that's where the future of the black and white truly lies.
Reply Quote
JA JandalLocal Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 44 posts 18 Nov 2026, 3:51 am
Funny how everyone in this thread is suddenly a selector, my pub table included. I could be wrong, but I reckon both halves of the argument are talking past each other a bit. Sam's right that heart alone doesn't win you the shield, Canterbury proved that the hard way, and 2021 is far enough back now that sentiment doesn't pay the bills. But SweetAs touched on the real point with structure. The 2021 side worked because the academy pipeline was producing players who were already ready, and whoever came in around them slotted into a system, not the other way round. So where I land is somewhere untidy. Pure academy-only sounds lovely at the pub but it's a rigid rule, and rigid rules lose you seasons. What the numbers I keep say (small sample though, worth saying) is that the years we've been competitive have always had the homegrown spine first and the signings filling gaps.
I keep my own tables πŸ“Š
Reply Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up β€” it's quick.