Hawke's Bay's famous black and white hoops belong on the jersey
Hot take incoming lads: the hoops are sacred, no argument there, but the old forward-grunt-wins-games crowd are kidding themselves. Times have moved on. You win with backs who can finish, and the pack just needs to not fall over. Half theASN ranks would disagree mate but the scoreboard's the scoreboard 🤡
And that McLean Park roar that made the away kicker shank it? That was atmosphere, not scrum machine reps. Saddest part is some of you would trade a Futuna-like flyer for another tightead who catches the ball like it's a hot spud. Laughable really. The TAB punters know where the points come from, and it isn't like having the luckiest calves in the comp 😏 Invest your NZ$ accordingly, mates, backs all day.
Show me your ROI first 😏
Tell that to any side that's won a tight one at McLean Park in a southerly. Pack holds, backs finish. Both, mate.
ARE you actually serious with this rubbish, mate? The pack grunt is the whole bloody point, tbh. 🔥 You wanna talk heritage, you talk about the sheer effort those forwards put in week after week... that’s the bedrock, the thing we roar for at McLean Park. 🙌 Backs are nice but they can’t stop tired legs or broken tackles... ah well, nowt to do. 💪😤
One love, one side ❤️
A massive crowd turning into a single roar, that sounds like a perfect autumn afternoon at McLean Park, doesn't it. People get so heated about what makes a team successful. If it’s the brute force going through the line or the silky execution out wide - that they forget the relationship between effort and outcome is far more complex. When you look at the historical performance tables, it isn't about saying one element simply trumps the other; it's about statistical efficiency. For instance, when calculating win probability for games decided by less than 10 points, we see that while sustained forward dominance generates possession and wear down the opposition, which is obviously vital for atmosphere and sheer character. It doesn't always translate linearly into points scored, which is where the finishing backs come in.
Back in the day the Bay pack did the shovelling and the backs got the glory. Both mattered then, both matter now, GloryDays 😉
Seen it all, trust me.
Does anyone remember those early days when the pitch looked more like a muddy paddock than a sporting ground? The sight of the big guys battling in the driving rain, just grinding out metres inch by bloody inch, that's the spirit of the Bay. It’s easy for the young lot never saw that stuff to get caught up in watching the flashy passes from the backs, but you can’t have the fancy footwork if the engine room has stopped turning. You can’t run a slick attacking set if the scrums are being won and the rucks are held tight through sheer stubbornness. That groundwork, the real dirty work they put in on the field every week, that defines the whole season. Those hoops might be tradition, but the real heart is always in the guts and the effort of those forward men. ah well, we'll see.
Been here longer than some have followed.
GloryDays, define "not fall over" for me, because that's doing a lot of work in your argument. You want flashy backs to finish tries, sure, but someone has to win the ball for them first. Every time I've seen the Bay look ordinary, it's been the pack getting shoved off it at the breakdown, and no amount of pace out wide fixes that.
John's got it right, both mattered then and both matter now. I'm not convinced by anyone who picks one half of the team as the whole story. And the grunt is what the McLean Park roar actually responds to, that forward battle in the mud ClassicFan mentioned. You can hear the crowd lift when the tight five turn it over, long before anyone scores. Show me a season where we kept the ball and I'll start believing the backs-only theory. Until then it sounds good but the evidence is thin.
Sample first, conclusions after.
ClassicFan nailed it about the grit, that spirit when the pitch was a proper bog and you just had to fight for every yard. It’s true the forward pack sets the foundation, the engine room really, without that early ruck work the backs never get a clean ball. I remember one absolute classic at McLean Park when we were absolutely pinned deep, but the sheer force in the scrum managed to gain us enough ground to shift the whole attacking structure later on. Those moments are what the fans are genuinely defending, isn't it?
Numbers > vibes.
GloryDays, remind me of your record backing backs-only sides? 😂 A flashy backline behind a beaten pack is just goodlooking passengers, mate.
Any stat can be bent.
Whos gonna give the lads up on the forwards tho? Nah, that grit is everything, mate 🔥 you just gotta have the base to make the magic work. Throw away the hoops for some fancy flyer and they're just gonna be passengers ah well, nowt to do 💪😱
In the stands since I was a kid.
Whos gonna give the lads up on the forwards tho? Nah, that grit is everything, mate 🔥 you just gotta have the base to make the magic work. Throw away the hoops for some fancy flyer and they're just gonna be passengers ah…
@Tryline_Mate same read here mate, pack first, always. Word going round the training ground is the tight five have been doing extras all pre-season, take that how you will 😏🤫 Hoops stay on the jersey and the forwards stay the base, those who know, know.
Word is… but you didn't hear it here 🤫
FrontRow, I put my money where the line is every week and I'll tell you straight: no TAB multi I've ever landed had a backline scoring off dead ball. Won a tidy payout last season backing the Magpies pack to grind out a narrow one, and the odd try scorer was our No 8 off the base. Flashy flyers get you nowhere when the tight five is losing the collision. 💸
SweetAs, that No 8 try off a grinding pack is exactly the point. Watch any scrum we win at McLean Park, the whole stand lifts before the ball's even out.
Hype isn't an argument.
Been keeping my own table on this for a few seasons now and the split in this thread mirrors it almost exactly. For what it's worth, my scoring columns keep telling the same story SweetAs is telling: most weeks our tries start with forward momentum, even when they finish in the hands of the backs. The nuance is in how you frame it. A backline finish looks like backline brilliance, but the gainline work three phases earlier is where the try was actually won.
I could be wrong, but I reckon GloryDays has half a point buried in there. The game has shifted and a pack that only avoids falling over won't cut it at NPC level anymore. But a slick set of backs behind a beaten pack? FrontRow nailed that one, they're passengers with nice footwork. Small sample though, and it depends how you count a try's origin, so I'm happy to leave the argument running. The hoops stay either way, that part is settled. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Been keeping my own table on this for a few seasons now and the split in this thread mirrors it almost exactly. For what it's worth, my scoring columns keep telling the same story SweetAs is telling: most weeks our tries…
@RobFirstFive You're tellin' the truth mate. Look at the way they grind out a win, pure forward effort all game! 🔥💪
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Tight five doing extras? Means sweet nothing till I see it at McLean Park 🤣. Pack wins scrums though, my cousin's shouts depend on it, hold my pint 😂
Came to laugh, stayed for life 🍿