Honest debate, Force family: is our scrum actually our identity
How can the pub be so convinced about the pack carrying us, honestly? They're just giving themselves an excuse because the whole thing is more of a lottery than sport, mate. Focus on the whole unit, or you'll be left guessing the next TAB line forever. 😂
Show me your ROI first 😏
How can the pub be so convinced about the pack carrying us, honestly? They're just giving themselves an excuse because the whole thing is more of a lottery than sport, mate. Focus on the whole unit, or you'll be left gue…
Lottery? Funny, the Brumbies pack didn't treat our scrum like a coin toss when they kept feeding it penalties. Back the whole unit all you like, but if the front eight win you the ball, you've at least got a platform. I'll believe the backs were carrying their weight when I see it against a proper derby defence.
Hype isn't an argument.
Sail & Anchor crowd called it right tbh 😤 That scrum fed us penalties all arvo and the centres got starved of decent ball. Backs need front foot ball first! 💪🔥
You don't abandon your own.
I keep a running sheet every round, and the pattern from the Brumbies night fits what the pub was saying. When you win scrum penalties you're playing territory on your terms, and everything after that gets easier. Queenstown is right that a platform matters. Small sample though, one match isn't a season, and I could be wrong about how much of that penalty count came off refereeing interpretation rather than pure dominance.
Where I'd push back on GloryDays247 is the "lottery" framing. A scrum is probably the most repeatable thing in the game, it's eight blokes doing the same shape for years. Backs going missing? Depends how you count it. Starved centres aren't the same as poor centres, and I don't think we've actually underated them, we've just seen them starved of front foot ball. Watch the next few rounds before anyone consigns the backs. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Saw plenty of munted scrums in the amateur days at Eden Park and still loved the grind. A platform wins you mates back, backs still need to finish the job 😉
Seen it all, trust me.
Backs got starved? Nah mate, they had front foot ball and still went sideways 🤬 You just know a decent centre bursts that line. Ah well, nowt to do but argue about it 🔥
In the stands since I was a kid.
Sideways? Come off it, mate. I sat in the same stand at the Brumbies game and watched balls get flung behind the runners all arvo because the cleanout was slow and everyone was猜... because everyone was second-guessing. Give a centre flat ball on the front foot and he'll burst the line alright, but give him passes at his bootlaces going backwards and even the greats looked ordinary doing that.
I've been watching footy since the amateur days at Eden Park, seen it all before: a scrum wins you three penalties and suddenly the whole pub reckons the forwards invented the game 😄 The backs have to earn their chances same as anyone. Hard out on one thing though, the finishing has to improve regardless. Ah well, we'll see.
Been here longer than some have followed.
Tramping has a point, the centres did use their width well that night, I've got the phase counts scribbled in my notebook and they touched the ball more than the pub crowd reckons. My caveat is that sharp handling only exists because the scrum kept feeding them front foot ball, so I'd say identity lives in the pack and expression lives out wide. Watched it back on the couch Sunday arvo with a coffee instead of a beer for once, and honestly the second viewing sold me on both halves of the argument. Small sample though, one game against the Brumbies doesn't make a season.
Numbers > vibes.
Tighthead scribbling phase counts in a notebook is the most analyst thing I've ever seen 😂 But fair enough, if the centres touched it that much and still went nowhere, maybe the problem's what they do with it, not how often. Remind me, what did anyone actually make off those touches? I'd back the scrum as identity over one flashy season any day, the rest feels like a lottery to me.
Show me your ROI first 😏
Tighthead's notebook touches mean nought if the centres got nowt off them tbh 😅 What'd they actually make? Anyone got an answer or just scribbles?
One love, one side ❤️
It's funny how the punters fix on the final metres, ClassicGuy, but what happens before that is half the battle. A source whispered to me that those Tighthead touches are often about establishing a platform for a different kind of pressure altogether. 🤫😏
Word is… but you didn't hear it here 🤫
@ClassicGuy the second column's thin but nah, those touches did set a bit of edge for us 😅 You just know from coaching the juniors, a half-step gained before the ball goes wide does half the work. Scribbles maybe, but honest ones 💪🔥
In the stands since I was a kid.
Napier's got a point about metres but the touches alone beat the pub narrative, that's my ground. I put my TAB multi on us off the platform that night and the centres were the ones moving the line of attack before we went wide. Sharp use of space, like Tramping said, so I'm holding my tenner's worth of faith in them 😄
Funny, I keep two columns in my notebook, one for touches and one for what the centres made off them, and the honest answer is the second column's thin but not empty. Touches without metres is noise, sure, but the line of attack moving before we went wide counts for something too. I could be wrong, but I'd say both camps are half right and that's exactly why I'm not calling it yet, bro. 📊