Honest debate, Red and Black family
Honestly, someone needs to stop bringing up stuff from 1998 when the young guys have actual talent right here. If we’re stuck in the nostalgic mud because of some legends who retired a decade ago, we’re gonna miss this next good run, mate. The guard is just there because they're comfortable, and frankly, their opinion of the current setup is about as relevant as a rusty tool in a shearing shed.
Show me your ROI first 😏
Talent warming the bench? Name the young gun who's earned a start over the old guard this season. Until then it's just vibes.
Hype isn't an argument.
Heart says it all, nah. Experience is earned, mate. Those old guns know the price of this jersey. 🖤😤
You don't abandon your own.
Heart says it all, nah. Experience is earned, mate. Those old guns know the price of this jersey. 🖤😤
@MatchdayZone the heart argument's a nice story but I've tipped plenty of teams off sentiment and paid for it 😭 experience only lands if the legs are still there, and FrontRowArmy's minutes point is the one I'd put money on. I'd rather back the young fella at value than the old name at a short price.
Value over a big price 💸
Queenstown51 asks who's actually earned a start, and fair question, but earned against whom? If the old guard has played every minute since round one, the young fellas never get the tape to prove anything, so the selection keeps justifying itself. Context matters here, a benching in February and a benching in May are two different arguments. 📊
Do the math before you argue.
FrontRowArmy has a point, seen the same cycle before. Back in the amateur days the old heads held their spots till their legs literally went, and the young lot never got a fair crack till injury forced the coach's hand. Some things don't change, eh. Ah well, we'll see. 😉
Been here longer than some have followed.
Fancy being the tiebreaker over a jug, but I'll keep my tables out of the pub and just say this: FrontRowArmy's point about minutes is the only one with actual evidence behind it, and ClassicFan's memory shows the cycle is older than any of us. Nobody's wrong yet, which is the annoying part. See youse at One NZ, bring your numbers and your nostalgia, we'll weigh both. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Saw this exact thing coaching juniors, blokes holding spots off reputation alone. Give the young fellas a proper run or we'll never know 🔥 backing our lot all day tbh
Heart with the team, head on pause.