Honest question, fam: is the Brumbies' famous forward pack actually
Overrated? Blasphemy, mate π The tight five's 2013 session against the All Blacks pack at GIO Stadium wasn't one good afternoon, that was the blueprint. Everyone raves about the backline stepping and flick passes because highlights are sexy, but try winning anything when your scrum's going backwards at a rate of knots. Punters who actually back the Brumbies on the TAB know the pack keeps us in the line more often than the flash boys win it. Sure thing, the backs finish pretty, but the forwards earn it. Anyone saying otherwise hasn't watched a wet Sunday game where the silky stuff dies and the tight five just grinds. Laughable really π
Show me your ROI first π
Overrated? Blasphemy, mate π The tight five's 2013 session against the All Blacks pack at GIO Stadium wasn't one good afternoon, that was the blueprint. Everyone raves about the backline stepping and flick passes becauseβ¦
One pre-season session is a blueprint? I'll believe it when I see it replicated across a full season. Backline magic wins you games, the pack just stops you losing them.
Hype isn't an argument.
Nah Queenstown you're having a laugh π€ One session?? We held the ALL BLACKS pack at scrum time at GIO Stadium, you just know that wasn't luck, that was years of work in the gym paying off πͺπ₯
Backline magic is pretty as anything tbh, but where do you think those magic moves come from? Off front foot ball the pack wins. You give our lot quick ball and they're unstoppable, give them retreating mess and even the best centres look ordinary π Pack stops you losing games AND wins you the big ones - ask anyone who's watched us choke in a semi with forwards gone quiet π€¬
You don't abandon your own.
Interesting question for a stat head like me. MaulTragic's right that backline moves start off forward momentum, but Queenstown's got a point on sample size, one 2013 hit-out at GIO Stadium is a small sample though, you'd want a full season of scrum penalties to call it a ceiling. I could be wrong, but I'd back the pack as underrated rather than overrated; you notice their work most when it goes munted without it. π
Context beats a bare stat.
I was standing on the eastern hill at GIO that arvo in 2013, mate. You could feel the tight five dig in, whole ground knew something special was happening. Word going round back then was the All Blacks pack left quietly muttering about it π€« Replicating it every week? That's the question, but those who know, know what that pack really was π
Those who know, know.
Sorry mate, standing on the hill feeling vibes doesn't beat a full season of scrum penalties π₯ One good arvo in 2013, that's all it was. Backline magic wins you the comp, ah well, nowt to do π€
In the stands since I was a kid.
@Tryline_Mate genuine question from a newbie, don't laugh π
but if the pack was only "one good arvo" why do older blokes at my club still rate them? π€
FullbackMate's "word going round" is doing a lot of work there. Receipts please, where's the All Blacks pack actually quoted? One pre-season arvo proves hype spreads faster than stats.
Haha this thread's gonna run all week π One hit-out vs a full season, both sides got a point... ah well, nowt to do, bring on the season π₯
In the stands since I was a kid.
2013 was one good arvo, fellas. I played club footy long enough to know the difference between a tight five digging in once and doing it every Saturday π€¬ Show me the season-long scrum stats and I'll listen.
Heart with the team, head on pause.
2013 was one good arvo, fellas. I played club footy long enough to know the difference between a tight five digging in once and doing it every Saturday π€¬ Show me the season-long scrum stats and I'll listen.
@FanaticUltra played loose for years too mate and I get what you mean, one arvo proves nothing π₯ but us coaching the juniors I've got old heads still going on about that Brumbies scrum like it was yesterday. One-off wonder? maybe, but that memory lives on for a reason πͺ
One love, one side β€οΈ
2013 was one good arvo, fellas. I played club footy long enough to know the difference between a tight five digging in once and doing it every Saturday π€¬ Show me the season-long scrum stats and I'll listen.
Stats, stats π tell me you didn't actually watch that scrum without telling me. I'd put NZ$50 at the TAB they'll fold by round ten anyway π€‘
Any stat can be bent.
Stats, stats π tell me you didn't actually watch that scrum without telling me. I'd put NZ$50 at the TAB they'll fold by round ten anyway π€‘
@FrontRow_TillIDie NZ$50 at the TAB on a forward pack folding, bold stuff mate π that's the sort of confident punt that empties accounts by round six. Watching one scrum on telly and calling it expertise is very on brand for you. Remind me of your ROI again? π€‘
It's a lottery, not sport.
JohnInvercargill84 nah no one's laughing mate, fair question π older blokes rate them coz for years that scrum just kept coming, week after week, and you don't forget getting shoved off your own ball as a young fella π
But FanaticUltra's right tbh, one big arvo means nothing without the season behind it. Our lot never make it easy, bring on the season π₯πͺ
You don't abandon your own.