Tin Hearth
22 Nov, 7:17 pm Log in Sign up
Brumbies

Honest question, fam: is the Brumbies' famous forward pack actually

club debate Brumbies Supporters Brumbies 6 posts ·1 view ·Posted: 22 Nov 2026, 12:31 am ·Updated: 22 Nov 2026, 5:18 am
HA HarryTramping Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 3 posts 22 Nov 2026, 12:31 am
Genuine question lads, and I'll cop the hate for it: do we actually rate this forward pack, or do we just love the maul because it's the only trick we've got? Every time the backs get clean ball they look dangerous, then Walda calls another rolling maul and we grind out 40 minutes of nothing. I watched the Reds game thinking the same thing. If the pack was as "famous" as the fanboys reckon we wouldn't be praying for a late penalty every week. And yeah I know someone's already reaching for that Giteka-era maul memory from Canberra Stadium, five minutes of shoving and we still lost by three. That's my point exactly 😂. Remind me of your ROI on backing the pack to win us tight ones? I took the Brumbies on the line at the TAB last few tight finishes and got burned more than once 🤡. Spicy pub debate at the Kingo before kick-off, I'll bring it up in person too 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Reply Quote
JA JandalMate Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 22 posts 22 Nov 2026, 12:52 am
Grinding out 40 minutes of nothing still wins you the territory battle though, Harry. Clean ball for the backs has to come from somewhere, and it's the pack that earns it. Sure, if Walda calls a maul on our own 22 with eight minutes left I'll join you in the groaning, but that's a selection problem, not a forward pack problem. You might be right that we lean on it too much, on condition that someone shows me the backs actually being starved. Were they getting quick ball and fluffing it, or were they getting slow, pressured rubbish that any backline would struggle with? Big difference. From where I sit the maul is a weapon, and every side in the comp would swap their tight five for ours tomorrow.
Hype isn't an argument.
Reply Quote
AU AucklandMate Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 109 posts 22 Nov 2026, 1:43 am
Nah Harry, the pack IS the platform, without it our backs are running off scraps 😤 clean ball don't fall from the sky mate, forwards earn it brick by brick. Sure Walda overcalls the maul sometimes and yeah that Giteka-era arvo in Canberra still gives me nightmares, five minutes of maul and we lost by three 🤬 ah well, nowt to do, I'll back the big buggers all day 💪
Brumbies stadium
Reply Quote
TI Tighthead Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 193 posts 22 Nov 2026, 3:40 am
Good thread lads, finally someone said it out loud. My gut says the pack is fine and Walda's maul habit is the actual bottleneck, and the eye test backs that up. Every time the backs get front-foot ball they look like the best unit in the comp, which means the delivery is there when the maul isn't eating it. Small sample though, and I'd want to see the sequence data before hanging the forwards: are the backs getting clean ball off first phase or are they living off restarts? If I had the numbers I'd check minutes with ball in hand by the pack versus possession actually used. My guess, from watching us cough up in Canberra that day the maul ground five minutes off the clock and we still lost by three, is that the platform earns plenty but we spend too much of it. JandalMate's right that clean ball has to come from somewhere, the question is where Walda chooses to spend it. 📊
Numbers > vibes.
Reply Quote
SW SweetAs_Mad Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 784 posts 22 Nov 2026, 4:46 am
Seen it all before lads. Back in my day the great sides won with the pack first and the backs finished it off, simple as that. That maul night at Canberra when we ate five minutes and still lost by three still stings, but blame Walda's habits more than the forwards, eh 😄
Reply Quote
JA JackalMate Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 36 posts 22 Nov 2026, 5:18 am
Funny how the same Canberra night gets read two ways, eh. I've kept my own tallies for years and the honest answer is the sample cuts both ways: the maul earns us territory and penalties, sure, but the carry count off nine and ten in those grinding patches is where I'd look before blaming the forwards themselves. Depends how you count it, really. Clean ball per ruck versus ball actually released wide, those are two different numbers and only one of them points at the pack. So Harry's question sits half-open for me. Pack's doing its job, Walda's calling the shots, and the backs starve in between. That five-minute maul that ended three points short still stings because we never went wide off the back of it. Kingo debate stays alive as far as I'm concerned 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Reply Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up — it's quick.