Honest question, fam: is this Canterbury pack actually great
Still reminiscing about the Addington roar after all these years, eh? I think a lot of us are mistaking old memories for actually winning rugby, mate. The current boys are solid enough, but expecting them to carry that historical hype is laughable really 🤡. We should be talking about the next line, not just waving faded flags.
Show me your ROI first 😏
Are people actually serious about basing an evaluation purely on nostalgia? That concept of "missing the old roar" just sounds like a convenient way to avoid looking at the present performance metrics. Throwing around subjective feeling isn't a substitute for data. If the performance is genuinely substandard, point to the stats, don't cling to hazy memories. I'll believe the claims of historical superiority when you show the actual turnover ratios from those earlier campaigns, not just the noise level.
Sample first, conclusions after.
You think we just wanna live in the past? Nah! 💪 The fire is still in us, the drive is there. We’ve got the same bloody heart as ever, just gotta feel it in the ruck now not just the terraces. We'll always carry the roar with us, fam, just have faith in our lot. 🔥🙌
You don't abandon your own.
Funny thing, I checked my own table for this round before replying and the pack's stats hold up fine on their own, context matters though. RotoruaLoyal has a point that feeling isn't data, but the current forwards' numbers don't need the old Addington noise to justify them. ScrumKiwi calling them "solid enough" is doing them a disservice, depends how you count it but on my figures they've earned the hype. 📊
Do the math before you argue.
ScrumKiwi, the old boys never needed a clown emoji to make a point 😄. I was on that Addington terrace back when Canterbury packed it before kickoff at the pub on Lincoln Road, and I'll tell you what I remember: the noise lifted the forwards, sure, but the scrum itself was won in the mud and the mauls, not in the stands. Those sides would've been ordinary without the work underneath the roar.
So when people ask if this pack is great or if we're just homesick for the old sound, my answer is both things can be true at once, eh. The current forwards' numbers stand on their own, FrontRowArmy is right about that, but a young lot never saw what a full terrace does to an opposition pack in the last twenty minutes, and that's worth something too. Heart plus proof beats either one alone, I reckon. Ah well, we'll see how they go when it counts.
Been here longer than some have followed.
You really think mud is the only metric, eh? some lads just play the cleaner game now, mate.
Is the whole debate just going to hinge on how loud the crowd was fifty years ago? I saw them operate against Otago last week; their set-piece work isn't messy, even if the noise isn't the same. The grunt work is there, you can actually watch it in the rucks, it's consistent.
Hype isn't an argument.
The way the air settles in a quiet country road after a summer downpour reminds me of how sometimes you need to step back and look at the fundamentals, not just the spectacle. I reckon Queenstown51 has hit on the essential point regarding the set-piece execution; it really is consistent. If you look at the cycle count of successful rucks versus missed quick phases, the current boys show very respectable numbers, and you can actually measure that grit.
I could be wrong, but there's a nuance here too. It's not just about whether the grunt work is there, because every modern pack does that to some degree. The difference, which I track in my own little tables, is the sustained pressure applied through the fringes, especially when the opposition is physically bigger.
All that historical shouting is just noise until you remind me of your ROI? Those grandfathers need to worry less about the roar and more about the line odds 💸😏.
Any stat can be bent.
FrontRow_TillIDie bringing up ROI like he's a stockbroker not a prop 😂 mate you'd know line odds better than scrum binds then. Queenstown51 is right though, watched the ruck work against Otago myself and the grunt's real, quiet ground or not. You just know the old Addington lads would've smashed all of us at the Monday fitness test anyway 🔥 ah well, nowt to do.
In the stands since I was a kid.
Funny how Ruck9 goes all poetic and everyone just nods along, but Queenstown51 says the same thing with ruck numbers and gets a thumbs up from Tryline_Mate too. Keep the pub on Lincoln Road for the kick-off ritual, but judge the pack on what happens in the ruck tunnel, not in memory. I've got no verdict for you yet, my tables need a few more rounds before I'd sign that one either way. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Funny how Ruck9 goes all poetic and everyone just nods along, but Queenstown51 says the same thing with ruck numbers and gets a thumbs up from Tryline_Mate too. Keep the pub on Lincoln Road for the kick-off ritual, but j…
@NickBreakdown1982 nah you're spot on mate, poetry don't win you the tight phases 😅 i coached against a canterbury age grade side last winter and even the juniors there hit rucks like they mean it, so it filters down from somewhere. pub ritual stays though, some things are sacred 🙌
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Don't laugh if this is a dumb one, still learning this side of the game 😅 but what exactly should I be watching in the ruck to judge a pack properly? I went to the Otago game and honestly just cheered when the big lads ran hard. StandsGuyLoyal's point about the juniors hitting rucks does make sense to me though 🙏
Dumb questions are my specialty.