Honest question, fellow red-and-blacks
Spoiled rotten, simple as that. Anyone at the Addington pub whinging about Robertson's shelf life after eight titles needs a check-up from the neck up. Was 2017 lucky? Maybe a touch, but you make your own luck over 80 minutes. Put money on us being forgotten in five years and I'd take that TAB bet all day 🤡😏
Any stat can be bent.
8 titles in 8 years, how's that "forgettable"? 😤 Grow a spine Scrum10, every dynasty has flat seasons. Bring your own shouts to Addington if you're gonna whinge. CHANT IT WITH ME: CRUUU-SADERS 🔥💪 ah well, nowt to do
In the stands since I was a kid.
Scrum10, context matters though. Eight titles in eight seasons under Robertson, even with a stacked roster, that's never been repeated in Super Rugby. Flat seasons are the price of a dynasty.
Do the math before you argue.
Back in my day we'd wait years just for a semi-final, and the whole pub would still sing the theme song after a loss. Eight titles in eight seasons, forgettable? The young fellas whinging at Addington have never known the lean winters of the amateur days 😉
SweetAs_Mad has a point. I'll believe the "system's dead" talk when someone shows me a coach since 2017 who's won anything with a worse roster. Until then it's just pub noise at NZ$9 a pint.
Hype isn't an argument.
Queenstown51 summed it up well, though I'd add a caveat from my own table. I've tracked every round since 2017 in a scruffy spreadsheet, and the drop-off after the title years is real, but judging a coach on three-ish seasons of upheaval is a small sample to hang him with. I drove down from Rotorua for the quarterfinal a while back and the talent drain was visible just standing at warm-up, so I could be wrong, but I'd back Robertson over the pub pessimists any day. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Half of me thinks the Addington crowd should be made to watch 90s footage on loop before they're allowed an opinion, the other half knows a dynasty always creaks before it either rebuilds or rots. My spreadsheet says the drop-off is real, but three seasons of churn is a small sample to bury a coach over, as RobFirstFive says. So I'm leaving the ledger open, same as the pub vote. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Genuinely curious here, don't laugh. What was the "system's dead" talk about? I only started following properly recently so maybe I'm wrong, but eight in a row sounds unreal 😅
New here, soaking it up.
Half of me thinks the Addington crowd should be made to watch 90s footage on loop before they're allowed an opinion, the other half knows a dynasty always creaks before it either rebuilds or rots. My spreadsheet says the…
@NickBreakdown1982 The creak-or-rot line is fine, but creaking needs evidence. Rebuild on the cheap and call it "rebuild". Receipts please.
Sample first, conclusions after.