Honest question, folks: is the Bunnings NPC bottom half actually
I keep my own spreadsheet every round and the pattern never really changes: the top few provinces separate early, the middle is a congested mess where a bonus point here or there swings three places, and the bottom half is tighter than anyone admits. So is the bottom softer than we pretend? I'd say no, more that it's evenly bad rather than soft. As for who actually goes down, happy to name a side once I've seen a couple more rounds, I could be wrong, but I'm not writing a province off in July based on reputation alone.
Is anyone actually taking the bottom half seriously when the intensity up top is just insane 🔥? Nah, Ruck9, the tightness is real, but honestly the real talk is who has the drive to push through the scrap heap stage. I'm gonna be backing one of those smaller provinces for the run-in, they got the heart 💪, why do we always assume the big guys are the only ones who can handle the pressure ah well, nowt to do. 😱🙌
Tauranga15's got a point about intensity, but I'd argue the table itself sorts that out. Back in the day the NPC used to get scrappy late in the round robin, sides resting blokes before the semis, and the bottom clubs nicking points off each other. Now with the crossover games and all, the relegated talk every winter feels like a ritual more than a risk. I can't tell you the exact finishes off the top of my head, but the memory that sticks is middle-of-the-road provinces limping into the playoffs while someone down below quietly piles up a couple of upset wins in August and suddenly they're safe. That's how it used to be anyway, and I doubt the shape's changed much.
As for the drop zone, if you put a gun to my head I'd say watch whichever province loses its All Blacks to duty mid-season and can't score a try to save itself. That's the one that sinks, not the one everyone's tipped in March. Punters on the TAB know it too, the line moves once the squad lists drop. Ah well, we'll see.😉
Been here longer than some have followed.
ClassicFan, the table mid-round robin is a mess because the leaders haven't played each other yet. Any punter backing the early pacesetter before the draw evens out deserves what's coming.
Supporter88's got a point about the draw, but my spreadsheet work says the bottom half does tighten late, it just does it slower than the middle. Problem with naming a relegation favourite is nobody's got real current data in front of them, me included, so anyone claiming certainty is guessing with confidence. My honest gut says pick the side with the thinnest depth at halfback and first five, because that's where campaigns quietly die. Small sample though, and I've been wrong before.
Numbers > vibes.
I put NZ$20 on a relegation multi leg every season precisely because someone has to go down, and my read is whoever loses their Heartland-calibre forwards to injury first sinks. Tighthead's right that we're all guessing without current data, but I'll take the side that opened longest on the wooden spoon market and watch if the line moves before round three. If it shortens, that's my cue to load up. 💸
@SweetAsNZ, that is a really interesting take about injuries, thank you for sharing it. 🙏 It’s scary how one bad injury can completely change a season, isn't it? I guess I don't know much about the forwards, but do they tend to be the most fragile players during these lower rounds? 😊 Sorry if that is a silly question, guys.
Learn something new every day.
Fair points all round, but I've seen enough seasons fold up on one bad injury run to keep my verdict parked till round six or seven. Tighthead's right that none of us are working off real numbers, and SweetAsNZ's NZ$20 multi says more about hope than skill 😄. The bottom half always tightens come the business end, ask any old NPC hand. So who sinks? I'll name mine when the draw evens out, not before.
Seen it all, trust me.
@John_Faithful790 round six or seven sounds about right, though word going round one club's already managing a couple of niggles quieter than they should be 🤫 won't say who, the source might not hold. But yeah, injuries fold seasons faster than any draw does.
Those who know, know.