Honest question, lads, was Razor's 2022-23 Crusaders actually better
The 2017 lot went unbeaten but the comp was soft, the '23 boys won a final in Christchurch then backed it up away from home, that's proper pedigree. Drop the unbeaten record talk and nobody actually rates it. Get the pub to settle it Saturday and I'll take the 22-23 side every time, and I've got the TAB slip to prove it. 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
"Noboddy actually rates it" - I'd like to see you say that to the 2017 squad's faces, because going a full professional season unbeaten against Super Rugby sides is a rare enough thing that it doesn't need your permission to count.
Where I'd push back on you is the other half: "the comp was soft" is doing a lot of work in your argument and you haven't shown it. The 2017 draw had the same opponents as everyone else that year, if it was soft, it was soft for the Chiefs, the Hurricanes and the Lions too, and none of them managed the run. Meanwhile the 2022-23 finals wins are genuinely impressive, especially away from Christchurch, but one-off finals are small samples and you know it. Knockout rugby rewards form on the day; a whole season unbeaten is a bigger body of evidence, not a smaller one.
My honest read as someone who does this with spreadsheets for a living: Razor's later sides were more complete, better depth, better chasing game, won the ugly ones.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Was at the '23 final in Christchurch with my old man and I still get goosebumps tbh 🥲 both things are true lads - unbeaten season is magic, no one's taking that off '17, but winning finals AWAY from home, in someone else's backyard, with the whole crowd against ya? That's another level of grit 💪🔥 RAZOR'S RED AND BLACKS 🙌 ah well, nowt to do, I'm shouting both sides tonight
In the stands since I was a kid.
I've kept my own tally on this for a while, and the away finals bit is where I land too. I could be wrong, but an unbeaten season under a soft-ish 2017 draw and a squad that won finals on the road in 2022-23 are testing different skills. One is consistency across a long season, the other is closing out a final with a hostile crowd and pressure ratcheted up. Anyone who's watched a side choke in a neutral-venue decider knows how rare the second one is.
Where I'd push back on ScrumKiwi: the 2017 record still counts as context for how good that side was week to week, Sam Whitelock's lineout work alone propped up half those wins. So I'd frame it as two great teams measured on different axes, with a small sample though: one final away each season, basically. Depends how you count it, but if you forced me to pick a bragging right, winning finals in someone else's backyard shades it. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
The 2022 final was at Eden Park, Blues' own patch, and the Crusaders still took it, that alone trumps an unbeaten run in a softer draw, on condition we're comparing strength of schedule honestly.
Hype isn't an argument.
Agree with Rob, it's two different kinds of great 🤔 my old man still reckons 2017 but even he admits Eden Park 2022 shut the Blues crowd up, don't laugh at me but I barely remember that season sober 😅 thanks lads for the breakdowns!
Josh your old man's got it half right at least 😏 Eden Park 2022 did it for me. Blues had the whole town behind them and still folded. But I'd want to know what happened when the '22-23 side actually played the '17 draw, which nobody can tell me, so I'll take finals won in someone else's backyard every time. Remind me of your ROI on those '17 multis, SweetAs? 😂
Show me your ROI first 😏
Half the pub yelling about Eden Park and the other half still swears by '17... honestly can't argue with finals won away 🔥 nah I'm with Napier_Legend, backyard wins trump it tbh
One love, one side ❤️
Wing_Fan, the Lions were a midweek-level touring side that winter, beat nobody else of note. Receipts on "harder work than it looked", please.
Napier's got it right, finals won in someone else's backyard is the strongest currency there is, I put money on the line those away finals weekends and the boys kept landing for me when it mattered 💸 That said, my old man was at Lancaster Park in '17 and swears blind that side cruised through the season without ever leaving second gear, which is its own kind of special. Cue me shouting about Whitelock's lineouts next pint anyway 🍺
Unbeaten is unbeaten, but away finals paid my TAB both weekends - that's the side I'd back again 😭🔥 Old man's '17 stories stay undefeated though.
@KevFan nah the TAB never lies 😂 if both away finals landed for ya then that's your answer right there. Winning in someone else's backyard with the whole crowd on ya back, that's the real test and that side passed it twice 🔥
Blokes forget how hostile those derbies get too, I coached the juniors up here in Whanganui and even the kids know you don't get anything easy over the ditch in Auckland. Cruised through? Steve's old man is remembering it through red and black glasses tbh 😱 backing Razor's lot all day
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Genuinely asking, don't laugh guys 😅 but how much does home crowd actually lift a finals team? Went to a derby in Nelson once and the atmosphere was mental 🔥
Home crowd lifts a finals side more than most realise, mate 😏 word going round from a source close to the squad is the '23 boys fed off it all winter. That's all I'll say 🤫
Solid source, details in the DMs.
Was at one of those home finals, the noise when the boys ran out still gives me chills 😅 so yeah I reckon the crowd did plenty. Still learning this era stuff though, thanks for the thread legends 🙏
Learn something new every day.
Never been to a final myself but I've been in that crowd at a derby and honestly your legs go numb before kickoff 😅 JohnInvercargill84 great question, no laughs here. If the '23 boys fed off that noise all winter then maybe that's part of the answer right there. Cheers for the thread legends 🙏
New here, soaking it up.
@RobbedAgainNightmare legs numb before kickoff 😂 try standing on the terraces at Amnesia with a few of us from Rotorua after the drive down. Crowd lifts them sure, but the '23 side won plenty away too, mate 😏
It's a lottery, not sport.