Honest take, crew: this Canterbury side is one good centre away from
Every year someone says "one centre away" and every year we find three more holes by July π Splash the coin if you like, but I've watched enough mid-season import signings fizzle in the Bunnings NPC to know it's a lottery, not sport. Back the colts kid and pray, that's my line. Wait for the fanboys to pile in telling me money buys titles π€‘
Show me your ROI first π
The colts kid is tearing it up against colts, Kiwi. NPC centres run harder lines than anything he's faced. I'll back the academy path if he gets game time off the bench first, that's my condition.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Nah ScrumKiwi, every import's a lottery but a class centre wins you finals, tbh π₯ Give the kid bench minutes AND chase an import. π
One love, one side β€οΈ
I've kept my own numbers this season and Tramping's got a point, small sample though. The colts kid's numbers look great, but every break he's conceded in his two bench cameos came from a hard unders line, exactly what NPC centres run. I'd back him for minutes and chase an import, ClassicGuy's version is the only one that survives July.
Numbers > vibes.
Back in my day we won titles with academy kids straight out of colts, no imports needed. Give the lad real minutes, Tighthead's unders worry fixes itself with game time.
Seen it all, trust me.
john, mate, love you dearly but the eighties are calling and they want their argument back π i was at lancaster park when those academy kids carried us too, but the game's changed. the young lot never saw how loose NPC midfields were back then compared to now, everyone runs hard unders lines off a nine who fires flat balls all day.
seen it all before with imports, some fizzle sure, but when we got a proper one he won us a final and we all know it. my two bob: give the colts kid twenty minutes off the bench against the weaker sides, but if the money's there for a genuine first-class centre, spend it. you don't win a title on potential alone. ah well, we'll see what the club does.
Been here longer than some have followed.
Tighthead's unders point is the only one here with evidence behind it. Give the kid a full start against a mid-table side before anyone spends a cent, I'll believe it when I see it.
Sample first, conclusions after.
RotoruaLoyal's got it right in my book, and coming from a fellow numbers nerd that counts for something. I've been tracking midfield defence in my spreadsheets all season and the pattern's ugly, but I could be wrong about the fix being pure recruitment. Before we drop serious NZ$ on an import, the kid deserves a full start against someone mid-table, because bench cameos against tired legs tell you very little. Small sample though, both directions.
One caveat I'd add to John's academy faith: game time fixes unders lines slowly, and a bad July can cost you a semi. I sat in the pub before the Taranaki match watching the same inside channel get run at three times and nobody adjusted. That's coaching as much as personnel. Give the lad a proper look, judge it on four starts, then decide whether the chequebook comes out. I watched a colts final at Rotorua last winter and the step up in pace is real, but the good ones bridge it fast. π
Context beats a bare stat.
Yeah Rob I trust your spreadsheets, but I'd rather lose with the kid learning than some import costing NZ$ big for one decent game π Academy lad every day.
Show me your ROI first π
Are we seriously debating this when we still have that gap in the scrum? π₯ Like, mate, the midfield problems aren't just about finesse or speed... some of these breaks look like pure luck tbhπ± Maybe instead of spending big on some shiny import, the coach just needs to set up the line better... they keep playing too loose... πͺπ€
In the stands since I was a kid.
Nah @Maul_Mate, that scrum gap is a huge issue tbh. But we still put our bodies on the line week in, week out. We can't let the luck take over us! π₯πͺ
You don't abandon your own.
Luck, Maul_Mate? Pure luck doesn't carve you up three weeks running, mate π Give the academy kid his shot before anyone talks about dropping serious NZ$ on an import who might not learn our patterns by August. And in reality? Every import we've chased mid-season has fizzled, sure thing.
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Are we seriously debating this when we still have that gap in the scrum? π₯ Like, mate, the midfield problems aren't just about finesse or speed... some of these breaks look like pure luck tbhπ± Maybe instead of spending bβ¦
@LockLegend yeah that makes sense actually, thanks π
I'm new here so don't laugh, but does the academy kid actually get much game time this season or has he just been training? Feels harsh to chuck him straight into fixing the midfield if he's barely played π€ hard out though, NZ$ on an import feels risky if it hasn't worked before
Learning from the veterans, go easy π
@LockLegend yeah that makes sense actually, thanks π
I'm new here so don't laugh, but does the academy kid actually get much game time this season or has he just been training? Feels harsh to chuck him straight into fixiβ¦
@SteveBeliever i think he'll get time if the coach stops staring into the void and actually trusts the lads. π€£π
Luck, Maul_Mate? Pure luck doesn't carve you up three weeks running, mate π Give the academy kid his shot before anyone talks about dropping serious NZ$ on an import who might not learn our patterns by August. And in reaβ¦
luck? i reckon it's just poor planning. Still, hope they find the right bloke this time, because i'm ready for a good yarn in the pub. π€£π
Hold my pint.
My old man used to say a leaking roof doesn't need the flashest patch, it needs the right patch. Having kept the defensive numbers all season I can tell you those midfield breaks are real, not luck, and they cluster in the second quarter more than anywhere. That points at structure and fitness as much as personnel, which is why I can't fully sign the import cheque just yet.
Where I land, I could be wrong, but: give the academy kid the colts-to-NPC bridge over the next month, keep the import option warm but unsigned, and hold the coin for if the pattern persists past round six. Any serious NZ$ spend mid-season on a centre who's still learning our line speed call-outs by August is money I'd rather see in the scrum ledger anyway. The hill you're all dying on might still be right, crew, we just haven't proven which centre gets us there. π
give the academy kid a run i say, worst case he learns on the job π₯ coached juniors long enough to know talent needs minutes not drills. get in! π
You don't abandon your own.