Honest take, lads: North Harbour should stop chasing big-name imports
Honestly the import era can wind up. Remember that big-money bloke who was better known at the pre-game pub than on the park at North Harbour Stadium? π Build it from Albany juniors, lose a few more games if we must, at least they'd bleed for the jersey. Would rather watch kids graft than rent a name for NZ$ and watch him limp off by round four.
Any stat can be bent.
One bloke at the pub and suddenly every import's the devil? Lose more games on purpose and you lose the juniors too, nobody stays at Albany to run around in a struggling side. Feel-good footy's sweet until you're shipping 50 in a derby, then the same lads will be howling for signings. Not convinced bleeding for the jersey fixes a thin squad.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Hard out Zoe, but nah, I'll take a young side getting pumped than some imported bloke on big NZ$ who's halfway through a jug by kickoff π€ our lot never make it easy anyway, at least the Albany boys would give a damn. Lose a few more, who cares, backing them all day πͺ
Zoe's got a point about shipping 50 in a derby, I've got every season in my spreadsheets since the early 2000s and the pattern is ugly either way, but here's my worry with the imports route. That pub bloke on the big NZ$ money was one of several, not a one-off, and every one of them blocked an Albany kid from getting game time they needed to actually develop. Depends how you count it, but losing 30-odd points a week with kids learning beats paying for someone else's highlight reel we never see. I'd rather watch a side that's ours get pumped than cheer a hired name I can't pick out of a lineup.
Context beats a bare stat.
I was on the terraces at Onewa Domain days, which were the real dark days, and I'll tell you what I remember. Back in the amateur era we lost plenty too, but the bloke wearing the jersey grew up two streets away and fronted up every week no matter the score. That pub-import story from FrontRow doesn't surprise me one bit, seen it all before, big NZ$ cheque and the appetite never arrives with the luggage.
Zoe, love your worry about the young lot drifting off if we're shipping points, and that's fair. But my memory says kids stay when they can see a pathway, not when a mercenary is blocking it. Take a few hidings in the derby, blood the Albany boys properly, and in three or four years you've got a side that actually means something to this patch. Ah well, we'll see how the board feels about patience, eh π
Been here longer than some have followed.
Seen worse arguments than that, mate, but I was on the terraces in those days too and my memory's a bit different. Back in the amateur era there were blokes who turned up from nowhere, wore the jersey with pride and became Harbour legends within a season, nobody asked which street they grew up on. Character shows up wherever a fella was born, one jug merchant on big NZ$ doesn't make every import a villain π
Seen it all, trust me.
Both vets have a fair point each, which is exactly why I keep two columns in my tables. One for imports who fronted, one for the jug bloke types, and the pub column has more entries than I'd like given what they cost us in NZ$. Small sample though on either side when you count genuine success stories. Here's my open question: is the goal fewer losses, or blokes who care at 60 minutes down? Because history says you rarely get both from one recruitment policy. I could be wrong, but I'd back the Albany pathway with maybe one or two signings a year as a hedge, not a full ban.keen to see if anyone's actually tracked how our academy graduates went elsewhere, because that number might settle this.
Context beats a bare stat.