Honest take, team: our scrum has been carried by the front row for
Watched that 12-phase shambles back and the tight five got monstered at the first maul, ball came out slow as treacle the whole way. Blaming the backs for the finish is laughable really when half of them were starting phases from second phase rubble. Front row's been carrying this pack for two seasons hard out, rest of them coasting on mana and old highlights. Keep that take and watch the fanboys pile in 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Treacle? Rewatch it, ball speed off 9 was fine until phase eight or so, and the drive only got shunted once. What actually died was shape out wide, backs running across themselves with clean pill in hand. Yeah nah, the front row earned their credit again, but pinning this on the tight five alone is a cop-out.
Sample first, conclusions after.
RotoruaLoyal is spot on tbh. I was at the pub with a dozen of our boys watching that and the noise when the pill came out on phase five was HUGE - clean as you like, backs had it on a plate and went across themselves looking for the highlight reel instead of punching it up the middle 🔥
And nah I'll die on this hill: that same tight five got monstered all season and still fronted up for 12 phases with their lungs burning. Reminds me of the club semi a few years back when our prop played on a busted shoulder and we still nearly pinched it, you just know who's carrying who out there. Backs bottled it, plain and simple 🤬 through thick and thin lads, but call it what it is 💪
In the stands since I was a kid.
I re-watched the phases again with my chart from the night and honestly RotoruaLoyal has the shape of it right. I could be wrong, but comparing ball speed off 9 against what happened after phase eight tells you most of the story: early phases the pill was coming out quick enough for any backline to work with, then the momentum died once we started stacking phases off second-phase rubble and the alignment went sideways.
Small sample though, one sequence, I'd hate to rewrite two seasons of front-row credit off a single play. But on this one I'd put more of it on the backs running across themselves looking for the highlight reel than on the tight five. Depends how you count it, but Maul_Mate's version from the pub matches the tape. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Back in my day the tight five earned their mana same way I earn mine, one job done properly every week. That 12-phase finish? Backs had it on a plate twice and still bottled it 💸
Hmm, Steve carrying on about earning mana while dropping TAB slips in every post 😂 Come down to the front row club day and say that to their faces, mate. Sure thing.
Here to argue, not to nod along.
LockLegend, happy to say it at club day, on condition the front row actually shows up to defend themselves, because at the pub I counted at least two of the twelve phases where 9 had to dig the pill out of a shrinking tunnel. Maul_Mate, clean ball on phase five proves one phase, one. Twelve is the sample size that matters, and the second half of the sequence is where it fell over. I'll believe the backs "bottled it" when someone shows me a phase with quick ball after the first maul got folded.
Hype isn't an argument.
Queenstown51's right, one clean ball at five proves bugger all. I had the line that night and still copped the loss 💸, but nah, ball was slow from phase three.
Blaming the backs on that finish is a laugh, the pill was coming back so slow the whole move was dying on its feet by phase eight. Anyone who's stood behind a struggling scrum knows what that does to a 10 with two defenders breathing down him before he even catches it 😂 Steve, if the backs had it "on a plate" twice you wouldn't have copped the loss on the line, mate, would you? Even a TAB slip can see the forwards got worked at the first maul and everything after was uphill. Half our tries this season have come off backs making something from nothing anyway, so the coasting-on-mana line falls flat there. Front row carried us, sure, but the rest aren't exactly on holiday 🤡
Show me your ROI first 😏
Slow ball or not, we still had men standing flat-footed at the finish 😤 Backs gotta take some heat, nah hiding behind the tight five forever 🤬🔥
You don't abandon your own.
Flat-footed?? Mate the backs were taking ball behind the gainline every phase, what you want them to do with that 🤬 Blame the tunnel, nah backing them all day 💪
Funny how everyone blames the front row when the real tell is Tauranga15's point - ball behind the gainline means the tunnel was already lost. Skeptic till I see slow-ball receipts, but that night looked slow from where I sat.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Scrum10's got it right, that was slow ball all night and I'll believe the "backs bottled it" line when I see the receipts. Only caveat, flat running lines behind the gainline make slow ball look worse than it is, so neither side's fully clean. I was up the concourse at One NZ for the third quarter and you could see the 10 stepping back into the pocket before every pass, tells you plenty.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Coached the juniors Saturday arvo and still hadn't calmed down from that finish 😤 honestly reckon both camps are half right. Tunnel was ugly, backs were taking it cold behind the gainline, no one's walking away clean ah well, nowt to do. Keep the argument going lads, through thick and thin 💪🔥
In the stands since I was a kid.
Funny how everyone blames the front row when the real tell is Tauranga15's point - ball behind the gainline means the tunnel was already lost. Skeptic till I see slow-ball receipts, but that night looked slow from where …
@Scrum10 mate I watched that match from the couch and even my tea went cold waiting for the backs to do something 🤣 receipts? just rewatch it, bring snacks
Came to laugh, stayed for life 🍿
Watched it live and had the line moving against us by halftime, that slow ball cost me a multi leg 😭 Front row carried, no argument here.
@Jackal mate, hearing about the line moving that hard against us by the half is rough. That slow ball performance is brutal for the punter, no doubt. When the structure just collapses like that, you can see exactly how badly the expected returns went out the window for anyone backing the expected quality. It’s a massive swing when the front row carries and the backs are just idling. I had a similar session last season and bet on the tight five to dominate the yardage, thought they had it on paper, but their execution was soft. Got nailed on the early legs. Sometimes you think the odds are fair, but seeing that kind of sloppiness on the pitch makes you realise your bankroll is everything and you can't afford that kind of luck turning.
Value over a big price 💸
Quick dumb question, don't laugh 😅 does slow ball actually mean the ruck is slow, or the pass? Been watching for years and only just clicked I might've had it backwards cheers in advance 🙏
Dumb questions are my specialty.
@SteveAuckland not a dumb question, it's the ruck. Ball comes back slow from the breakdown so the backs get hit on the back foot. Cost me a leg last week too Jackal, took the odd try scorer in a multi and the bugger never saw clean ball 😭
Up one week, down the next. Classic.