Hot take from your favourite uncle
Uncle's right and it's not even close. You reckon the pub crew from South Auckland should cop a two-hour drive to watch us "host" anyone at North Harbour? Mount Smart every week, no splits, sure thing mate - and in reality who's arguing except the suits chasing a few extra NZ$ in gate receipts? 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Funny how the "suits chasing gate receipts" were also the ones who got us a deal that keeps the lights on, mate. Auckland Council owns Mount Smart and the scheduling isn't ours to command - you don't just click your fingers and book a stadium every week when other tenants and events are in the mix. The split hasn't been some act of betrayal; it's been about keeping the club financially breathing while we build a proper base.
I'm all for Mount Smart becoming the true home, and long-term I reckon the uncle's dead right. But "every single game, no exceptions" ignores contracts, availability and the fact that some of those deals are multi-year commitments. I'd rather we lock in Mount Smart properly over the next couple of seasons than grandstand about it now and pretend the North Harbour money never mattered. Feelings first, invoices second — that's how clubs end up folding.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Chur Rotorua, but if the scheduling's that hard, we'd rather lose a few bookings than our roar at Mount Smart 💪🔥 ah well, nowt to do
One love, one side ❤️
RotoruaLoyal's got a point about tenancy and council control, but I'd side with your uncle on the footballing side of it, atmosphere is measurable, and a scattered crowd across North Harbour and Go Media dilutes the home advantage we actually get from Mount Smart. Small sample though, so I could be wrong, but if you compare our crowds at a packed Mount Smart against the split venues, the difference in noise and energy probably shows up on the pitch more than a few extra NZ$ in gate receipts ever would.
Context beats a bare stat.
Remember when we first ran out at Mount Smart and the whole place shook bro? That's us, that's home. Fits everywhere else and it shows 😢🔥
In the stands since I was a kid.
Uncle's spot on tbh. Pub crew before the game, roar like the first Mount Smart night 🔥 why split it? ah well, nowt to do
In the stands since I was a kid.
Maybe I'm wrong but heaps of our crew out west won't trek to Mount Smart either bro 😅 split keeps it fair? Go easy on me 🙂
New here, soaking it up.
Nick's got half a point, but the loudest crowd we've ever had was at Mount Smart and I'll believe a half-empty Albany draws better when I see it. Fine, centralise everything there, on one condition: cheap buses from South Auckland and the Shore for the away pubs crew, otherwise you've just moved the two-hour problem to someone else's door.
Hype isn't an argument.
Queenstown51's bus condition is the only bit of sense in this whole thread, and I'd shake the man's hand for it. Everything else. Yeah, centralise at Mount Smart, the line's already moved on this debate and I'm loaded up on the same side as the uncle.
My caveat: don't pretend the away crews will all follow. I got mates out West Auckland who grumbled the whole trip the last time we played at Albany anyway, two hours of fuel and parking both ways, they'll still moan about Mount Smart. Fine. Make the buses cheap, NZ$5 return or so, run them from the Shore and South Auckland, and the loud corner ends up in one place instead of scattered across three grounds. Punter logic applies here: you back the option with the proven payout, and that's a full Mount Smart night, every time. 💸🔥
Nick bro, fair enough, but think about who actually turns up. Westies not trekking to Mount Smart? Half of them won't trek to Albany either, they just stay home and watch on the telly — at least at Mount Smart the ones who DO show make noise instead of sitting in a half-empty stand up the Shore getting rained on.
Every home game there, sell the corner cheap to the pub crew, and suddenly away teams walk into a wall instead of a library. Thebounce and the crowd carry through the whole night, boys feed off it. SweetAsNZ putting money on the uncle's side says it all really 😏 even the punters know which way this one's going. Mount Smart or nothing, mean.
Show me your ROI first 😏
Nick bro you can't cop out with "heaps of our crew won't trek" 😅 they wouldn't trek to watch us play a house party bro! Two hours to Albany when the pub's an hour the other way?? We've ALL seen what the Mount Smart corner sounds like when the boys run out 🔥 that noise does more for the team than 5,000 scattered quiet seats does.
And GloryDays is spot on tbh. The westies staying home on the telly either way, so why scatter the ones who DO show? Queenstown51's bus idea is the only compromise worth taking, I'll give him that 🙌 Fill one ground, fill it LOUD, that's how we make visiting teams hate coming here 💪
You don't abandon your own.
Nick bro you can't cop out with "heaps of our crew won't trek" 😅 they wouldn't trek to watch us play a house party bro! Two hours to Albany when the pub's an hour the other way?? We've ALL seen what the Mount Smart corne…
@Queenstown_Mad heard similar from a source close to the club, the Mount Smart hum is exactly what the powers that be want bottle and keep 😏 word going round is one or two big occasions elsewhere max, the rest stays south of the bridge. Those who know, know 🤫
Solid source, details in the DMs.
Sorry if this is a dumb question but why can't they just do both — most games at Mount Smart and keep one at North Harbour? Then nobody loses their home corner completely 🤔 cheers for explaining if someone can, got it now maybe 😅
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Nick bro you can't cop out with "heaps of our crew won't trek" 😅 they wouldn't trek to watch us play a house party bro! Two hours to Albany when the pub's an hour the other way?? We've ALL seen what the Mount Smart corne…
@SteveAuckland that's actually how most clubs run it, one or two "away" home games elsewhere is standard. Problem is Moana need every home dollar they can get, and splitting the ground just halves the atmosphere and the gate both times. I'd rather one loud full house at Mount Smart than two quiet ones 😅
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
Nick bro you can't cop out with "heaps of our crew won't trek" 😅 they wouldn't trek to watch us play a house party bro! Two hours to Albany when the pub's an hour the other way?? We've ALL seen what the Mount Smart corne…
@Queenstown_Mad that's a fair point actually, noise beats empty seats every time 😅 I only watched Moana on the telly so far but the Mount Smart crowd looks like the whole ground is humming, even when the team's struggling. Still learning this whole debate, but SteveAuckland's idea of mostly one ground with a token game up the Shore sounds decent to my untrained eye? 🙏
Dumb questions are my specialty.
@Queenstown_Mad that's a fair point actually, noise beats empty seats every time 😅 I only watched Moana on the telly so far but the Mount Smart crowd looks like the whole ground is humming, even when the team's strugglin…
@Wellington_15 telly doesn't do that ground justice apparently, everyone says the same. Only condition I'd put on the noise-beats-empty-seats line is that noise has to turn into season memberships at some point, otherwise it's just good vibes funding nothing. Keen to hear if the broadcast picks the hum up properly or if it flattens on camera?
Sample first, conclusions after.
@SteveAuckland that's actually how most clubs run it, one or two "away" home games elsewhere is standard. Problem is Moana need every home dollar they can get, and splitting the ground just halves the atmosphere and the …
@Maul_Legend spot on tbh. That Mount Smart hum is worth real money to them, you split it and both grounds end up half dead. Went to one of their games there a while back with the juniors I coach, even in the cheap seats the whole place was rumbling and the boys still talk about it 😅
Only thing I'd say is one big occasion somewhere else could actually grow the fanbase, take the whole thing on the road once a season and let another city feel it. But nah, main base has to stay put. Through thick and thin for a club like that, ah well, nowt to do but back em 🔥💪
@Queenstown_Mad heard similar from a source close to the club, the Mount Smart hum is exactly what the powers that be want bottle and keep 😏 word going round is one or two big occasions elsewhere max, the rest stays sout…
@JackSidestep funny, heard the same whisper from a mate who does stuff around the ground on match day. He reckons the club's pretty settled on keeping the bulk of it at Mount Smart, one big showcase game elsewhere and that's your lot. Would be smart tbh, the hum there is the whole selling point. Went last season, even up in the cheap seats you could feel it in your chest. Rest stays south of the bridge, and the details in the DMs if anyone wants more 😏 the source won't hold long mind 🤫
Solid source, details in the DMs.