If Northland can put 52 on Wellington away
52 put on Wellington away and people still reckon no one up here deserves a look? π€‘ That Whangarei mob torched Waikato 34:17 at Semenoff the week before too, in the same month, and suddenly the entire NPC conversation lives in Christchurch and Wellington because of one sloppy 19:22 afternoon against Counties Manukau. Selectors watch one bad half at home and bin the whole province, classic.
There'll be a bolter or two in that backline worth a camp at minimum, but nah, one stinker at Whangarei shouldn't kill anyone's chances when the body of work is two big wins from three. Problem is selectors pick off highlights reels like punters slapping together a TAB multi, one leg lets the whole slip down the drain. π laughable really.
Show me your ROI first π
Steady on, ScrumKiwi, I want Northland guys picked as much as you do, but the 19:22 home loss to Counties Manukau matters more than you're allowing. Selectors read context, and losing at Semenoff to a side Wellington had just smacked around tells them the 52:28 away win says as much about Wellington's afternoon as ours. Small sample though, four games, one of them a 42:57 hiding up at North Harbour that nobody's mentioning either. Name the individual who was clearly the best on the park across those wins and I'll happily back him, that's where the argument actually gets won.
Numbers > vibes.
fair point from you Tighthead, context does count. still, I've watched selectors ignore the winter programme for decades and then pluck someone off one test in June like it never happened. how it used to be with the old bin days, nothing's really changed there.
look at it plainly though. 52 on Wellington away, then Waikato turned over 34:17 at Semenoff the following week. two real results inside a month. one sloppy afternoon against Counties Manukau and suddenly the whole conversation lives somewhere else? if a bloke's form is genuine, one bad Saturday doesn't erase it, and any selector who thinks that way isn't watching the tape properly. the North Harbour loss earlier on, 42:57, nobody even brings that up, which tells you they're just cherry picking whatever suits the argument.
can't name you the individuals from up here because I don't have the figures in front of me, but someone put 28 past Wellington. that doesn't happen by accident. ah well, we'll see π
Been here longer than some have followed.
Nah Tighthead, one bad arvo at Semenoff shouldn't torch a whole roster π₯ 52 in Wellington doesn't happen by accident. Selectors hide behind context tbh π€¬ ah well, nowt to do
Dunedin187 is spot on tbh π₯ I drove up from Invercargill for nothing when we got smacked 42:57 by Northland in Whangarei country earlier that month, so they're legit. My caveat though, one 19:22 stinker does matter when the season's this short ah well, nowt to do πͺ
In the stands since I was a kid.
I chucked a lazy tenner on Northland at the TAB when they were written off for the Wellington trip, so trust me when I say I'm not the one needing convincing π But and in reality, Tighthead's got a point, selectors forgive a 52-burger far easier than a home stink against Counties Manukau. Funny how the line moves on one bad arvo eh π€‘
Here to argue, not to nod along.
LockLegend cashing that tenner is exactly why I keep saying value beats a big price every time. I had Northland in a multi that weekend with the line, legs one and two landed fine and then the head-to-head let me down somewhere else entirely π still filthy about it.
But I'll take the other side on the selectors thing. One 52-point arvo away from home? Flick of the wrist, forgotten by June. Struggle at Semenoff in front of your own mob and suddenly everyone remembers your name. Funny how that works.