Semenoff Stadium's hill beats any corporate seat in the country
Watch the suits come sniffing round Semenoff with a fancy stand plan and watch the hill fight back π Where else in this country does the whole bank stand up and roar a comeback home like it did against Counties in 2023? Punters who'd rather trade the grass for a corporate box can laugh, but I know where I'll be. Sell it and you're just renting your own roar π€‘
Show me your ROI first π
Watch the suits come sniffing round Semenoff with a fancy stand plan and watch the hill fight back π Where else in this country does the whole bank stand up and roar a comeback home like it did against Counties in 2023? β¦
I was on that bank in 2023 and yeah, you're right about the roar. But a decent stand with seats would bring in revenue, not kill the hill. Convince me otherwise.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Revenue means nought if you flatten the soul of the place, brother. That bank roared the Taniwha home in 2023 and I was there π backing the hill all day π₯
RotoruaLoyal, I keep the figures every round and even I can't put a dollar value on what that western bank did in the last ten minutes against Counties in 2023. A stand sells seats, but it doesn't sell the noise that gets under a visiting side's skin when the whole hill rises at once. I could be wrong, but I'd back the bank to out-earn any corporate box in atmosphere alone. The day they flatten it, WhangΔrei loses its voice.
Back in the day we stood on grass banks all over the country and the hill was always where the noise lived, same as the old Eden Park terraces before the suits got to them. Seen worse ideas than a stand, plenty of them, but once that bank goes quiet for good you never get the roar back. Ask RotoruaLoyal what 2023 felt like from those seats they want to build π
Seen it all, trust me.
RotoruaLoyal, mate, I'd sooner take the hill at NZ$15 a ticket than a stand of quiet seats any day. You want revenue? That bank against Counties in 2023 put fear into a visiting side worth more than any corporate box, and you can't invoice that. Keep your hands off our roar ππ₯
For once I agree with the room. WhangΔrei locals bring their kids and their eskies to that bank, no stand gets you that for free. Keep it.
Ruck9 put it well and I'll back him, but one caveat from a numbers bloke: whatever revenue a stand might project on a spreadsheet, none of it survives if the product on the park loses its edge, and the hill is part of that edge. I keep my tables every round and there's no column for atmosphere, which is exactly the problem with trying to price this.
I could be wrong, but I doubt a corporate box has ever got a Taniwha side over the line in the last ten minutes. Watched that Counties game from a mate's couch and could still feel the bank through the telly. Grass banks and eskies beat padded seats every day of the week, and once you pave the roar there's no refund. π
Context beats a bare stat.
@RobFirstFive right on the money, and I'll put it in punter terms: the hill is why home advantage at that ground is worth more than the line suggests, and I've had multis die there when visiting sides just don't handle the noise. Tear it out and I'm pricing Northland differently, simple as that.
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
@RobFirstFive right on the money, and I'll put it in punter terms: the hill is why home advantage at that ground is worth more than the line suggests, and I've had multis die there when visiting sides just don't handle tβ¦
@Maul_Legend you've had multis die there, fine, but "the line suggests" means nothing unless you can show a sample of Northland home games versus the TAB price and how often they covered. Two losing tickets is an anecdote, the bookies already bake the noise into every price anyway. Show me a season's worth of closes and I'll listen.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
@RobFirstFive agree with the caveat, though I'd push one step further: a spreadsheet can price seats per square metre but it can't price home advantage, and Maul_Legend's point about the line shows the market already knows that. Small sample though, so the noise link is hard to prove. Depends how you count it, but I'd rather keep the edge and lose the projected revenue than the reverse.
I keep my own tables π
Did my apprenticeship shearing in WhangΔrei one winter, most of it on the hill at Semenoff between runs. Try explaining to a suit what a grass bank smells like after rain when three thousand blokes lose their minds in the last ten minutes π Rob's got it right, the edge pays the bills, the spreadsheet doesn't π
Show me your ROI first π
Took my old man up there for a game years back and the hill does weird things to visiting halves, swear it. Scrum10's right that the TAB prices it in, but I still faded a line there once and got burnt. π
Bankroll discipline wins.
Scrum10 asking for a sample size like the TAB publishes a Northland hill index π I've stood on that hill with a few cold ones and watched visiting halves sail touch finders into the second row, that's all the proof I need. You ever actually been up there mate, or just reading prices off an app? π
Here to argue, not to nod along.