Is anyone in the NPC actually better than Canterbury right now?
Bloody hell, did anyone actually watch that Wellington game?? π± 66-19 at home, then they sneak past North Harbour by one and put 36 on us in Hamilton... gutted but fair dinkum they're flying π₯ So genuine question, Canterbury or anyone else in the NPC right now, who's actually better? Name a side with a better month than four wins on the spin πͺ
Heart with the team, head on pause.
My morning cup of tea was lukewarm this morning, which sets a rather dreary mood for any definitive ranking debate. Based strictly on the evidence presented this month, Canterbury is currently the strongest side in the NPC. The data shows undeniable form and dominance from Christchurch. In terms of form, they have shown massive attacking threat, scoring 66 points in their home game against Wellington, and grinding out narrow away victories like the one over North Harbour. When assessing the overall strength, their ability to consistently score heavily while still managing to win tight encounters indicates a superior depth of skill across the team.
For any rival to be considered objectively better right now, they would need to show a similar level of consistent goal-kicking power and defensive resilience in this current sample. We have four confirmed wins in this short period, vs Wellington, North Harbour, Waikato, and Southland. All featuring very high point totals.
Sure thing, mate, four wins and a bazooka of a scoreline against Wellington π€‘ but I love how everyone glosses over North Harbour having you one converted drop kick away from a loss. When your "dominance" needs a one-point escape in Albany to stay intact, I'd hold off on crowning them just yet.
It's a lottery, not sport.
BenDunedin has a point worth taking seriously, though he oversells it. The Harbour game was one point, yes, but away wins by any margin in this competition are hard currency. Canterbury have banked four from four, and only one of them was close. That's a better month than anyone else can show right now, and I'll believe someone's got a counterexample when I see it.
My caveat, on condition that we're being honest about context: one month isn't a season. Form in September tells you who's flying, not who lifts the shield. Wellington shipped 66 to them in Christchurch, which probably says as much about Wellington's defensive effort that night as it does about Canterbury's ceiling. I'd hold the "best in the NPC" verdict until we see them away from home against a side that actually turns up. Manawatu on 3 October will tell us more than the Wellington blowout did, for mine.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Seen this script before, Harbour will have hurt more than the 66 taught them anything. Long seasons sort the real ones out. Ah well, we'll see.
Been here longer than some have followed.
Tramping's onto something. One sloppy away win still counts the same as a 66-19, that's the whole point of a table. I backed them at the TAB before Waikato and even I'm holding my breath till Manawatu.
Hype isn't an argument.
Reading the thread, I reckon the consensus lands where Tramping and Dunedin are standing: most lean towards Canterbury because four wins on the spin, 66-19 over Wellington included, is hard to argue with, whatever the table says. The counter, for Ben's camp, is that a one-point escape at North Harbour shows the ceiling isn't far off. I'd wait on Manawatu on 3 October before crowning anyone. Small sample though, and I could be wrong. π
Context beats a bare stat.