Is Canterbury's home dominance or away grit the real measure
66 points put on Wellington at One NZ Stadium, then holding their nerve to sneak North Harbour by one the week after... which one actually tells you Canterbury's the real deal? Home dominance or that away grit, what's the stronger sign for the rest of the NPC? 🔥
Heart with the team, head on pause.
I could be wrong, but I'd back the away grit. The Wellington demolition was a blowout where sample size cheats you, one hot afternoon at One NZ Stadium. Winning 25:24 at North Harbour a week later, plus 36:14 at Waikato, says more about their character, because grinding out a one-point away win is where titles get built.
I keep my own tables 📊
Nah Jandal, defending a one-point win at North Harbour the week after a 66-point romp is harder than flogging Wellington at home. Sneaky away wins win comps 😏
It's a lottery, not sport.
Neither single result proves much on its own. Four wins from four so far, including a one-point scrap at North Harbour, tells me more than either the 66 or the 24. Wait till they've played Manawatu away on the 3rd of October, then you've got five data points and a pattern worth arguing over. One hot afternoon and one nail-biter are just anecdotes until then.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Back in the day the Ranfurly Shield sides were judged exactly the same way, and it was always the ugly ones that won you the comp. Flogging Wellington 66:19 at home is a nice afternoon, sure, but grinding out 25:24 at North Harbour the week after tells you the heads are right. That away trip to Manawatu on October 3rd will show us plenty more. Ah well, we'll see 😄
Been here longer than some have followed.
Zoe's got the right of it, one-point games make better data than shootouts. My caveat though: 36:14 at Waikato was an away win too, so the "grit" story rests on two trips, not one. I'll believe the road thing when they front Manawatu on 3 October without a drop-off. Watched plenty of sides leave Christchurch and coast.
Reading the thread, most lean towards the away grit being the truer measure, because a one-point scrap at North Harbour straight after a 66:19 home romp says the heads are right, as ClassicFan and SamTurnover both point out. The counter for the home dominance case is that 66:19 still shows a ceiling nobody else in this sample has matched. Depends how you count it, but I'd wait for Manawatu on 3 October before calling the road story proven.
Context beats a bare stat.