Is our current 'perfect' Brumbies setup just too fragile?
Pretty sure I backed this mob at the TAB to top the conference last year and got burned, so treat my opinion accordingly π But honestly, the set-piece machine is lovely until a team like the Chiefs decides to play sevens at us for forty minutes. Fragile? Ask any punter who took the short line. Dynasty needs a Plan B that isn't just another rolling maul π
Any stat can be bent.
You really think one match defines the entire system? Prove that weakness exists across multiple fixtures.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Nah bro, one bad day at the line doesn't kill a system πͺ You just know the set-piece will hold when it matters, always has through thick and thin. Chiefs playing sevens? Then we choke their feed and the whole game slows to our rhythm. Back this mob π₯
In the stands since I was a kid.
I saw the Chiefs come over to take a crack at the set piece last season, and even then the structure didn't crumble. While some say they rely too much on the forward pack dominating, the sheer repetition of those core players in critical phases proves the setup is fundamentally sound when it's executed correctly. The plan relies on efficiency rather than unpredictable flair, which is something I genuinely appreciate about this team's foundation.
Context beats a bare stat.
Ha, Tryline_Mate talks like the boys in the pub after a few π but rob's got a point about repetition. Back in my day we watched the great Brumbies sides of the 90s run everything off a rock-solid pack, and the flair came off the back of it, never the other way round. Structure first, then the fancy stuff finds room. Fragility? I'd worry more about injuries to the core eight than any system. π
@SweetAs_Mad still learning this stuff so bear with me π
but if the pack gets hammered by injuries like Jandal says, does the flair just fall over with it? π€
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Mad, I reckon your memory's wearing rose-tinted glasses there. The 90s sides had Larkham and Mortlock to turn all that forward muscle into points, and the young lot never saw how quickly those games could swing when the backs were humming. A rock-solid pack on its own buys you territory, it doesn't buy you tries against a Chiefs side that scores from anywhere.
And Rob, repetition of the same core players cuts both ways. One injury roster reshuffle and that "fundamentally sound" structure gets tested against fresh legs playing loose. I've seen it all before with sides that looked bulletproof until they weren't. Some chaos in the game plan wouldn't hurt, eh. Ah well, we'll see π
Been here longer than some have followed.
Watching both sides argue past each other here is a bit like doing my tables on a Tuesday night, the sample size is too small to call either way. Rob's right that the pack keeps holding up, but ClassicFan's got the sharper point, structure only wins you titles if someone turns the good ball into tries when the game speeds up. Depends how you count it, I reckon, ask me again after we've faced the Chiefs twice and the Crusaders once more. π
Context beats a bare stat.
Ha, tryline_mate talks like the boys in the pub after a few π but rob's got a point about repetition. Back in my day we watched the great Brumbies sides of the 90s run everything off a rock-solid pack, and the flair cameβ¦
@NickBreakdown1982 mate my source reckons the physio room's busier than anyone's admitting, sample size or not π€« word going round, you know the rest
Screenshot this.
Watching both sides argue past each other here is a bit like doing my tables on a Tuesday night, the sample size is too small to call either way. Rob's right that the pack keeps holding up, but ClassicFan's got the sharpβ¦
@NickBreakdown1982 nah bro, I coached juniors long enough to know when a setup's one big hit away from falling apart π
you can call small sample all you want, physio rooms filling up IS the sample. When I was playing we lost two locks in a week and suddenly the "structure" was just forwards hanging on. Brumbies fans gotta be bricking it tbh π€·
You don't abandon your own.
@MatchdayZone nah you're spot on mate, I've seen it a hundred times coaching the juniors here... one or two boys go down and suddenly the whole thing wobbles like a jandal in the wind π
But tbh every club's one injury wave away from chaos, that's just footy. The question for me is whether they've got the depth coming through or if they've been leaning on the same ten fellas all season. If the physio room's as busy as Jandal's hearing then someone better be blooding the young pack soon, 'cause you can't just flip a switch mid-season... ah well, nowt to do πͺ
One love, one side β€οΈ