Is our gritty, 'Northland way' of playing holding us back from the
Gritty wins nothing but pub arguments, mate. We smash the scrum, monster the ruck, then kick the ball away and wonder why the tries dry up. If domination up front can't buy you points out wide, what's the point of the dominance? "The Northland way" is starting to sound like an excuse for a backline that hasn't fired in years. Change the gameplan or accept we're the lovable doormats of the competition. 😏
Any stat can be bent.
Watch any title-winning side and you'll find a pack that wins the collision first, Maul. Tries out wide come off front-foot ball, and front-foot ball comes off exactly the scrum and ruck work you're sneering at. Fix the service from nine and the width looks after itself.
Hype isn't an argument.
Queenstown51 gets it 🔥 front foot ball wins comps. Nine's service has been choppy for seasons... fix that and the width comes 💪 through thick and thin, mates
In the stands since I was a kid.
Sometimes watching the match feels like watching two engines running perfectly, but they aren't connected to the drive shaft. You can’t just assume the physicality of winning the ruck guarantees the try, especially when the linkage is dodgy. Queenstown51 is hitting on something fundamental here, and the whole discussion hinges on the quality of the transition from phase work to structured attack.
If the pack is dominant, meaning they're gaining high percentage carry metres through their relentless pressure, the statistical likelihood of converting that dominance into successful phase play increases exponentially. But if the distribution. Specifically the service from the nine, is inconsistent, that huge amount of physical possession just becomes static accumulation.
Context beats a bare stat.
ain't it funny how this argument keeps coming up, like it's some new thing they’ve invented lately. i remember watching some of those epic matches at Eden Park when the whole game was built on pure forward dominance, pure grunt. back in my day, we didn't always have the sparkling flair they talk about now, but if the forwards did their job, we'd get there somehow, just took more time and guts. it wasn't always the wide stuff that won them the day.
Queenstown51 talking like front foot ball is a cheat code 😂 we've HAD front foot for seasons mate, still kicking wall possession away. You just know it's the game plan, not the nine 🤬
You don't abandon your own.
StandsGuy, how is it the game plan when we've seen half-games where the width actually comes off? I keep thinking of that spell a couple of seasons back when the nine was sparking and we were putting it through the hands, and the crowd down the terraces could feel tries coming before they happened. That didn't come from ripping up the plan, it came from the forwards winning the collision so clean the backs had time to breathe. linkage, like NickBreakdown says.
Back in the day at Eden Park you'd watch the All Blacks take the Bledisloe off ten minutes of shoving the Wallabies backwards, and nobody whinged that they kicked too much. Front foot first, flash second, always. Ah well, we'll see what the coach does about the nine service 😉
Been here longer than some have followed.
ClassicFan's right that the width has worked in spells, but a couple of half-games doesn't answer the question. Front foot ball that ends in a shotgun kick to the corner is dominance converted into territory, not tries. Show me a full season where the hands actually stuck out wide, then I'll call the game plan the problem.
I remember the atmosphere the last time we saw that kind of attacking play, standing there near the centre and you could genuinely hear the cheer before the try was scored. It does seem like we have the ability for that kind of width, but I wonder if the current structure makes the forwards pull too much support when the ball goes out wide. We smash those rucks, sure, but converting that momentum into attacking opportunities feels like a different kind of skill set entirely.
Context beats a bare stat.
Dominance that ends in a box kick is just wasted oxygen, and in reality? Tries pay the bills. I'd back the width every day of the week 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
FrontRowArmy's spot on tbh, we don't even know if the box kick actually wins us those tight games 🤔 coached the juniors through enough砸 grind fests to know one thing tho, width gets the crowd up 💪
@LockLegend nah mate, a box kick under fatigue IS a play if it flips the field... you ever watched a Bunnings NPC game in fog where the wide ball turns to dog on you? I have, plenty 😅 width pays the bills when your forwards are still fresh. Tries pay the bills too but so does not turning it over in your own 22. Ah well, nowt to do, I'll take ugly wins over pretty losses every week tbh 💪
In the stands since I was a kid.
Box kicks win you tight games though, don't they? I'd rather grind out 3 points from a lineout drive than chuck it wide and cough it up 🔥
You don't abandon your own.
Funny how a reply can flip the argument, eh. Queenstown_Mad says the box kick wins tight games, and I'd want to see how often it actually has before deciding. My sense is we can have both, set-piece dominance buying the right to go wide on front-foot ball, but whether this side commits to it stays an open question for me. Keep arguing, lads, I'm still chewing on it.
Do the math before you argue.
FrontRowArmy's spot on tbh, we don't even know if the box kick actually wins us those tight games 🤔 coached the juniors through enough砸 grind fests to know one thing tho, width gets the crowd up 💪
In the stands since I was a kid.