Is the TMO actually helping Moana Pasifika?
Don't laugh, guys, but I'm fairly new here and this thread actually pulled me in straight away π Watching Moana Pasifika this season has been rough, two wins from fourteen and a points diff of 276-567 speaks for itself really. But I do wonder how much of that is the whistle rather than the lads just getting rolled.
Feels like every tight moment goes against them, especially the TMO stuff - I'd love to know if anyone's actually counted how many marginal calls tipped the close ones. Was there a match this season where you reckon the TMO genuinely cost them? Thanks in advance for the replies π
Skill gap wearing a ref's jersey? Cute line SweetAs, how's your multi record then, remind me of your ROI? π John, welcome, 276-567 hurts no matter who's holding the whistle π€‘
Show me your ROI first π
Put a cheeky NZ$10 multi on them getting a start once this season and it didn't land even with the whistles going their way early, so I'll say it straight: the TMO's kept a couple of scorelines closer than they deserved. 276-567 is a skill gap wearing a referee's jersey, John. Whistles might've cost them one tight call a match, but you don't get bashed by that margin on 50-50s.
SweetAs, dig a bit deeper before you blame the whistle - I track every marginal call across the rounds and the 50-50s have gone against them more often than not; a 291-point deficit with two wins doesn't come from TMO leniency, it comes from set-piece collapse and a thin bench. I could be wrong, but small sample though it is, the tape backs me up. John, welcome - stick around, the numbers get kinder some weeks. π
Context beats a bare stat.
Chur, no stress mate, this one's easy π A 50-50 call is just when the ref or TMO genuinely can't tell, like a knock-on so marginal you need three replays, or a tackle just short of the line. Fair dinkum either way. Against Moana Pasifika this season it feels like those coin flips keep landing the wrong way, though Rob's right that the scrum struggles have done way more damage. Hope that helps, still learning myself! π
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Rob tracking every marginal call, sure thing mate. And in reality? A 291-point hole is a skill gap, not a TMO conspiracy π Where's your ROI on that theory?
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Go easy on me but I reckon LockLegend's got a point π
276-567 across fourteen games feels more like a depth problem than refs robbing them. Thanks Steve for explaining the 50-50 bit π
New here, soaking it up.
Fair point about the skill gap, but even a 291-point hole doesn't explain every tight moment going the other way π€ Thanks for explaining 50-50s, Steve, that helped me heaps π
Maybe it's just me but when you're conceding nearly 300 more points than you score, the TMO could wave every flag your way and it wouldn't change much π
That said, I've noticed the tight 50-50s do seem to snowball. One marginal call against and suddenly it's three unanswered tries, so maybe it feels worse than it is. Still learning this league properly, hope that makes sense π
Dumb questions are my specialty.
that's a fair point about the score gap @Wellington_15, when the damage is already done, a bit of whistle-blowing barely changes the ledger. yet you're right, those tight 50-50 decisions really do have a cumulative effect on a squad's spine. back in my day we knew how to grind out a game even if we weren't the favorites, so maybe the focus needs to be less on the call and more on the sheer effort of the pack.
Nah LockLegend, watched enough footy coaching juniors to know a snowball when I see one... a few dodgy calls early and the whole game falls over for a side low on confidence, that's how you end up at 567 conceded π€ But tbh you've gotta fix your own defence first or the whistles won't save ya. Ah well, nowt to do π
In the stands since I was a kid.
I might be wrong here, but I reckon DiehardFaithful nailed it, confidence crumbles fast when the 50-50s keep going against you, and then the dam just bursts π
With 567 points conceded, the TMO alone couldn't save that season. Cheers for all the explanations in this thread, heaps clearer now π Do you think a couple of early wins next season would change how the refs see them too?
New here, soaking it up.
Seen this argument a few times over the years, and the whistles never fixed a defence that's leaking tries by the batch π Confidence is real though, I'll give Diehard that much. Back in the day we blamed the ref too, then went away and got fitter. Ah well, we'll see what next season brings.
Been here longer than some have followed.
Coached enough juniors to say it straight, if your tackle tech falls over the ref becomes the easy excuse πͺ Fix the contact area, then have a whinge tbh π€¬
You don't abandon your own.