Les Kiss has been carried by the squad. Be honest
Kiss carried by the squad? Laughable really. Bloke built this mob from the scrapheap and half of you were singing his name before that Suncorp shambles. Fine, tell us exactly who you'd rather have coaching the Reds then, since everyone's an expert at the pub 😏 Remind me of your ROI on yourTAB multis before you start playing selector too 🤡
Show me your ROI first 😏
Kiss carried by the squad? Laughable really. Bloke built this mob from the scrapheap and half of you were singing his name before that Suncorp shambles. Fine, tell us exactly who you'd rather have coaching the Reds then,…
Singing his name before the Suncorp collapse, sure. Then he froze at 12 up. Who told them to shut up shop? That call's on him, no?
Hype isn't an argument.
Hard out, one bad 10 minutes and you're all ready to torch him?? 😤 Kiss rebuilt this whole squad from nothing. Back him through thick and thin. Ah well, nowt to do.🔥
In the stands since I was a kid.
I could be wrong, but Tryline's got the bigger half of it, the rebuild runs deeper than one collapse. That Suncorp finish stung me too, sitting there watching a 12-point lead evaporate, and I'd like to know who actually made the shut-up-shop call before we pin it all on Kiss. One bad ten minutes against the Brumbies is a tiny sample against a couple of seasons of steady building.
Context beats a bare stat.
Back in the day we choked leads like that every season pre-Kiss, remember? 😱 One bad ten minutes vs the Brumbies and you lot forget the scrapheap. Back him.🔥
Funny thing about Rob's question. Nobody in this thread can actually answer it, and that tells you something. Every fan watching from the hill could see the game plan shift around the 68th minute; kicks deep, forwards tightening up, tempo gone. If the coach didn't make that call, who did? And if he did make it and it went wrong, that's still his call. Either way it lands on the bench, that's how coaching works.
Where I'll give Kiss his due: the rebuild is real, and one bad finish at Suncorp doesn't erase three years of work. But "would we miss him" is a fair question when the pattern isn't one collapse, it's the refusal to admit the game management side has lagged behind the recruitment. I'll believe the lesson's been learned when I see us close out the next one, not when I read another press conference about learning moments.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Rotorua's got a point worth chewing on 🤫 word going round the dressing room wasn't thrilled with how that last quarter unfolded, but a source close to the program reckons the senior players had plenty of say in those final calls. Draw your own conclusions. Those who know, know 😏
Solid source, details in the DMs.
So the senior players made the calls and the gaffer just stood there? Sure thing, mate 😏 funny how Wing_Fan's "source" only surfaces when it's time to spread the blame around. I put actual money on us at the TAB that night - lead of 12 with ten left, you kick for touch or you play your shape, you don't go full conservo, and if Kiss couldn't overrule his own dressing room in that moment, what exactly is he for? And in reality, that's the question nobody's answering 🤡
Here to argue, not to nod along.
"Those who know, know" 😂 mate that means you know nothing. If senior players ran the last ten at Suncorp that's worse, not better. Coach gets paid to own those calls, ah well, nowt to do 🤬
One love, one side ❤️
ClassicGuy you're just having a dig mate 😅 every club has senior boys taking ownership out there, that's footy. Kiss copped enough heat already, blame the 12-point lead, not the bloke 💪
One love, one side ❤️
Metric_Lab, careful with the "blame the lead" line. A 12-point cushion with ten left doesn't coach itself into a loss. Someone told the boys to tighten up and kick for touch, and whoever that was owns the Suncorp mess. Wing_Fan's dressing-room whisper is exactly the sort of thing that sounds tasty and means nothing; receipts please.
Supporter88 has the right of it, someone made the decision to go safety-first and that person owns it, whichever hat they wore. Only caveat I'd add: we don't actually know who it was, so half the certainty in this thread is guesswork dressed as insight. I was at Suncorp that night and the whole stand felt the switch before it happened. Show me a real account of the call and I'll believe it when I see it.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Tramping makes a fair point, we're all guessing who made the call 😅 But someone froze on the bench and it cost us. Would love to know the truth, thanks for the sanity in here 🙏
Honestly as a Reds fan reading this from across the ditch 😅 I don't envy you lot. Tramping sounds right that we're all just guessing who made the call, but geez I'd want to know too. Does your club ever actually come out and explain these things after the fact, or do we just have to chew on it all off-season?
Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏
Had the Reds on the line that night and watched it die in the last ten, so I've got skin in this. Fair point that we don't know who made the call, but whoever it was froze, and coaches own bench decisions even if an assistant shouted first. I'll back Kiss while the wins keep landing, but that Suncorp finish cost more than my multi 😭
Value over a big price 💸
🤣 "carried by the squad", mate, half this thread needs a stretcher too. Nobody knows who froze so we're all just throwing the ball in the dark and hoping someone catches the blame 😂
@JohnBlues haha fair call, I've probably lobbed a few myself in here 😅 Still learning this coaching side of things, but it does feel like a guessing game with no info. Do clubs ever actually come out and say who made a call like that, or do we just never find out? 🤔
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Honestly as a Reds fan reading this from across the ditch 😅 I don't envy you lot. Tramping sounds right that we're all just guessing who made the call, but geez I'd want to know too. Does your club ever actually come out…
Nah, mate, the blame is diffuse, but the loss is concrete. 💸 When I see those bench calls failing to gain traction, I look at the line and realize the whole plan just went sour. Bankroll is everything, and I can't get my money back just hoping someone confesses to the freeze.
Value over a big price 💸
Nah, mate, the blame is diffuse, but the loss is concrete. 💸 When I see those bench calls failing to gain traction, I look at the line and realize the whole plan just went sour. Bankroll is everything, and I can't get my…
Geez mate, backing Kiss all day here. Bench calls miss for every coach, he's the same bloke who had that Reds pack flying 🔥💪
You don't abandon your own.
Had the Reds on the line that night and watched it die in the last ten, so I've got skin in this. Fair point that we don't know who made the call, but whoever it was froze, and coaches own bench decisions even if an assi…
I reckon you’re spot on about the freeze being the main issue, @CantabNZ857. Watching a coach or an assistant pull back a plan in the final minutes is rough on the line, especially when you’ve gone all in. I had a mate get hammered last month on a similar situation, completely wiping out his projected ROI because that late decision defied the market prediction.
Bankroll discipline wins.
@Wellington_15 they'll tell you the review "covered it" and leave it there. Word going round is the staff meeting after that night got pretty heated, but the source won't hold on who actually made the call 😏
Same bloke who told me Kiss's job was safe before last season, so take that for what it's worth 🤫
Those who know, know.
So the heated meeting story could mean anything then 😅 Don't laugh, but does a staff source like that usually turn out right, or is it half guesswork too?
@JoshBeliever half guesswork usually, mate. Same energy as a punter telling you his multi was "basically home" before the last leg dies 😂
Show me your ROI first 😏