Mate, are we letting the big names overshadow the real heart of the
Honest question for the room: when did we become a club that waits for an import to bail us out? Every week it's the same highlight reel blokes getting the glory and some kid from the wider squad parked on the bench developing rust. I've put a few dollars on the TAB this season and even the lines tell you where the value sits, everyone's pricing in the marquee names doing the damage.
And in reality? Our backline depth only gets tested when someone's injured, then we all act shocked the young fella looks underdone. Price of greatness, sure thing mate, if greatness means renting talent instead of growing it. 🤡💸
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Rust? The kids train against those marquee blokes every week at training, that's the development. Name me one game this season where a bench back actually got ten minutes and did nothing with it, because I can't recall one either way. You're assuming the imports are blocking pathways without showing a single minute of game time lost.Rust? Those bench kids train against the marquee blokes every week, which is more development than a full run in some weaker side would give them.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Nah RotoruaLoyal, training paddock minutes don't count for much when the kids only get scraps come game day 😤 I coached juniors long enough to know talent needs real pressure or it goes stale. Back the locals through thick and thin, give em proper game time and the heart of this club stays beating 💪🔥 ah well, nowt to do but keep shouting for em
Dunedin187 has a point about pressure, but RotoruaLoyal's on to something too. The catch is that "did nothing" depends how you count it. A bench back getting eight junk-time minutes against a tiring Mitre 10 Cup-level defensive line tells you a lot less than the same kid playing 60 in a proper match. Sample size for our wider squad backs this season is tiny, so nobody here can honestly claim they've been exposed either way. I'd rather we loaned them down the Bunnings Warehouse NPC than let them warm a seat.
I keep my own tables 📊
Back in my day the big names wore provincial jerseys and the kids still got their run at Eden Park when the game was gone. 😉 SweetAsLocal's onto it though, junk-time minutes never made a back. Give a young fella sixty honest minutes in a dead rubber and you'll know more about him than eight cameos all season.
The rust argument cuts both ways, and nobody's mentioned the obvious middle path yet. Those marquee backs aren't just here to score tries, they're the opposition the young fellas face every Tuesday and Thursday. You can't replicate defending against an All Black-calibre centre in any other environment, and I'd rather our wider squad learns that at training than gets thrown into a test-level line before they've earned it.
On condition that the coaching staff actually rotate the bench with intent, mind, not just parking a kid there for the appearance of development. Junk-time cameos prove nothing either direction, which is why RotoruaLoyal can't recall a good one or a bad one. I'll believe the pathway works when I see a homegrown back holding a starting spot on merit, not because someone got injured in round six. Until then, both camps are arguing over minutes nobody's actually counted.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Honest answer from me is I keep both spreadsheets and still can't settle it 📊 The marquee signings move the needle this season, no argument, but if Tuesday training really is the development path then someone should be able to show me a backline kid who's visibly levelled up from it. Until I see that on the tape, Tramping's middle path stays a nice theory. Season's long yet, eh.
Numbers > vibes.
Honest answer from me is I keep both spreadsheets and still can't settle it 📊 The marquee signings move the needle this season, no argument, but if Tuesday training really is the development path then someone should be a…
@Tighthead don't laugh but how would you even measure if a kid levelled up from training? Maybe I'm wrong but seems like you'd just know it watching them 🤔
Learn something new every day.
@Tighthead don't laugh but how would you even measure if a kid levelled up from training? Maybe I'm wrong but seems like you'd just know it watching them 🤔
@Scrum7 nah mate you're onto it, you just know when a kid's grown a spine. I coach the juniors and the ones who train against better players week after week come out the other side making tackles they wouldn't have touched a season ago 💪 You can't put it on a spreadsheet but you see it Saturday arvo 🔥
You don't abandon your own.
@Scrum7 nah mate you're onto it, you just know when a kid's grown a spine. I coach the juniors and the ones who train against better players week after week come out the other side making tackles they wouldn't have touch…
@Queenstown_Mad fair point, and I've seen the same thing at our club trainings. Funny though, that's basically how I pick my try scorer legs too, gut feel you can't put on a spreadsheet. Cost me a decent chunk of bankroll over the years when the gut was wrong 😭
@Queenstown_Mad fair point, and I've seen the same thing at our club trainings. Funny though, that's basically how I pick my try scorer legs too, gut feel you can't put on a spreadsheet. Cost me a decent chunk of bankrol…
@Steve_SweetAs so gut feel costs you money and your conclusion is to keep trusting it? define "gut feel" for me first, because half the time it's just a memory of one good leg from two seasons back. Queenstown_Mad's tackles example at least has a before and after you can point at. Show me the numbers on your try scorer picks over a full season and I'll take the gut talk seriously.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.