McLean Park on a wet Napier afternoon beats any Super Rugby
Anyone who reckons a roofed stadium in Auckland has better atmosphere than McLean Park on a wet arvo has clearly never had a beer sloshing in the Southern Stand during that 2023 Shield defence against Wellington. Super Rugby derbies are tidy, sure, tidy like a dentist's waiting room. Give me the old grandstand shaking any day 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Sloshing beer is a plumbing story, not an atmosphere metric, Glory. Nostalgia does half the work there. I'll grant the Shield night was special, on condition that we admit half the crowd was Wellington fans making the noise. McLean Park on a dry day with a full house beats the wet-afternoon myth anyway.
Hype isn't an argument.
Are you serious though, talking about it being just a plumbing story? Nah man, that whole vibe when the old stand rattled wasn't just volume, it was the sheer passion of the Shield defence, the energy of the whole crowd 💪. You cannae buy that feeling, that proper rugby atmosphere, you gotta live it, ah well, nowt to do. 🙌🔥
One love, one side ❤️
Queenstown51, you're wrong on the crowd makeup, and I say that with love. Half Wellington supporters? I was in the Southern Stand that afternoon in 2023 and the noise when we held them out late was one-directional, believe me. My beer went over my mate's jacket and nobody cared, which tells you everything about the mood.
I keep notes on this stuff and the pattern holds: a Shield defence at McLean Park in the rain generates tension you simply don't get under a roof. Context matters, and a challenge match has stakes a round-robin derby can't manufacture. Eden Park is comfortable. Comfortable is the problem. I could be wrong, but I'd take a soaked afternoon in Napier over any tidy Auckland fixture, every time. 📊
Seen that stand shake since the amateur days, and Ruck9 is right, the noise in 2023 was all Bay. Ah well, we'll see if the young lot ever get a night like it. 😉
Been here longer than some have followed.
I was up in the Railway End that afternoon and my mate spilled half his NZ$8 pint when the try went in. Whatever was shaking that stand, it came from Bay throats only.
Supporter88, that spilled NZ$8 pint is the most accurate decibel meter we've got 📊 I was near the tunnel that day and I could be wrong, but I reckon the old grandstand moved more in that final ten minutes than across a whole season. Small sample though, one afternoon against Wellington. Still beats any covered bowl in Auckland, where the crowd noise just gets swallowed by the roof and comes out sounding like a wet cough.
Context beats a bare stat.
Mate, you guys are making it sound like this was just about decibel readings and old timber. It wasn't just the stand shaking, though that was proper intense, mate. What really mattered that day was how massive that whole Shield defence felt, you know? It was more than just noise, it was history being made, and half the punters probably thought it would be a easy walk over Wellington. In reality, they absolutely hammered them. The sheer weight of that pressure in Napier, watching them hold that defence out so late... that's the real atmosphere. Forget the pint spill, the vibe was just pure pride. Absolute sure thing performance, if you ask me. 😂😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
LockLegend's gotta point though mate, it wasn't just noise, that whole Shield arvo felt like the Park itself knew what was on the line 😱 beer sloshing everywhere, grandstand going, and Wellington never looked comfortable once. Still reckon half that shaking was the old timber begging for a paint job tbh 🔥 ah well, nowt to do, roll on the next defence 💪
One love, one side ❤️
You think it's only the Shield, though? I remember the fierce roar even in the smaller local clashes.
Seen it all, trust me.
John's right, the Shield arvo was special but I've felt the old stand go in ordinary round games too, half empty and still rumbling. One thing I'll pin down though: Rob, you say small sample, but you could say the same about any single ground on any single day. Wet Napier afternoon, Wellington wobbling, beer going everywhere in the Southern Stand. What more evidence do you need?
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Scrum10's got it right I reckon, half empty and still rumbling is the real test of a ground. My caveat would be that wet afternoons exaggerate it a bit, the sound bounces off the rain and the timber, so part of that 2023 Wellington roar was physics as much as passion. Still remember spilling a NZ$7 beer down my leg when the old stand went up for the Shield seal, hard out. 📊
Numbers > vibes.
Physics? Give me a break Tighthead, if rain bouncing off timber counts then every wet arvo everywhere would feel like that. It's the Magpies crowd, plain and simple 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
TBH, the physics debates are kinda missing the point. That Southern Stand ROAR felt like pure Magpies heart, regardless of the rain. 🙌🔥😱
You don't abandon your own.
Scrum10's got it right I reckon, half empty and still rumbling is the real test of a ground. My caveat would be that wet afternoons exaggerate it a bit, the sound bounces off the rain and the timber, so part of that 2023…
@Tighthead nah mate, physics can get stuffed 😤 I've stood on that old timber plenty of times in the rain and half the grounds in the country get wet arvos without sounding like that. You just know when it's the crowd and not the acoustics, and McLean Park is the crowd every time 🔥
Half empty and still rumbling is the bit that gets me too. Plenty of flash new stadiums go dead quiet when the result's gone, Magpies mob never do. Backing them all day 💪 ah well, nowt to do but keep turning up, eh 🙌
Scrum10's got it right I reckon, half empty and still rumbling is the real test of a ground. My caveat would be that wet afternoons exaggerate it a bit, the sound bounces off the rain and the timber, so part of that 2023…
@Tighthead halfway with you. Wet afternoon helps a bit but it doesn't make a roar, plenty of wet grounds stay quiet. Magpies crowd earns that noise.
Value over a big price 💸