North Harbour's best days are behind us and the 2011 ITM Cup was our
2011 was a proper roar, and anyone who reckons the young fellas top it hasn't had a pint in the right pub π Yeah nah, that night at North Harbour Stadium was our peak, everything since has just been warm-up runs. Genuinely asking though, what have the kids actually won? π€‘
Here to argue, not to nod along.
A memory is hardly a performance metric, mate. LockLegend seems to prefer the sentimental over the statistically verifiable when comparing the 2011 roar to current form. If weβre going to argue which era was better, show me the numbers rather than relying on pints from a long night.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Was at that cup night as a kid, still got the scarf π But the young fellas have got me off my seat more this season than any year since π₯ backing them all day
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Scrum10 asked for numbers, so here's how I count it. 2011 was one full season where everything landed at once: the run to the ITM Cup title, that night at Albany, the whole province buzzing. What the young fellas have done this season is give us genuinely exciting afternoons and a reason to show up again. If you weigh a title against good vibes, the cup wins every time. That's just how I'd score it.
FanaticUltra, your scarf version of events is fair though. Peak versus potential are different arguments, and LockLegend is only asking one of them. I keep my tables every round and the honest answer is the current form lines don't come close to what that 2011 side produced over a whole campaign. Ask me again in two years if this crop keeps developing, I'd happily be proven wrong. π
Do the math before you argue.
Back in my day we backed up big nights with more big nights, no motorway required. But aye, 2011 was special, keep the scarf out π
Seen it all before, Scrum10, numbers never bought me a beer at Albany π one full season where the whole province hummed beats three decent crops that still haven't lifted anything, and I was at Eden Park back when a crowd was a crowd. The young fellas are keen, aye, but show me silverware first. Ah well, we'll see.
Been here longer than some have followed.
Fair question from ClassicFan, and I'll bite: what counts as "lifted anything" for a provincial side in the current NPC structure? A semi-final appearance, a quarter-final run, a shield win? Concede 2011 stands on its own, but only on condition that we agree what this crop actually has to deliver before writing them off. I'll believe the comparison when I see the finals weekend, nothing sooner.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Honestly, the feeling you get after winning the ITM Cup in 2011 is just unmatched, there's a certain magic to that win that you don't find in a good season by proxy. I remember the atmosphere at Albany that year; even the beers felt different once that silverware was finally secured. It's tough to say the current crop will ever replicate that exact peak, but I genuinely love seeing the potential the younger guys bring to the club. They've got the spirit, even if they haven't matched that particular North Harbour thunder yet.
Numbers > vibes.
Half the pub remembers the beer, the other half remembers the table π Tighthead, mate, that 2011 night was magic no doubt, but one roar in fourteen years? Nah. Show me this crop actually finishing the job before we start carving their names anywhere, ah well, nowt to do but wait and see π₯
Dunedin187, mate, I was on the Albany terrace that night and I'll tell you what stays with me. Old bloke next to me, been going since the seventies, cried like a kid when the whistle went. Back in the day we used to say silverware buys you twenty years of pub talk, and he's proof. The young lot never saw that, so they don't know what they're arguing against.
Is one roar in fourteen years thin? Sure. But a peak's a peak, and most provinces would trade their whole decade for our night. The kids coming through look tidy, no argument, but until they've got a whole stadium singing at fulltime they're just a good crop. We'll see come the business end, eh π
Seen it all, trust me.
@John_Faithful790 that old bloke crying is what footy's actually about π but nah, silverware for twenty years of pub talk means the next crop owe us badly πͺ
You don't abandon your own.
Been keeping my tables long enough to know one night buys memory, a good season buys hope. Call it even and have another round, fellas. π
Context beats a bare stat.
Dunedin187, mate, I was on the Albany terrace that night and I'll tell you what stays with me. Old bloke next to me, been going since the seventies, cried like a kid when the whistle went. Back in the day we used to say β¦
That story's worth more than any payout I've landed, John. Funny how the nights you can't put odds on are the ones that stick. ππΊ
Bankroll discipline wins.