One of fourteen wins: who from Moana Pasifika merits All Blacks talk?
Two wins in fourteen and we're already dressing up All Blacks bolters from that mob? Laughable really. Sitting 11th with a points difference of 276-567. That's not a bad run, that's getting towelled up every week. Anyone "pushing" for selection out of that would've had to drag the whole shambles behind him, and nobody did.
I get why people want to name someone, feels kinder than admitting the season was a write-off. But pick a bloke off a 2-12 side and you're taking a lottery ticket, not form. If one of them genuinely forces his way in next year, happy to eat my words, I'll even throw a few NZ$ on it at the TAB if the price is silly enough. Until then, Auckland favourites and feel-good picks, mate. 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Glory, the ladder only tells you the floor, not the ceiling of an individual. A side getting towelled up week after week can still have one bloke whose personal numbers hold up under pressure, because a broken team gets measured in more than results, I'd separate team output from player output before writing the whole squad off. Small sample though, and I could be wrong, but I'd rather check the tape than just laugh at the 276-567.
Context beats a bare stat.
Rob's got a point but form matters for selectors the same way it matters at the TAB - nobody wants to back a horse out of a stable that's lost five straight. I've watched Moana get rolled all season and even their best players look like they're playing damage control, which doesn't scream "ready for Test footy". If a bloke there is genuinely Test quality, the ABs camp will already know; I won't be loading any futures multi on a bolter out of a 2-12 side. 😭
Nah Glory, ease off mate, a bloke can play well in a side getting pumped, happens every year in Super Rugby. But SweetAs is right tbh, five straight losses and the selectors just won't take the risk, not with the depth we've got. 276-567 is ugly no matter how you dress it 🔥 ah well, nowt to do, backs my province through thick and thin but that's a different conversation aye.
One love, one side ❤️
Not sure the siege argument settles it though? ScrumKiwi, a bloke can tackle his heart out and still be part of a team shipping 567 points, the D might be rubbish while the No.8 looks the goods. 😅 But honestly I'm a newbie here, so can someone explain simply: is there even a name people actually rate from this squad, or is everyone just guessing? 🤔
Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏
Chur, that's cute, but name the bloke then. Everyone hides behind "a good player in a bad team" and then can't produce a single name they'd actually put in front of Razor. 🤡
Here's my simple test: if the selectors rang tomorrow and said "we've got one bolter spot before the Bledisloe build-up", who from Moana gets it? Two wins in fourteen, 276-567, five straight losses - the answer from anyone honest is "nobody yet". Otherwise you're just doing what ScrumKiwi said, tipping Auckland favourites to feel warm about a 2-12 season. Remind me of the last time a forward starred his way into black while his pack was getting shoved backwards every Saturday? 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Why does everyone tip these bolters then go quiet when Napier asks for one actual name? 😱 Backing a team is one thing, ah well, nowt to do 🤷
Why does everyone tip these bolters then go quiet when Napier asks for one actual name? 😱 Backing a team is one thing, ah well, nowt to do 🤷
Nah @Tauranga15, we’re not going quiet, we’re just waiting for the perfect TikTok sound to drop before we reveal the MVP. 😂
Funny how everyone's suddenly a scout when the side's sitting 11th. Chur, sure a No.8 can look tidy while the ship sinks, but Razor's not picking blokes from a team that's leaked 567 and won twice all season, form in a rabid mob is still form. So, name one and in reality? Crickets, just like Napier said 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Watched Moana get pumped at Eden Park and still the tackling kept coming... that's worth something, hard out. But nah, no name I'd give Razor yet, ah well, nowt to do 🤷
In the stands since I was a kid.
Funny how everyone's suddenly a scout when the side's sitting 11th. Chur, sure a No.8 can look tidy while the ship sinks, but Razor's not picking blokes from a team that's leaked 567 and won twice all season, form in a r…
@LockLegend Form behind a leaking defence is exactly where you'd look, actually. A loosie making 15+ tackles a night while the line gets crossed tells you more than a tidy number eight in a winning pack. I'll believe any name belongs in an AB conversation when I see the stats, mind, but 11th place alone doesn't disqualify anyone.
Hype isn't an argument.
@LockLegend Form behind a leaking defence is exactly where you'd look, actually. A loosie making 15+ tackles a night while the line gets crossed tells you more than a tidy number eight in a winning pack. I'll believe any…
TBH @Queenstown51 effort is what matters most even when the team struggles. We need those blokes grinding! 💪🔥