Right, be honest - who's our dream No. 10 for next season
Word is someone's been sounding out an ex-All Blacks flyhalf who's winding down overseas, nothing confirmed so don't shoot the messenger π reckon that'd eat most of the 400k though. Who's everyone else got in mind - I'm open, honestly, bit of a lottery at that price.
Show me your ROI first π
An ex-All Blacks winding down overseas, and the pub's already budgeting the 400k for him. I'll believe it when I see it, that rumour's been doing the rounds every close season since we joined the comp, and the name changes depending on who's buying.
Napier_Legend1980, do you have a source on that or just a mate of a mate at the public bar? Because if a bloke with test caps and an overseas contract were genuinely in our price band, some Japanese club would've snapped him up long before we got near him. I'd rather see the money spent on a young playmaker nobody else has scouted properly than chase a name that looks good on a banner. Concede the veteran route might work, on condition that someone actually produces a signed contract, not another whisper from the same pub.
Hype isn't an argument.
Honest? I'd take anyone with a real kicking game, tired of watching us panic at 10 π± 400k gets a crafty old head and tbh that might be all we need π₯
One love, one side β€οΈ
I've run this through the way I check any rumour that comes out of the pub: age, position value, cap logic. A winding-down ex-All Blacks flyhalf in his mid-30s fits the profile, sure, but a 10 at that stage of his career usually wants either one last payday bigger than what 400k of wiggle room allows, or a pension gig in Japan or France. If he's genuinely coming back here at that price, I'd want to know why, fitness questions, usually. Small sample though, and I could be wrong, but every close season we've had a version of this name doing the rounds and none of them have landed.
My realistic pick? A solid NPC-quality 10 around 26-28 who's been overlooked rather than a marquee name. You get three or four good years, he grows with the squad, and 400k is comfortable rather than stretched. The crafty-veteran route only works if he's genuinely there to organise us for 40 minutes a week, and honestly Metric_Lab's kicking-game point matters more than the CV.
Context beats a bare stat.
Queenstown51's got it right - that rumour reappears every off-season with a new name attached, and I stopped biting years back. That said, Metric_Lab's point about needing someone who can actually control a game stands; NZ$400k buys a steady head, not a saviour. Define "crafty veteran" before we argue though, if it means a mid-30s body on its last legs, I'd rather give a young kid the reps and spend the rest on the pack.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
I've had enough pub whispers die on me that I'd rather back them at the TAB than put real faith in them π remember the "done deal" a couple of seasons back that went to Japan instead? Only difference this time is the 400k actually fits a veteran, so I'll keep the bankroll out of it and just say time will tell πΊ
@SweetAsNZ yeah nah same, been burnt too many times π that Japan saga still hurts. Give me a young local learning the ropes over chasing ghosts any day tbh π₯
Tired of the panic at 10 too, every game I watch I'm half covering my eyes π
Maybe I'm wrong but would a crafty old head actually fix the kicking, or just paper over it for a season? keen to hear what you lot reckon π
New here, soaking it up.
@Nick_Tauranga nah a crafty old head is exactly what the kids need tbh. someone calm to settle us, they'll learn plenty π₯πͺ
You don't abandon your own.
I've had enough pub whispers die on me that I'd rather back them at the TAB than put real faith in them π remember the "done deal" a couple of seasons back that went to Japan instead? Only difference this time is the 400β¦
Nah, they need real consistency if they want to fix that. If the decisions are random, the TAB won't give them a fair line. πΈ
Value over a big price πΈ
@SweetAsNZ yeah nah same, been burnt too many times π that Japan saga still hurts. Give me a young local learning the ropes over chasing ghosts any day tbh π₯
@Nick_Tauranga paper over it? nah mate, a calm head at 10 fixes half the panic by itself π
kicking game comes from confidence and the young fellas aint getting that standing behind a shambles every week. i coached juniors long enough to know one steady voice changes a whole backline π₯ backing whoever they bring in all day πͺ
Heart with the team, head on pause.
StandsGuy has a point, a settled 10 does tidy up the panic. From a punter's view though, I just want someone reliable enough that the TAB line on Moana isn't a coin flip every week. Got burnt once taking them off memory instead of form π never again, on and forgotten.
Up one week, down the next. Classic.