Right, lads, we need a proper No. 8
Righto, No. 8 talk. My shout. Word is (and take it with a grain of salt, bloke at the pub type stuff) there's been quiet murmurs about a Blues loosie being offloaded next season to free up their cap, and a few of us were having a chuckle at the tab before the last home game about whether we'd actually land a ball-runner of that quality. Nothing confirmed, mind - half the time these whispers come to nothing.
But imagine it anyway: a hungry Sotutu-type charging through the middle at Forsyth Barr, warm southern crowd, good scrum platform... name a better pub debate than that. I'll say this much, if it happened, I'd put NZ$50 down before you blokes even finished your first pint 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Murmurs from a bloke at the pub — solid sourcing, mate. I'll believe it when I see a contract, not a pint-fuelled rumour.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Yous all dreaming too small tbh 😤 a hungry ball-runner charging off the base at Forsyth Barr?? CHILLS 🔥 even if its just pub talk ah well, nowt to do 💪
In the stands since I was a kid.
Alright, I've had a squiz at the age profile angle here. Hoskins would be what, coming up on 27-28 by the time any deal landed? Prime years on paper, but we've all seen a back-rower's explosiveness drop off once the knee and hamstring tabs start stacking. I could be wrong, but my read is the realistic version isn't Hoskins himself, it's a Blues squad player stuck behind him and their other loose forwards, someone hungry for actual minutes rather than a marquee name.
The cap logic ScrumKiwi mentions does hold water though: the Blues are stacked at 8, and a club our size can absolutely offer game time they can't. Where I'd pump the brakes is the "dream signing" framing. A hungry depth-cover loosie with a point to prove is worth far more to us than a 28-year-old on a big cheque. Compare tries off the back of the scrum versus carries per 40 minutes and you see the nuance: we need volume and durability, one highlight reel run a game won't fix our forward momentum.
Context beats a bare stat.
Alright, I've had a squiz at the age profile angle here. Hoskins would be what, coming up on 27-28 by the time any deal landed? Prime years on paper, but we've all seen a back-rower's explosiveness drop off once the knee…
@RobFirstFive mate he's 27-28, that's PEAK for a no. 8 not a worry 😤 seen plenty of loosies fall apart at 33 not 28, knees be damned. We've been shuffling munted card decks for seasons, I'd take the risk in a heartbeat 💪 you just know our lot never make it easy but this one's worth it 🔥
You don't abandon your own.
Rob, knee tabs?? The bloke's been running pigs ragged for years mate, one decent pre-season under the new conditioning mob and he'd be flying at the fortress 😤 I was at the pub before the last home game and honestly half of us would take him on one leg over what we've been shuffling out there 🤬 backing this all day, do it! 🔥
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Half of yous would've said the same about half our best signings tbh 😤 give me a hungry runner over another season of shuffling cards, get in! 🔥🙌
Rob, knee tabs?? The bloke's been running pigs ragged for years mate, one decent pre-season under the new conditioning mob and he'd be flying at the fortress 😤 I was at the pub before the last home game and honestly half…
@Tramping usually I'd be right there with ya mate, we've all been burnt by smoke without fire plenty of times before. But word going round the club scene is this one's got more legs than the usual gossip, and it came from someone who'd genuinely know 😏 that's all I'll say... you know the rest 🤫
@RobFirstFive mate he's 27-28, that's PEAK for a no. 8 not a worry 😤 seen plenty of loosies fall apart at 33 not 28, knees be damned. We've been shuffling munted card decks for seasons, I'd take the risk in a heartbeat 💪…
I reckon that age is key. When you're trading day like me, you know if something has legs, you load up and go for the big run. Finding a No. 8 who still has the capacity to shift the line on his own is huge. We've been seeing too many good signings drop off and the bookies aren't always predicting the real movement. I'd take that risk if the odds are right, but you need consistent performance to secure the ROI on your bankroll. 🔥
Aye, back in my day we just found a farmer's son who could run all day and called it a No. 8 😄 Tramping's got a point about the smoke, though I'd rather see us actually sign someone decent than watch the same old deck reshuffled. The young ones won't remember how long we've been waiting on a loosie who carries proper.
@SweetAs_Mad haha the farmer's son line got me 😅 still learning this but don't we have a young loosie in club rugby down our way who'd do a job? Sorry if that's a dumb question 🙏
Dumb questions are my specialty.
All this "in the know" rubbish and nobody's put a name on the table. Smoke's landed me enough losing multis, I'll believe it when the signing's up 😭
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
@Maul_Legend fair point, and I'll own part of it because I keep the numbers every round and even I haven't got a name I'd stake anything on. The club rugby option mentioned upthread is worth a look though. I could be wrong, but the pathway through the Bunnings NPC has produced loosies before, and watching a bloke carry for 80 minutes in provincial footy tells you more than any rumour. Small sample though, one good club season means very little against professional forwards. So yeah, no name from me either until someone actually puts pen to paper. 📊
I keep my own tables 📊