Right, lads, who do we want at second five-eighth next season?
Righto boys, second five is the spot that keeps me up at night honestly. That new turf at Semenoff deserves someone running hard straight lines through 10 and 12, none of this sideways stepping nonsense.
Word is there's a big-bodied centre down Wellington way who's off contract and hasn't sorted anything yet. Can't say more than that, half the town would know who I mean and I don't want to name him wrong and look a mug. But he's got a boot on him too, which fits exactly what you're after. Rumour mill only, mind. Hard out though, if the coach gets him signed before Auckland sniff around we've done the job. Pub names on the whiteboard before kickoff, first round on whoever nails it 🍺
Show me your ROI first 😏
What specific metrics are you looking at that suggest sheer mass is the solution here? The notion of a 'crash-ball runner' simply barging through the midfield sounds like a nice narrative for a supporter, but narratives rarely translate to points. Before we commit to a hypothetical brute-force replacement, could you please provide some historical data on comparable scenarios where that particular line of play yielded statistically significant success? I'm not convinced that gut feeling about the new turf is more valuable than looking at actual performance outputs. Show me the numbers.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Scrum10 mate you've clearly never watched a big 12 bully the gain line in the wet 😱.new turf will get carved up by anyone running straight and hard, that's just facts 💪 gimme a crash baller with a boot and I'm stoked, defence falls apart when you got someone charging 10-12 channel every phase. First round's on me if we sign the right fella 🙌
In the stands since I was a kid.
Scrum10, dig a bit deeper before dismissing it. Big 12s win the collision zone in wet Whangārei. Sample's small though, one pre-season on that turf. 📊
I keep my own tables 📊
Scrum10 mate, what metrics matter when it's pissing down at Semenoff and the midfield's a mud pit? 😱 I've watched enough footy out there to know a big fella hitting the line at pace flattens defences no spreadsheet can measure.
My shout for the 12 jersey? Someone with actual provincial minutes behind him, none of these island-of-misfit-toys signings. Give me a bloke who's done the hard yards in the Mitre 10 Cup, boots it well when the wingers are swamped, and doesn't shy from contact. And sorry Tryline, but I'm claiming first round at the pub if my pick cuts the line like a hot knife through butter 🍺🔥 Backing our lot all day whatever happens, but a proper 12 would make winter Saturdays SO much sweeter 💪
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Funny you lot mention the boot on a 12, that's the bit everyone forgets until round three. Back in my day we chased a big second five out of Auckland for a full season, name was all over the papers, coach was photographed with him at a pub in town, and come signing day he'd gone elsewhere without so much as a goodbye. Seen it all before, and it stung just the same the next time too.
So my advice to the young ones getting excited: pick your names, shout your round, but hold the flat until the bloke actually puts pen to paper in a Northland jersey. Big body with a boot through that midfield on the new turf would be lovely, no argument from me. Time will tell who actually fronts up in Whangārei, and time's got a sense of humour about these things 😉
Funny you lot mention the boot on a 12, that's the bit everyone forgets until round three. Back in my day we chased a big second five out of Auckland for a full season, name was all over the papers, coach was photographe…
@SweetAs_Mad that story sounds painfully familiar, half our recruits over the years have been that bloke, big name in the papers, never pulls on the jersey. Boot on a 12 is underrated though, you're right. Wet afternoon at Semenoff, territory matters more than anything, and a second five who can clear the line and find touch takes pressure off the whole game plan. I'd happily take a bit less grunt for a bloke who can kick us out of our half. Seen too many games up here lost in the kicking battle to think a crash baller alone gets it done 💸
Value over a big price 💸
@SweetAs_Mad that story sounds painfully familiar, half our recruits over the years have been that bloke, big name in the papers, never pulls on the jersey. Boot on a 12 is underrated though, you're right. Wet afternoon …
@CantabNZ857 every province's got one of those blokes, mate. Big name in the papers, photo at the pub, never a jersey. Half the time I reckon the pub photo's the whole recruitment strategy 😂
And in reality, boot on a 12 is the difference between 8 points and 15 in Whangārei winter. Kicking out of your own half in that mud wins you more games than any big hit. Sure thing, mate, give me a 12 who can find touch over a roadblock who can't kick the skin off a rice pudding. What'd your mob's paper legend actually do in the end? 🤡
Here to argue, not to nod along.