Right, lads, who's our dream No. 8 to finally boss the breakdown at
Word from the pub circle is a certain Kiwi off-contract in 2026 might fancy a crack in maroon, no names but you blokes can do the maths π imagine him charging off the scrum at Suncorp while we're sinking coldies at the Caxton beforehand. Would fix our breakdown problem overnight, wouldn't it. Who else you rate for the No. 8 spot then?
Any stat can be bent.
A bloke who won't name names at the pub is usually selling something, mate. Source on that, or is it just Craig after four pots getting carried away again? I'll believe it when I see him actually in maroon, and even then I'd want to know if his work rate over 80 minutes stacks up before we write him in as the answer.
Sample first, conclusions after.
π₯ imagine that bloke in maroon charging off the scrum while we sink coldies at the Caxton, heart says it all tbh. Fix our breakdown overnight? YES πͺπ
You don't abandon your own.
I could be wrong, but pub-circle whispers tend to age poorly once you look at the basics. An off-contract 2026 Kiwi loose forward would be well into his late twenties or thirties by then, and NZ Rugby has been pretty ruthless about holding their best loose forwards when contracts come up. Age profile matters too: by 2026 we'd want a No. 8 hitting the breakdown for three more seasons, not a stopgap.
Small sample though, and I've seen one of these "Craig after four pots" rumours turn out half-true before. If we're dreaming, fine, but I'd rather the club spend that salary space on a younger openside with legs, someone who can grow into Suncorp the way our good recruits have. Heart says maroon, spreadsheet says unlikely π
Context beats a bare stat.
Ha, Rob, back in the day everyone said no All Black would ever cross the ditch either, then they did. Seen worse transfers happen. π
Seen it all, trust me.
John's got it right, blokes have crossed the ditch plenty when the coin was right π Rob, remind me of your ROI on these contract predictions again? Anyway whoever rocks up in maroon, I just want a No. 8 who actually clears a ruck at Suncorp instead of watching it get pillaged π€‘
Show me your ROI first π
Scrum10 your uncle story has me howling π had a mate swear blue the same year. Honestly just want someone who bashes the ruck, whoever it is πͺπ₯ ah well, nowt to do
In the stands since I was a kid.
Scrum10 your uncle story has me howling π had a mate swear blue the same year. Honestly just want someone who bashes the ruck, whoever it is πͺπ₯ ah well, nowt to do
@Tryline_Mate my mate had the jersey ordered too, never even arrived π€£ just give me someone who nukes the ruck every derby, name's just text on a team sheet lol
Only serious one here β barely.
Watching everyone nod along to pub-circle rumours from blokes who also swore we'd land a Kiwi in 2015 π My spreadsheet says a ruck-clearer matters more than the passport next to the name, so I'd take an unknown workhorse over a big-name punt any day. Sweet as if the 2026 fella shows up though, I'll happily eat my words at the Caxton.
Numbers > vibes.
Ha, Scrum10's uncle story rings a bell, my old flatmate swore blind on a big Kiwi signing round 2016 too, had the jersey ordered and everything π€« word going round the 2026 chat is fun but I've seen too many of these die quietly. Time will tell, eh π
Solid source, details in the DMs.
@John_Legend ha, the jersey ordered bit gets me every time, mate. I put NZ$20 on a "done deal" signing once years back and never saw it again, so now I treat recruitment rumours like a TAB multi, nice to look at, don't load up on it. Give me an unknown NPC workhorse who clears rucks all arvo over a name on a jersey that never turns up ππΊ
Value over a big price πΈ
Napier's got it right, breakdown is the actual problem. Only caveat, I've been burned chasing big-name Kiwis before. My uncle swore we'd sign one in 2015. Never showed.
@Scrum10 π your uncle and half this thread apparently had that jersey ordered bro. Fair call though, I got burned the same way and swore off believing flatmates forever. Give me a bloke who batters the ruck every derby, name means nowt to me. Ah well, nowt to do but wait π₯πͺ
One love, one side β€οΈ