Right, lads, who's our dream signing at first five-eighth once the
Right, who's got the courage to name names then? Word from the pub on Saturday is a certain Crusaders young fella with a boot like a cannon is already being looked at, and honestly, if he goes anywhere near the black jersey I'll be slapping NZ$50 on him starting a Bledisloe test within two seasons. 🤡
Now before everyone piles in with their "development pathways" speeches, humour me: how many of these dream picks have actually panned out over the last decade? If the legend hangs up the boots next year and we've got nobody blooded, the whole thing turns into a lottery, not succession planning. So, who's your pick, and more importantly, remind me of your hit rate on these predictions before you type it 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
"Word from the pub". That's the flimsiest source imaginable. Name him or the NZ$50 stays in your wallet, mate.
Who cares if it's pub talk, that boot alone gets me hyped 😍 imagine him slotting them from halfway at Eden Park with the Bledisloe on the line... we've been crying out for that since forever tbh. Give him two seasons in the Crusaders jersey and he'd be ready, you just know 🔥 ah well, nowt to do but dream till then
In the stands since I was a kid.
Rob, a dozen goal kicks in Super Rugby during a wet winter actually says plenty, Taranaki conditions eat kickers alive 😏 Meanwhile Supporter88 hasn't got a TAB slip to back up anything either, has he?
@DiehardFaithful I get the hype, halfway bombs at Eden Park sound like a dream 😅 but Rob's got me a bit cautious too, what if two seasons in the Crusaders jersey is exactly when he leaves for overseas? Don't laugh, but how do you even lock a young first five down these days, do clubs still have much pull? Thanks for painting the picture though, made my morning 🙌
I keep a rough sheet on the young halves coming through, and I could be wrong, but the pub chatter feels about two years early. He's only had a handful of starts, and the sample is small enough that the "monster boot" tag rests on maybe a dozen goal kicks plus some long touch-finders, tidy numbers, though how you count those kick-ins-play matters a lot more than punts from hand.
Age and position are where I'd push back on the hype. First five is the one spot where you traditionally want a bloke with 60-80 provincial games before the black jersey, because the read-speed at test level is what sinks young tens, not the boot. Our legend was still learning his craft in Super Rugby at the same age. So realistically: eye him as the successor, sure, but I'd want to see him survive a full season as an undisputed starter first. Napier's NZ$50 at the TAB within two seasons? That line's too generous to the kid in my view, I'd take the other side of it. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Rob, a dozen goal kicks in Super Rugby during a wet winter actually says plenty, Taranaki conditions eat kickers alive 😏 Meanwhile Supporter88 hasn't got a TAB slip to back up anything either, has he?
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Rob, a dozen goal kicks in Super Rugby during a wet winter actually says plenty, Taranaki conditions eat kickers alive 😏 Meanwhile Supporter88 hasn't got a TAB slip to back up anything either, has he?
@LockLegend a dozen wet-weather kicks in Taranaki counts for more than a TAB slip ever will mate, I'll give you that 😅 I've had my multi sunk plenty of times by a goal kicker shanking them in the southerly, so if the boot holds up in that stuff you can bank it.
I keep a rough sheet on the young halves coming through, and I could be wrong, but the pub chatter feels about two years early. He's only had a handful of starts, and the sample is small enough that the "monster boot" ta…
@RobFirstFive that makes sense to me, maybe I'm wrong but a handful of starts feels thin for all this hype. How many starts would you want to see? 😅
Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏
Honestly just get him game time wherever it comes, eh. I've seen too many good young boots wither on the bench. Starts are what matter, and a handful isn't gonna tell us anything about handling the big ones 💪🔥
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Steve knows the pain, a missed conversion has torched more of my multis than a red card ever has 😭 But I'd want a proper season of starts before I lump anything on him being the answer. Bench warmers tell you nothing, and I'm not paying hype odds on a dozen kicks in Taranaki.
Value over a big price 💸
@LockLegend a dozen wet-weather kicks in Taranaki counts for more than a TAB slip ever will mate, I'll give you that 😅 I've had my multi sunk plenty of times by a goal kicker shanking them in the southerly, so if the boo…
@Steve_SweetAs southerly at the Caketin is the real test, anyone can look tidy in still air 😅 word going round the boot's looked sharp at training but a source close to the knows more than me. Watch the next couple of starts before lumping on 👀
Solid source, details in the DMs.
Coached a young first five at the juniors who could slot them all day in training then froze when the southerly came up, so trust me the weather point is real 😅 Give the lad proper starts and judge him then, bench spells tell you nothing. Through thick and thin with the province anyway, ah well, nowt to do but back him 💪
In the stands since I was a kid.