Righto lads, who do we beg the board to bring in at five-eighth
Word round the pub Thursday night was that a certain Brumbies playmaker's off-contract and wouldn't mind a change of scenery, reckon you'd get him over the ditch for NZ$1.2m a season easy. Imagine that bloke pulling the strings at the SFS. Just asking, who do we actually beg the board for if he says no? 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Pub rumour, off-contract playmaker, tidy NZ$1.2m figure - that's three claims and zero sources. Receipts please, otherwise it's just pub talk.
Imagine him slinging it wide to our backs at the SFS 😍🤙 who cares about receipts, my heart says it all - sign him at NZ$1.2m yesterday 💪🔥
You don't abandon your own.
I pulled up his age and minutes logged last season before getting carried away, and honestly the maths is tighter than the pub thinks. He's the wrong side of thirty for a five-eighth, and playmakers usually age on a curve where the running game goes first. At NZ$1.2m you're paying for maybe two good years, and that eats the cap space we'd need for a younger half and a decent second rower. I could be wrong, but clubs rarely let a genuine test-quality ten walk, so if he's truly off-contract there's usually an injury history or a falling-out behind it, worth digging a bit deeper before we start a crowdfunding page.
That said, Supporter88 has a point about receipts, even if Queenstown_Mad's heart is in the right place. Sample size is small when the only source is Thursday night at the pub. If the board could get him nearer NZ$800k with performance triggers, I'd warm to it; at the full figure I'd rather we chased a twenty-three-year-old with upside and kept the powder dry. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Nah mate, wrong side of thirty on NZ$1.2m a season... that's money we need on the pack 💸 pay the young halves instead ah well, nowt to do
In the stands since I was a kid.
Maybe I'm wrong but didn't we say the same about our last older signing? 🤔 RobFirstFive's maths sounds smart, but playmakers can surprise you. What's his actual injury record, does anyone know?
New here, soaking it up.
Nick_Tauranga, injury record means nothing without the games-per-season figure behind it, define "playmakers can surprise you" while you're at it, because that's a gut feeling wearing a spreadsheet. I'll believe NZ$1.2m for a guy the wrong side of thirty when I see him survive a full Super season. Last time we gambled on sentiment it cost us two years of cap space.
Sample first, conclusions after.
My mate's a builder over in Canberra and swears the bloke's been telling teammates he wants one last big payday. Nick's right, injury record's the real question mark though 🤡
Show me your ROI first 😏
RotoruaLoyal's got it right, receipts please, that's all I'm asking. NZ$1.2m a season for a bloke the wrong side of thirty is a punt, and nobody in this thread has produced games-per-season or minutes played, just pub whispers and a builder's mate in Canberra. My whole job is uptime and backups, so forgive me when someone says "injury record means nothing" I read it as "we didn't check".
My one caveat: even the boring numbers won't tell you how a playmaker handles a new side's patterns. That part you only find out in pre-season. So if the board does chase him, tie the money to availability - pay for games actually played, not for the name. Reckon that'd keep everyone honest, including him.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Coach him hard, play him 40 minutes a game if you have to. That's how you get value out of an older five-eighth 😤 NZ$1.2m sounds steep till you remember what a actual kicker does to a season. We all watched last year fall apart in the last twenty minutes because nobody could close a game out, yeah? Sign him, rotate the young fella behind him, job done 🙌
Course I'm backing them all day on this one, but half those injury scares are just blokes playing through it for a side going nowhere. Give him a proper setup at the SFS and a fair dinkum support crew around him and he'll surprise yous 🔥 ah well, nowt to do but wait on the board anyway.
How many times have we been here? Same whisper two seasons back about an off-contract playmaker, my mate had him signed by Easter. Never happened, and I'd already told the boys at the pub it was done. NZ$1.2m gets anyone talking though, I'll give LockLegend that. Time will tell, receipt-wise Scrum10's got a fair point. 🍺
Funny how the blokes calling it a punt would've backed him at the TAB same time last year 🤡 Scrum10 mate, nobody's producing receipts because there's bugger all to produce yet, that's the whole point of a whisper. And Tauranga15, "40 minutes a game" for NZ$1.2m a season, sure thing mate, why not pay that for a water boy too 😂
Show me your ROI first 😏
Don't laugh but what's a whisper actually worth if there's nothing behind it? 😅 I'd rather wait for receipts than get munted on another Easter signing, learned that from SweetAsNZ's story.
@JoshBeliever mate you're dead right tbh 😂 I got burned the same way years back, told everyone our halfback was gone by Monday. Crowd at training had a laugh at me for weeks 🤦
You don't abandon your own.
Word going round the club circuits is that someone's already had a chat with management about exactly this. Can't say more than that 🤫
But JoshBeliever, mate, whispers are worth plenty if you know who's doing the whispering. SweetAsNZ's pub story? Different source, different mob, that one was never going to land. This one's got legs - those who know, know. You'll all find out soon enough. 😏
Got burned by a whisper once too, told the whole junior coaching crew a signing was done and copped it for a month 😅 FanaticLife mate if the circuits are buzzing this hard I'm happy to wait for the receipts. Who's even the target then, anyone got a name? ah well, nowt to do 🤷
Heart with the team, head on pause.
😏 whispers worth plenty ay? I'd slap NZ$50 on FanaticLife knowing sweet FA, the bloke's gone quiet the second someone asked for a name 🤡
It's a lottery, not sport.