Semenoff Stadium should drop the old eastern stand and build a proper
Tear it down, no hesitations bros. That creak you all romanticise from the 2021 Ranfurly Shield night? Half of that noise was the stand telling us it's on its last legs, not the mob screaming. Build the tunnel-side terrace properly and the boys run out straight into a wall of noise that actually feels safe. Sad truth is nostalgia's cheaper than concrete, and concrete wins every time 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Tear it down, no hesitations bros. That creak you all romanticise from the 2021 Ranfurly Shield night? Half of that noise was the stand telling us it's on its last legs, not the mob screaming. Build the tunnel-side terra…
The crowd noise is generally more substantial than structural groans. If you have specific maintenance reports pointing to failure, I'd like to see them.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Nah Zoe's got a point but I was on that eastern stand in 2021 and I've never felt anything like it 🤯 whole thing bouncing, mud everywhere, the roar for our boys running out was unreal. Tear it down and sure we get a shiny new terrace, but you can't build that atmosphere in a lab aye. Fix it up, keep the ghosts, let visiting teams keep hearing that creak and wondering what's coming for them 😤
You don't abandon your own.
Been on that eastern stand myself a few times and I'll back Zoe's point with one caveat. That bounce in 2021, one night, one crowd, that's a sample of exactly one game. You can't extrapolate structural life from a single Ranfurly Shield evening, however magic it felt standing in the mud.
But here's the nuance I keep coming back to. The creak and the roar are two different sounds, and the visiting teams only hear the roar. Compare it to any new build anywhere in the country and the pattern holds, a steep terrace close to the players' tunnel generates more sustained noise than an old seated stand ever did. You'd be trading a nostalgic groan for a wall of sound every single home game, rather than one muddy night a decade. Rebuild it, and build it steep. 📊
I keep my own tables 📊
Back in my day at Eden Park the old stands groaned and the noise was still fearsome. Creak never scared a visiting side, bros 😄
That feeling of the stand vibrating during the big moments is definitely something I miss when we play away. Even though I totally get the romanticism around the noise, it’s hard not to think about the safety and comfort for future generations of Northland fans. If they put in a proper, high-quality terrace design, could we actually engineer something that keeps that raw, intense energy we all love?
Context beats a bare stat.
Funny, SweetAs's "sample of one game" cuts both ways aye, one creaky night proves nothing about safety either. Rebuild it and the first mud-soaked night will make new memories.
Context beats a bare stat.
Nick's got a point aye, one night proves nothing either way. I'd still take my chances in a stand that groans a bit over some shiny concrete bowl with all the atmosphere of a carpark. Half the fun of Whangārei away trips is standing somewhere that feels like it might fall down 😂
It's a lottery, not sport.