Southland's 43:12 demolition of Bay of Plenty says more than those
Honest question for the thread: the Stags who put 43 on Bay of Plenty at Rugby Park, or the Stags who leaked 55 to Taranaki away? Same jersey, two totally different sides it feels like. Which one turns up against Northland on Friday week? 🤔🔥
Heart with the team, head on pause.
StandsGuyLoyal, the honest answer is you've got two teams and the sample says the road version is the real one. One 43:12 at Rugby Park against a poor Bay of Plenty defence beats three away trips where they conceded 34, 55 and 47, and points for and against is a bigger sample than one good afternoon. If the Friday-week Northland side shows up like the home one, I'll happily eat my table, but a punter backing the away form has the numbers on their side. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
StandsGuyLoyal, the honest answer is you've got two teams and the sample says the road version is the real one. One 43:12 at Rugby Park against a poor Bay of Plenty defence beats three away trips where they conceded 34, …
So one decent home win somehow outweighs shipping 136 points in three away games? Remind me of your ROI on that logic, because the TAB certainly wouldn't 🤡
Any stat can be bent.
MaulMad, before anyone argues about weighting, define "the goods". One home win against a leaky Bay of Plenty versus 136 points shipped away in three weeks? The missing word here is consistency, and Southland haven't shown any. I'll believe it when I see it travel past Invercargill.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Watched enough Southland teams come through Rugby Park over the years to know one thing, young fellas: the home crowd makes everyone look a grade better. Back in my day we called it the Invercargill weather tax, visitors off the plane, cold southerly in their faces, and suddenly the Stags look like world beaters. That 43 on Bay of Plenty was real, but BoP defended like the gate was unlocked.
Thing is, over a long season it's the road trips that tell you who you are. Canterbury away and Taranaki away were hard watch, no sugarcoating it, 34 and 55 against is a lot of Sundays driving home quiet. I'd say the truth sits between the two versions, and the Northland game at home won't settle it either. Ask me again after they've had to front up somewhere hostile 😉
Reading the thread back, most here lean towards the away version being the real Stags, because 136 points shipped in three weeks (34, 55, 47) is a bigger sample than one sunny afternoon against a leaky Bay of Plenty defence. For the 43:12 counting for more, the counter is that Rugby Park at home flatters everyone, which SweetAs_Mad nailed from experience. My own table says context matters, but I'd want to see it travel before Friday week against Northland.
Do the math before you argue.
FrontRowArmy talking sample sizes now, eh, funny how the stats blokes only remember numbers when they suit the argument 😂 The sunny afternoon at Rugby Park counts for something, ask anyone who's stood on the hill with a few NZ$ on the line. I'd love to know though, did you actually back the Stags away or just crunch it after the fact?
Any stat can be bent.