Southland's place in the table is up for grabs after the recent
Right, since everyone's arguing about where Southland actually sit, I did what I always do and put the five rounds side by side.
1. Home vs Bay of Plenty (43-12, 13 Sept). Genuinely good. 43 points at Rugby Park, nobody saw that coming.
2. Away vs Counties Manukau (24-47, 6 Sept). Bad, but it opened the run, so at least the trend is readable.
3. Away vs Canterbury (21-34, 26 Sept). Losing to Canterbury on the road surprises nobody.
4. Away vs Taranaki (19-55, 20 Sept). That one I can't defend, hard out.
5. Home vs Northland (2 Oct). The whole table question rides on this one.
So my read, depends how you count it: home form says top four, away form says bottom three. Three away losses, one of them a horror show, cancels out one very good home win. Sit tight until Invercargill hosts Northland before anyone crowns or buries them. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Nah Nick, that Bay of Plenty game should be first on your list, not buried in the middle. 43-12 at Rugby Park?? Our lot turned up that day 🔥🙌
You don't abandon your own.
Nick, remind me of your ROI on these lists? 😏 You've got five rounds there and somehow Canterbury 34-21 and Taranaki 55-19 both got a polite little mention as numbers without anyone asking why we got pumped by them. Canterbury's hardly a small name to leave off, mate, that's the one that actually told us where we sit.
Stands is right about the Bay of Plenty game though, 43-12 at Rugby Park was the good day. Trouble is one good home afternoon and three away shellackings doesn't tell you a rank, it tells you the road form's a write-off. I put NZ$10 on them beating Northland next month mostly out of loyalty, someone talk me out of it 😂
Any stat can be bent.
FrontRow, give Nick a break mate, the list was fine. I've watched Southland sides get towelled up in Christchurch for forty years, 34-21 away to Canterbury is hardly a mystery, it's just a hard road trip. The Taranaki one stings more, but one good afternoon at Rugby Park doesn't fix a season either 😄
You've seen some teams where the early form is so poor it's like trying to start a cold fire in damp conditions. While those three road losses are definitely weighing on the record, I think focusing purely on the result ignores the scoring margins. If they are running within striking distance on those trips, the aggregate data on their performance under pressure is what matters more than just the final score line, mate.
Do the math before you argue.
Funny how everyone finally agrees on something. Reading the thread through, the forum consensus top reads: 1) the Bay of Plenty win at Rugby Park as the high point, 2) the away form as the biggest worry with Canterbury and Taranaki both beating us properly, 3) the Northland game on 2 October at home as the real test of where we sit. I'd keep my spreadsheet on hold until that one's done, small sample though. 📊
Numbers > vibes.
Sorry, dumb question maybe 😅 is the Northland game definitely at Rugby Park? Might head down for it, haven't made a home game yet. Cheers 🙏
New here, soaking it up.