Steaders smash Southland 47 then fold to Otago
That 50-pointer from Otago still hurts, took them on the line at home and never saw the arse coming. Hawke's Bay at Navigation Homes on 3 October, I'm leaning Counties Manukau win, they grinded out 22:19 away at Northland so they can scrap. Bet small though, NZ$20 max, bankroll is everything after last fortnight. 💸
Value over a big price 💸
I find the focus purely on the recent Northland victory misses the point entirely when assessing the actual defensive vulnerability of the squad.
The fact that they ground out the 22:19 win at Northland away from home certainly shows grit, and that's commendable, but we have to look at the wider defensive profile across this period. While the 47:24 score against Southland highlights a potent home offensive capability, the leakage when the opposition has the advantage is a major concern. Specifically, conceding fifty points against Otago at Navigation Homes just a few weeks prior shows there are massive weaknesses that can be exploited on their own turf.
If we are considering the probability of a Counties Manukau victory over Hawke's Bay on the 3rd of October, the statistical risk lies in that defensive fragility under sustained pressure, which the league has already demonstrated they can suffer from despite scoring runs.
Context beats a bare stat.
That Northland win is doing a lot of heavy lifting in this thread for my liking. One point win away from the bottom of the table, then a week earlier they're shipping 50 at home to Otago. That's the pattern I keep coming back to.
My read is Hawke's Bay on 3 October is the side of the line I want. I got burned taking Counties at Navigation Homes against Otago, never again off one gritty result. Went 47:24 over Southland, looked like world beaters, then folded the very next home game. The line moved and I still took the bad side. Lesson banked. I'll be on Hawke's Bay straight head-to-head, small stake, no multi leg on it. Bankroll is everything and this one smells like a trap either way, so I'm keeping the exposure thin. 🔥
SweetAs talking about heavy lifting when your last tip was the Otago line that got flattened by 29, that was comedy gold 😂 Jackal's already admitted the same wound. Anyone backing these mob off a one-point scrape against bottom-table Northland deserves whatever the TAB takes off them 🤡 Weirdly that makes me fancy Counties Manukau, my record's ruined enough anyway 💸
Show me your ROI first 😏
Honestly you just know with us, could smash someone or ship 50 the next week 😂 Dreaming on Hawke's Bay at Pukekohe, throwing NZ$10 on it purely on faith 🙌
You don't abandon your own.
I keep my own table on these guys and the split that jumps out is defence at Pukekohe: 47:24 put on Southland at home, then 50 shipped to Otago a fortnight later at the same ground. Small sample though, five games tells you their ceiling and floor and almost nothing in between. I could be wrong, but I'd take Counties Manukau on the line against Hawke's Bay rather than the straight win, the 22:19 scrap at Whangārei says they stay in tight ones even when the tank is empty. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
MaulTragic your NZ$10 on faith is braver than me 😱 we shipped 50 at Pukekohe two weeks ago mate, ah well, nowt to do 🤬
In the stands since I was a kid.
I treat the Otago game as an outlier before I treat it as a trend. A side that ships 50 at home one fortnight and then grinds out a 22:19 win at Northland the next week isn't a team with a defence problem, they're a team whose effort level swings with who's in front of them. Otago at Pukekohe had pedigree and pace, Hawke's Bay on 3 October profile closer to Southland than to Otago in my sample, and Counties found 47 points against that sort of opponent.
I could be wrong, but if the line is anywhere near single digits I'd take the home side. Small sample, five games, so size your stake like MaulTragic's NZ$10 of faith rather than a week's wages. 📊
Seriously Ruck9? You're treating a proper team like they're some kinda whackcoin, like one bad game ruins the whole thing. I don't give a toss about the swing, the guy can grind out 22:19 away to Northland, that's proof they can play tough when they gotta. Hawke's Bay is a bloody tough bunch too, but I reckon the forwards will smash them for the win 🔥💪🙌
RobFirstFive's table got me pulling up mine, and the thing I keep circling is what happens the week AFTER a loss. Auckland 43, Otago 50, and both times the following outing they showed up: 47 on Southland came straight after nothing worse than a standard round, sure, but the 22:19 at Northland landed a week after shipping 50. That bounce-back pattern is the only consistent signal in a five-game sample, and it points to them turning up on 3 October.
So my stake sits with Counties Manukau, modestly, call it NZ$20 rather than pride money, because Hawke's Bay away record isn't in front of us and the volatility here is brutal. If the TAB line is anywhere near single digits on the home side I'd look at it, but I'd want the win only, no minus. The floor case for them is real, the ceiling case is a coin toss. 📊
Numbers > vibes.
Ruck9 reckons Otago was an outlier but shipping 50 AT HOME is hard out the worst thing a side can do 🤬 and Hawke's Bay won't be mucking about like Southland did. Funnily enough we beat Northland 22:19 and Northland pushed everyone around before that, so what does that even prove? Tighthead's week-after theory's cute but I ain't staking my NZ$ on patterns, I'm staking it on pride, and our lot never make it easy either way 💪
Heart with the team, head on pause.
I find the focus on the single 50-point loss misses the actual statistical deviation in the sample set. When you look closely at the wins, the Southland result was a shootout that relied heavily on attacking volume, whereas the Northland win was far more restrictive. Given how close the Northland fixture was, I reckon the blueprint for the October match hinges on that tighter defensive structure, which seems like the more sustainable approach.
I keep my own tables 📊
These endless stats are confusing for sure. Just rely on the gut and the drive, nah? What does the heart actually tell you here? 🔥🙌
You don't abandon your own.
You’d think after seeing them blow 50 points at home they’d crumble, but they didn't. Their 22:19 win over Northland wasn't about the scoreboard volume; it was about the restrictive nature of that result, a solid defensive performance. That clip of grit against a quality pack is exactly the kind of disciplined rugby you need against Hawke's Bay on the 3rd.
Do the math before you argue.
Still learning all these stat terms, but the Northland game being tight and grindy makes sense to me. Do they struggle when teams just run at them non stop? Got a soft spot for Counties since my uncle's from Pukekohe so I'll be cheering anyway 😅 thanks SweetAsLocal for explaining the difference 🙏
Learn something new every day.
Good on ya BachMate, uncle from Pukekohe counts for plenty 😄 And yeah, they can be ground down if you run straight at them all arvo. Kept the forwards busy back in my day, works a treat.