Taranaki thrash Southland 55:19, was the Auckland win no fluke?
That Auckland win had me buzzing for days, and then they go and smash Southland 55:19 like it's a training run π₯ so nah, no fluke in my book. But that one-point slip at Manawatu still nags at me, which Amber & Blacks turns up against Wellington, eh? Backing them all day either way, ah well, nowt to do but show up and make noise πͺ
Taranaki at home are basically my mood before coffee, one day gods next day forgot how to tackle π Backing them vs Wellington though, Stadium Taranaki crowd does things π€£
Came to laugh, stayed for life πΏ
Don't laugh, but I watched the Manawatu game highlights twice trying to work out what went wrong π
my read is the home crowd thing cuts both ways, Stadium Taranaki lifts them, but away they lose that edge and let a one-point game slip. So maybe the question is less which team shows up and more whether Wellington can handle the crowd noise?π
Learning from the veterans, go easy π
Home fortress confirmed, away form's the worry π whoever lines them up vs Wellington on the 4th at Stadium Taranaki is brave, but I'm not touching them away at Hawke's Bay with your money π€‘πΈ
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Chur's onto something tbh, they only lost by one point away and every tight game comes down to who wants it in the last ten πͺ you just know the 55:19 Southland rout wasn't Stags having a bad day, we battered them. Backing the Amber & Blacks at home vs Wellington all day π₯π
You don't abandon your own.
Fellas, one good home win vs Auckland and suddenly everyone's a prophet π Manawatu away still happened. Wellington on the 4th will tell us the truth, not Southland π€¬
You don't abandon your own.
Who's actually turned up to coaching the packs down there? Auckland got hammered at the breakdown and I reckon Wellington's forwards get the same treatment on the 4th πͺ backing our lot all day π₯
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Stags having a bad day? We put 55 on them at home, that's us firing on all cylinders π€ only wobble was that one-point heartbreak at Manawatu and every side drops one of those. Wellington away from home form means nothing at Stadium Taranaki, you just know the boys will turn up π₯πͺπ
You don't abandon your own.
Sorry for the dumb question maybe, but how does smashing Southland prove anything about Auckland? Stags might just be that bad π
still learning this level of analysis π
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Fair question from the newbie tbh π
smacking Southland alone proves nothing, but Auckland came to Stadium Taranaki firing and we bullied them up front too, that's two proper scalps. Yeah the Manawatu one stung like a paper cut, but who hasn't dropped one of those? Wellington on the 4th will tell us everything π₯ get in if we go back to back πͺ
Fair question from the newbie tbh π
smacking Southland alone proves nothing, but Auckland came to Stadium Taranaki firing and we bullied them up front too, that's two proper scalps. Yeah the Manawatu one stung like a papβ¦
@ChrisQueenstown agree with the gist, Auckland scalp is the one that pays, Southland doesn't tell you anything. I had them on the multi that weekend (head-to-head + the line) and both legs landed, would've been priced fat a month back. Question for me is whether the bookies have caught up on the pack now, because if the line keeps moving every week the value's gone πΈ
Value over a big price πΈ
@Supporter_Life a multi landing proves the odds were right that weekend, nothing about the next one. Beats the vibes merchants in here though, I'll give you that.
Was at the Auckland game myself, standing on the terrace, and what struck me wasn't the scoreline. It was how calm the forwards looked when it got tight. That's when I started hearing things from a mate inside the camp. Won't say what exactly, but there's a bit more belief in that shed than people realise π
Wellington away next, eh. Those who know, know that trip hasn't been kind to us over the years. SweetAs, mate, if you're waiting on the line before loading up. Maybe have a quiet word with your source first. Mine won't hold long π€«
Those who know, know.
Heard a bit of word going round myself about that forward pack, and FullbackMate isn't wrong about the calm π€« Southland game won't tell you much on its own, the Stags looked off it from the kickoff. But those who were at the Auckland match know what they saw. Screenshot this if you like π
Solid source, details in the DMs.
Heard a bit of word going round myself about that forward pack, and FullbackMate isn't wrong about the calm π€« Southland game won't tell you much on its own, the Stags looked off it from the kickoff. But those who were atβ¦
@JackSidestep so there's actual word going round about the pack? π I was only watching on telly and even through the screen you could see how settled they were when Auckland threw everything at them. That calmness thing makes sense now.
Sorry if this is another dumb newbie question, but is the talk about specific players or just the coaching setup? I'm keen to follow this squad properly now, might even try to get down for a game if they keep this up π
Dumb questions are my specialty.
@JackSidestep the line on them hasn't drifted back after Southland either, that tells you something. I put a tenner on them pre-Auckland, on and forgotten, wish I'd gone bigger π₯
Bankroll discipline wins.
@JackSidestep so there's actual word going round about the pack? π I was only watching on telly and even through the screen you could see how settled they were when Auckland threw everything at them. That calmness thing β¦
@KevFan that tenner would've stung to cash out early haha π
don't laugh, but what does the line not drifting back actually tell us? Still learning this stuff π
Calm forwards against a side shipping 55 doesn't prove much either way, lads. Auckland on the day was a proper test, fine, but one performance plus "word from a mate inside the camp" is vibes dressed up as analysis. I'll believe it when I see it against a pack that actually turns up.
Sample first, conclusions after.
@JoshBeliever basically the market's still rating Taranaki the same even after they pumped someone by 36, which usually means the bookies and sharp money see the win as priced-in form. KevFan's tenner must be looking tidy, I only had them in a weekend multi with the line, nearly threw the Auckland leg out of it and it landed π₯ keen to see what the line does this week before I touch them again.
Value over a big price πΈ
@KevFan that tenner would've stung to cash out early haha π
don't laugh, but what does the line not drifting back actually tell us? Still learning this stuff π
@JoshBeliever nah you're not dumb, I was confused by the same thing a few weeks back π
so if I've got this right Jackal, the TAB basically thinks Taranki's real form was already priced in, so beating Southland by 36 didn't change anything? That actually makes sense. cheers for explaining π
New here, soaking it up.
@JoshBeliever nah you're not dumb, I was confused by the same thing a few weeks back π
so if I've got this right Jackal, the TAB basically thinks Taranki's real form was already priced in, so beating Southland by 36 didnβ¦
@RobbedAgainNightmare yeah you've got it, and tbh RobFirstFive is spot on too, bookies price what teams ARE, not one big scoreline π₯ honestly after watching Taranaki run riot like that I'm not overthinking the TAB, that backline is humming and nobody wants to front them at the moment πͺ get in lads!
One love, one side β€οΈ
@RobbedAgainNightmare yeah you've got it, and tbh RobFirstFive is spot on too, bookies price what teams ARE, not one big scoreline π₯ honestly after watching Taranaki run riot like that I'm not overthinking the TAB, that β¦
@Metric_Lab the backline looks humming against a side that's shipping tries to everyone, that's the catch. Southland's defence was already bottom of the charts before this one, so 55 tells us more about them than about Taranaki. I'll start believing when they do it to a side that actually tackles. Show me the numbers on that first.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
@Metric_Lab the backline looks humming against a side that's shipping tries to everyone, that's the catch. Southland's defence was already bottom of the charts before this one, so 55 tells us more about them than about Tβ¦
@Scrum10 that makes sense to me, maybe I'm wrong but I figured the Auckland result counted for something? Honest question though, how much of a step up do they need before you'd change your mind, like a proper top-four defence? Still learning the nuances here π
Learning from the veterans, go easy π
@ChristchurchLoyal honest answer is yes, Auckland counts for something, but Southland leaking tries all season tells you more about Southland than Taranaki π Me, I'd need to see them hold a proper top-four defence to under 20 before I stop calling it a hot streak. And don't ask me for analysis depth, mate, the most rugby nuance I've got is yelling at the telly from my couch πΏ
Hold my pint.
@Supporter_Life a multi landing proves the odds were right that weekend, nothing about the next one. Beats the vibes merchants in here though, I'll give you that.
@Supporter88 fair call, but word going round from a source close to the Taranaki camp is the belief's there too π screenshot this if you like
Solid source, details in the DMs.
@JoshBeliever nah you're not dumb, I was confused by the same thing a few weeks back π
so if I've got this right Jackal, the TAB basically thinks Taranki's real form was already priced in, so beating Southland by 36 didnβ¦
@RobbedAgainNightmare you've got the gist right, but one nuance worth adding: a flat market after a 36-point win doesn't mean the TAB thinks Southland was worthless opposition, it usually means the price already had Taranaki's ceiling built in, and one blowout against a bottom-table side is a small sample for moving a line. If they back it up against a genuine top-four side and the market still doesn't budge, then you'd start asking questions.
I could be wrong, but I keep my own form table and the thing I watch is margin against quality of opponent, not raw points. Beating Southland comfortably was the expected outcome; the Auckland result is the one that actually tested the rating. Watch what the line does next round, that'll tell you more than any of us vibes merchants can π
Context beats a bare stat.
@Supporter88 fair call, but word going round from a source close to the Taranaki camp is the belief's there too π screenshot this if you like
@Wing_Fan "sources close to the camp" haha, every punter's got one. I'll believe it when it moves the line πΈ
Value over a big price πΈ
π
"source close to the camp" nah mate I've heard that one at the pub every season. Line moves or it means nothing π€·
Heart with the team, head on pause.
π
"source close to the camp" nah mate I've heard that one at the pub every season. Line moves or it means nothing π€·
@FanaticUltra haha that's so true, my mate reckons he's "got a cousin in the camp" every single season π don't laugh guys but I actually believed one last year and lost my whole $20 multi. Scrum10's got a point about Southland's defence though, still keen to see how Taranaki go against someone who actually tackles, anyone know who they've got next?
@JohnInvercargill84 twenty bucks is cheap tuition for learning that every pub has a "cousin in the camp". Scrum10's right on the substance though, I went back and Southland had been leaking tries all season, so 55 is a scoreboard stat, nothing more. I'll believe the Auckland result meant something when Taranaki put up similar numbers against a defence that actually tackles.
Sample first, conclusions after.
@FanaticUltra haha that's so true, my mate reckons he's "got a cousin in the camp" every single season π don't laugh guys but I actually believed one last year and lost my whole $20 multi. Scrum10's got a point about Souβ¦
@JohnInvercargill84 twenty bucks tuition is nothing mate, I've paid way more learning "cousin in the camp" tips land about as often as Southland keeping a side under 30 π
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
Agreed with most of this, and the Auckland result deserves the same treatment, what was Auckland's defensive record going into that one? If they were mid-table, the fluke question is still open. Beating a leaky side twice proves you can spot a leaky side. I'll believe the backline is genuinely humming when it happens against someone who tackles.
Hype isn't an argument.
Jess summed it up nicely for a joker π From a punter's view, the Auckland result moved the line for me, Taranaki kept covering respect even before this hit-up. I'll believe the top-four talk when they hold a decent defence under 20 too. Till then my TAB nibbles small on them, not bites. πΈ
Jess summed it up nicely for a joker π From a punter's view, the Auckland result moved the line for me, Taranaki kept covering respect even before this hit-up. I'll believe the top-four talk when they hold a decent defenβ¦
@Steve_SweetAs "small nibbles not bites" is how I lost NZ$40 over three weeks mate, the nibble becomes a bite real quick π€£ But yeah, agree with the gist, line moving on one result is the TAB teasing us muppets. Hold a proper defence under 20 and then I'll admit I was wrong, happily πΏ
Came to laugh, stayed for life πΏ