Tate McDermitt is already our most important player and it's not even
Funny how one night at Ballymore rewrites half the forum's memory π McDermott's been electric since he grabbed the nine jersey, no argument from me there. But the punter in me put $20 on the TAB line last season expecting the forwards to get steamrolled, and the boys up front turned that into a cheeky win. Carry the club? Sure, when the pack gives him front-foot ball he looks like a genius. Wait for the fanboys to pile in, but someone's got to say it: underrate Fraser's work and you're kidding yourselves π
Show me your ROI first π
One night at Ballymore and suddenly everyone's a convert? Aye, McDermott's been sharp, quick pass, good snipes, no argument there. But "most important player and it's not even close" needs more than one hot evening and pub consensus to convince me.
Fraser's pack has been doing the dirty work for seasons now, and Tate only looks electric because the forwards are winning him front-foot ball. Swap the nine, keep the pack, and I reckon we'd still be competitive. Do it the other way round and see how pretty the passing game looks off slow rubbish. I'll believe the "carrying the club" line when he does it against the Crusaders in Christchurch, not on a friendly night at Ballymore.
Hype isn't an argument.
Skeenptic till you see him live mate π€ I was at that Ballymore night and the place went MENTAL every time Tate touched it, quick as anything π₯ Everyone bangs on about Fraser's pack doing the hard yards, good on them, but who's actually setting the tempo? Heart says it all, Tate's carrying us, ah well, nowt to do πΊπͺ
Queenstown51 has a point about one night, but the tempo argument holds up across the whole run since Tate took the nine jersey. My table keeps attack speed and ruck arrival rates every round, and the quickness off his service is what makes Fraser's pack look so dominant, the forwards get their go-forward because the ball comes out before the defence resets. Dig a bit deeper on the tape and you'll see most of those big tight five carries happen off fast, clean McDermott ball. π He's the engine, full stop.
I keep my own tables π
Back in my day the halfback just fed the scrum and kept quiet π Tate runs the whole show now, young fellas don't know how good they've got it.
Back in my day the halfback just fed the scrum and kept quiet π Tate runs the whole show now, young fellas don't know how good they've got it.
@SweetAs_Mad half the reason I chuck him in my try scorer leg most weekends is exactly that, he touches everything. Punters notice who runs the show pretty quick, the TAB knows it too, his markets firm up faster than any forward's π you only live once though.
Bankroll discipline wins.
Still thinking about that one night, are we? Honestly, the sustained dominance heβs shown since then makes the skeptics look like theyβre watching the back of the ball. Heβs carrying the load, mate.
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Still thinking about that one night, are we? Honestly, the sustained dominance heβs shown since then makes the skeptics look like theyβre watching the back of the ball. Heβs carrying the load, mate.
@LockLegend nah he's fair dinkum carrying them tbh, you only gotta watch him sniping round the fringes to see it π₯
Watched him live when the Reds came over here and he was in everything, every ruck, every call. And yeah the pack gives him front-foot ball but plenty of nines get good ball and still butcher it. Tate doesn't πͺ we'd take him tomorrow, no shame in saying it π
In the stands since I was a kid.
Ask the Caxton crowd to split the bill between Tate's tempo and Fraser's pack and you'll get a scrap every round, which tells you something. My own tallies say the ruck service got sharper once he had the nine jersey, but the forwards earned him that front-foot ball in the first place. Honest answer? Depends how you count it, and I'm still counting.
Context beats a bare stat.