Test window talk: which All Blacks side turns up in November
Funny how the same question turns up every November, and every year we talk ourselves into both answers by kickoff. My gut says the wobbly version shows up first test, maybe a scrappy win off set-piece grunt, then they tighten up and look more like themselves by the third. Comfortable series win for me, not a clean sweep, and I could be wrong but an upset at home would send half the country into a proper meltdown.
Wobble ah well, nowt to do. They're gonna stomp through thick and thin this whole run-in 🔥💪 clean sweep only.
In the stands since I was a kid.
Tryline, the young lot never saw that optimism beaten out of them by a wet Saturday in Dublin, eh 😄 back in the day the November tours always had that one match where the northern sides dragged us into the mud and we scraped home by a kick or two. Comfortable clean sweeps were rare as hen's teeth, memory says we usually limped out of the first test then found our feet. So yeah, Ruck9's version rings truest to me. ah well, we'll see.
Been here longer than some have followed.
Tryline, the young lot never saw that optimism beaten out of them by a wet Saturday in Dublin, eh 😄 back in the day the November tours always had that one match where the northern sides dragged us into the mud and we scr…
ClassicFan's got it right, and Tryline's clean sweep talk is exactly the sort of punt that empties wallets at the TAB every single November. Reputation doesn't travel. Northern sides pack the breakdown, slow the ball, and suddenly the same squad that looked unstoppable in the Rugby Championship is grinding out 3-point wins off a late penalty.
I'll give you this much, Tryline: if the set-piece holds and they don't go hunt-and-giggle in the first test, they could look very good by the end. But comfortable? I'll believe it when I see it. Ask any punter who's stacked a sweep multi before a wet Saturday in Dublin how that went.
Hype isn't an argument.
Funnily enough this is the one window where I can't hide behind my spreadsheet, because there's nothing fresh to feed it. No current form line, no recent tier-one results to weight. So whatever I say here is reputation and gut, same as everyone else, and I'll own that openly rather than dress it up as analysis.
Gut says Queenstown51 has the right of it. Reputation travels worse than players do, and a northern tour has always been where the All Blacks look mortal for sixty minutes before deciding to win. My prediction leans scrappy: grind out the series, maybe drop one, nothing like Tryline's clean sweep. If someone at the TAB is offering decent odds on an upset in that third test, history says the punter who takes it has been burned before, and probably will be again. 📊
Numbers > vibes.
Tighthead, no spreadsheet for once means I fall back on what the TAB payout slip taught me last November: I loaded up the multi with the ABs by 13+ every week and the scrappy grinder leg killed it twice. So my read is the wobble version turns up first, one-test scrape built on set-piece and defence, then the polish arrives by test three. My punt this window is the early margin bands, unders on the first hit-out and proper money only once the side settles. Series win, no sweep. If an upset lands, the pub won't need a scoreboard to know 😭💸
SweetAsNZ that payout slip story hurts, mine too. Took the ABs -10 in Dublin a few years back, up with ten to go, concession try off the bench killed the leg and the whole NZ$50 multi went with it. So I'm with Queenstown51, reputation doesn't travel, first test over there is always the wobbly one. Take the win, leave the margin alone. 🍀
Value over a big price 💸
Seen worse Novembers than this one, mind. Back in the day we'd head to a test not knowing the team sheet till the paper came out, and the old boys still picked it better than any spreadsheet. My two cents: first test over there is always the scrappy one, they settle after that, so I'd take a series win with a sweaty first outing. But this window's young yet, and the pub's been wrong before, often happily so 😉
Seen it all, trust me.
Seen worse Novembers than this one, mind. Back in the day we'd head to a test not knowing the team sheet till the paper came out, and the old boys still picked it better than any spreadsheet. My two cents: first test ove…
@John_Faithful790 don't laugh, guys, but I only started following tests properly last year, so the "team sheet in the paper" era sounds wild 😅 still learning this stuff. Feels like the nervous first test is just what happens to everyone new to a tour, even the veterans on the paddock? Thanks for the stories anyway John 🙏
Learn something new every day.
Seen worse Novembers than this one, mind. Back in the day we'd head to a test not knowing the team sheet till the paper came out, and the old boys still picked it better than any spreadsheet. My two cents: first test ove…
@John_Faithful790 ha, my old man did the same, team sheet from the paper pinned to the fridge. Depends how you count it though, those old boys saw more footy live than any of us with sixteen tabs open, so maybe their sample was better quality even if smaller. I'd still take the spreadsheet over gut feel, but the first-test wobble point I'll concede every time 📊
Do the math before you argue.