The 2012-13 back-to-back Chiefs still had a better spine than this
Put me at the TAB and I'd take the old spine every day of the week π Collison, Cane, Meek ran that 2012-13 pack like a machine, nobody in the current forward group scares a return leg like those blokes did. Half the crowd here's wearing nostalgia goggles after a few jugs at the pub before kickoff, and I get it, but come on.
Anyone want to tell me who in today's pack gets near Cane at his peak? Didn't think so. Laughable really π€‘πΈ
Show me your ROI first π
Careful with the TAB talk, Napier, you'd be laying odds on blokes who haven't scrummed since 2013 against a current pack nobody's actually measured them against. Collison and Meek were class, sure, but nostalgia does funny things after a few pre-match pints. Name me one metric from those seasons that the current tight five clearly fails, and I'll take the argument seriously; until then it's just fond memories dressed up as analysis.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Nostalgia goggles?? nah Rotorua, I watched those back-to-back sides lift trophies with my own eyes π€ Cane was hitting like a wrecking ball and Meek never took a backwards step, you think this pack strikes fear into anyone? I'll back our current lot through thick and thin mate, but come on πͺπ₯
Heart with the team, head on pause.
StandsGuy, I sat through every minute of both title runs and I'd still hedge: the Cane-Collison-Meek spine was more proven, sure, but this current pack hasn't had the sample size to be dismissed either. Small sample though, one rough return leg and we all downgrade them, which is exactly the nostalgia trap Napier's milking. I could be wrong, but I'd want to see this lot over a full season before I hand the TAB money to the 2013 blokes. π
Context beats a bare stat.
I was a kid watching those back-to-back runs from Gisborne so maybe I'm wrong, but Cane hit like nobody today π
can someone explain how the current pack even compares? cheers π
New here, soaking it up.
Nick lad, anyone who watched 2013 knows Cane was already a machine π would happily put NZ$50 at the TAB on the old spine still, sure thing, mate.
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Blokes keeping picking on a kid from Gisborne, that's low tbh π€ Nick's right to ask, answer him instead of slinging NZ$50 multis around like tough guys πͺ
You don't abandon your own.
Nostalgia goggles ON, some of you lot π€ Cane was unreal, no one's arguing that, but this current pack has been battering teams up front all season, where was the "scary" bit in that scrum domination against the Crusaders? Nick mate, don't let the old heads spook you, go watch the last few matches and judge for yourself π
LockLegend, keep your NZ$50, because punting on memory is the easiest way to lose money at the TAB π 2012-13 was class, we all know, get in! But this spine is STILL growing, give them two proper seasons and I'd back them against anyone in a return leg. Backs the boys π₯πͺ
One love, one side β€οΈ
@Metric_Lab nah you're talking sense. Cane was the best flanker I've watched live but that current pack has been carrying my multis all season, scrum penalties alone have paid for a few Friday nights at the pub. I'd still take the old spine to close out a tight one though. That's where the odds always shorten on finals teams.
Value over a big price πΈ
Metric_Lab has it right. Cane's tackling was elite, sure, but nostalgia does the rest. Current pack's scrum work against the Crusaders speaks for itself. I'll believe the "better spine" claim when someone actually sources it.
Hype isn't an argument.
My IT mate reckons my memory is like our scrum. Mostly reliable π I'd back the old spine, but that Crusaders demolition was decent eh πΏ
Came to laugh, stayed for life πΏ
My IT mate reckons my memory is like our scrum. Mostly reliable π I'd back the old spine, but that Crusaders demolition was decent eh πΏ
@JohnNapier1976 that scrum line is gold π honest question from me though, is "spine" just the halfback, first five and hooker? Saw it earlier and got a bit lost π
New here, soaking it up.
My IT mate reckons my memory is like our scrum. Mostly reliable π I'd back the old spine, but that Crusaders demolition was decent eh πΏ
@JohnNapier1976 that Crusaders demolition has already paid my Friday beers twice over, so current pack gets my respect πΊ But on the spine alone I'd still take the 12-13 vintage, they'd decide a tight one with a boot or an intercept, that's what wins you playoff markets. I put a modest multi on the current lot for the line plus margin band, decent odds, holding so far, whether it lands comes down to whoever closes better, and that's where the old spine was ruthless. RobbedAgainNightmare: spine is basically 9-10-12 plus your hooker and lock, the core that never leaves the field.
Value over a big price πΈ
Honest answer? My TAB multis on both eras say they'd be bloody close, and that's about the only verdict I'll give π
Cane's loose forwardspeak was elite but this current pack's scrum haul against the Crusaders landed for me at decent odds, so they've earned some credit too. Call it a pub argument that stays open till someone beats them both πΊ
@Maul_Mate nah fair point, that pack never stops hitting π
still learning this stuff but grit only gets you so far if the old spine was smarter, eh?
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Nah, you r all getting too bogged down in tactics... the current pack is just pure grit tbh. They take a massive hit up there and keep going. π€―π₯
@Maul_Mate grit pays the bills most weeks, but it doesn't win you a tight playoff line. The old spine knew how to close a game out, and that's what my multi needs in the last 20, not another hit-up into traffic. Put $20 on the vintage lot any day ππΈ
Value over a big price πΈ