Tin Hearth
22 Nov, 7:32 pm Log in Sign up
Highlanders

The 2015 Highlanders were our greatest side ever

club debate Highlanders Supporters Highlanders 16 posts ·103 views ·Posted: 19 Oct 2026, 7:58 pm ·Updated: 11 Nov 2026, 10:20 pm
NA Napier_Legend1980 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 457 posts 19 Oct 2026, 7:58 pm
That semi against the Chiefs at Forsyth Barr, walking out of there hoarse, was worth more to me than any 1998 highlights reel ever will. Anyone saying the old era was deeper: remind me of your ROI on that argument? 😏 The 2015 mob actually got it done when it counted.
Show me your ROI first 😏
Reply Quote
QU Queenstown51 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 483 posts 19 Oct 2026, 11:39 pm
ROI on memories, is that the best you've got? Hoarse throat counts as evidence now? 1998 won a title too. I'll believe "deepest ever" when someone shows the squad list.
Hype isn't an argument.
Reply Quote
TR Tryline_Mate Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 640 posts 20 Oct 2026, 2:12 am
Was at that semi with my old man, still get chills thinking of the noise 🔥 2015 got it DONE, champs in Sydney the same year, hard out. 98 legends were magic tbh but you just know that squad was deeper, ah well, nowt to do 🙌
Highlanders team
In the stands since I was a kid.
Reply Quote
RO RobFirstFive Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 735 posts 20 Oct 2026, 4:08 am
I was 21 in '98 and went to most of the home games that season, so I've got a soft spot for that mob, but I'd back the 2015 squad on depth without much hesitation. Look at the two lists side by side and the 2015 side had starters and bench guys who'd all been through Super Rugby finals campaigns before, plus they won two knockout games away from home pressure in the same season, capped off in Sydney. The '98 title came in a very different competition structure and a smaller squad pool, which muddies any straight comparison. The honest caveat is that "depth" depends how you count it. If you're measuring bench quality and injuries absorbed across a season, 2015 wins comfortably in my book. If you count All Blacks per capita in the starting XV, '98 might edge it, small sample though. I could be wrong on the exact splits, I'd have to dig through my old spreadsheets, but the Chiefs semi at Forsyth Barr was the night that depth actually showed.
Context beats a bare stat.
Reply Quote
SW SweetAs_Mad Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 784 posts 20 Oct 2026, 8:57 am
Saw both eras live, and I'll say this quietly: the '98 mob had more magic, the 2015 mob had more men. Both champions, no shame in either 😉
Reply Quote
CH ChrisQueenstown Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 283 posts 20 Oct 2026, 12:50 pm
My old man reckons depth is just a fancy word for whoever lifted the trophy 😂 I've watched the '98 tape more times than I'll admit and yes they were magic, but half of you arguing for them weren't even born yet tbh 🤬 SweetAs_Mad actually nailed it, more magic vs more men, I'll give you that much. Chills at Forsyth Barr don't lie though 🔥
Reply Quote
JO John_Faithful790 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 481 posts 20 Oct 2026, 1:08 pm
i always think back to how gritty the 2015 lads were throughout the whole season, even when things went wrong. you could shift the lineup a bit and they'd still hold their nerve, which is something the young lot never saw that in the older setups. the magic from '98 is lovely stuff, i get that, but pure, hard-nosed consistency is what wins the tougher battles. 😉
Highlanders fans
Seen it all, trust me.
Reply Quote
RO RotoruaLoyal Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 455 posts 20 Oct 2026, 2:43 pm
I'll give the 2015 crowd this much: rotating blokes in and out during Super Rugby and still turning up in the semis and the final says something about the squad that highlights footage never will. I sat in the Stand at Forsyth Barr that July night against the Chiefs and the bench made the difference late, that's depth you can actually point at. What I want defined before I sign off on "greatest ever" is whether we're counting the title or the whole season, because those aren't the same argument.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Reply Quote
TI Tighthead Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 193 posts 20 Oct 2026, 6:04 pm
SweetAs_Mad hit the nail on the head with the magic vs men line, I've been turning that over since I read it. My own tally sheet from 2015 says the same thing: blokes like Osborne and Nasi Manu coming off the bench and the intensity not dropping a rung. You could rotate the pack and the scrum still held. That's depth in the real sense. One caveat though, and I say this as someone who keeps the numbers for a living: the 2015 squad was built for a 17-week format with a big bench doing heavy lifting, while the '98 side played through a different structure entirely. Small sample if you try to compare them head to head, honestly. Both champs, and the Chiefs semi still gives me chills. My dad was up from Invercargill for that one and I've never heard him that loud.
Numbers > vibes.
Reply Quote
SC ScrumKiwi Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 241 posts 20 Oct 2026, 6:52 pm
Bit rich arguing depth with blokes who remember '98 through rose-tinted beer goggles 😏 Tighthead's right about the bench though, Manu and Osborne kept the hitout at full noise. I put actual NZ$ on us that final through the TAB and even the line fancied us, which says what the comp thought of that squad. 2015, easy, fight me 😂
Show me your ROI first 😏
Reply Quote
ST StandsGuyLoyal Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 542 posts 21 Oct 2026, 6:16 pm
Nah, you can't even compare depth like that. Were those '98 lads just lucky to have peak form every single season? 2015 proved they could still grind out massive wins even when the rotation was nuts, how can you say that doesn't count for something 🔥🙌?
Highlanders goal celebration
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Reply Quote
CL ClassicFan Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 485 posts 22 Oct 2026, 5:25 pm
StandsGuy, grinding out wins with rotation is impressive, I'll grant you, but depth and luck aren't the same animal. '98 never needed half a squad rotated like Jamie Joseph was shuffling a deck, they just turned up and belted people week after week. The young lot never saw those Carisbrook nights, so I'll forgive the rose-tinting going the other way, ah well, we'll see 😄
Been here longer than some have followed.
Reply Quote
SU Supporter88 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 339 posts 23 Oct 2026, 2:54 am
Nah, you just can't beat the brute force of the '98 lads. They always felt like a proper, unstoppable machine.
Reply Quote
NI NickBreakdown1982 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 283 posts 23 Oct 2026, 5:59 am
Brute force against tactical depth, it makes sense that both sides have valid arguments for greatness there.
Context beats a bare stat.
Reply Quote
SU Supporter_Life Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 208 posts 2 Nov 2026, 4:38 am
Watched that '15 side live more than a few times and they just kept landing when the line looked too wide. '98 were animals, but I'd back 2015 to cover any spread you gave me 😄
Value over a big price 💸
Reply Quote
FA FaithfulUltra Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 18 posts 11 Nov 2026, 10:20 pm
Nah '98 for me, watched them belting teams at the ground as a young fella, proper feared them 😤 '15 were class but... eh, still can't call them our best 💪
One love, one side ❤️
Reply Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up — it's quick.